Narmada Prasad Mohar v. State Bank of India

DRT4 Sept 2024MA/48/2024

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No..

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
Tq.q. +8/2024
04.09.2 24 Grril{osqTd ft+ftffiqcr.s 3lfu{fiTI sm-.qrfr d-ndfrrfrslm"cTfi erkq-mit
1.vqq^qeTo\fumqerqrennqq3rd*. 5180/2024^q{Sqr^rl-I[ItI 2.erw^q?T3i-s-dtm-{fu-qrr-qT Bt 3.Gnfq-6^qeTifuiro-07.08.2024o)^trrsr 22(fr)3l-r.S.fr.'f,dderqqm[5vrri^qd frhtr sniq{Es GrBFirrdTdfi=dr$-{ 3TffiETflfr0-wc-d gfu	E=iq{
467/ zorzdet-o.oilF^gtrsqt6*-q^q-trqr u-m<t-5q\rq orqt^q)fuovo ^ce+qffq ftir6rz.ro.zorso)^slqn<Tm^qritg rrgofuurwTB,^q)q?rqEEqT^Grqfuqrfu-d ili tfuaq^erqrftti^qdt^y.ro3rd-qn u-rgo fu-+rtt 4.u-tgofrri^.dft-mq^{srqtGil-i{qoT} qqrqsf,{qrfrqeiErrtu-t3ofrr+r^qrgor dr
5.r*go fuo<erqrenieqoT5qenwt o1d.q.767/2017t^{qFrarft,T,T/cnneoqvr} Cnfudfrtrflft-{rfi^{rc.0s.2017er<qorfta} €,fu-florqur^{GIBf,{qA onAqrftfl-fi'oo.os.} zorsd^3tgllx$flzit-{^qad^{qrtqqt +trfl} mTRTdotrrll^rrrlT,frrd^{ci-ffi.rtqTil}Rd qqrqRqad fue-flfuf,{uT3nd-{o-Turd^-lrs tr-frd-drt,+Ene-6rRrd$n,ffi^frw frenileo,r"rolrqo,^3{zrqlsral66^qfro qrrmTftl-& g{r d^qnqqt@ti

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

PAGE No

¶7

Narmada Prasad Mohar versus State Bank of India — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶8

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE OROER 6.3rrdq-6seToT^3In6?T{B^O1q-rfrqn q-qq{ftGrffigRrffi {If,rTR=il-6 12.04.2024nBao1^.r$,nq^{3ntr{ficeit-fi} erffii drrq-dfuqr,ffi gRIqE 3{sfl€sftrqr^rrqrQnfu3lff<-6-Turo-rd{ \r6'rsuc^{q-ffYrR'rd ernmqr+-f,flftlql} qrhrr,frtdq-6qdrzlrTrIIot,oeil6fr-f,-{fr etsq-qcmB^qfi-dE<sup>g_+t11qvfr srrf<-6^qai^qrfuoiqqrqzoszz/zozqs{ql fuqr,frrdftqio.os.oe.zoz4d^qrqtrdfuql ir 7.3nil{6^qeTor6arqBfufuTrfi30.04. 2oz4tqerrn<-6^qqTq-1frotffi t^3r{F-a e)vq@)fus 1e^qalfl-frofeilq{edrddRrc q,r+qs@flqqlflerqdgnr rtqqfiqr^q frTlorffir^q-(rqo1T$^afrt^gqeilEr-ttwfuoq
flrrTa-{r-qafrftuso-{urwsiuwEi qrtor3r-dfufu-qrtt B.3ffiril{fitoasfuMf,E6iltl^tr{gdo{ orril({oTmro-rdgsorqkfr^.r$t^q,1 fu{ifi12.i0.2018al^{qrRilGftqsTreYrd}
fuqrmgdfrfuq^{qcr-{oTcnqfuqrD-a}B^t
dq'lrT oetdfuf,qte-6{uTtrsgf,93ilt,
s{fu{d'dq.3rilfi^(d.q.)zozlzotz^ti
qffi{qdeifrqsrf,qdwvftngdsro
t+trfltsTrqr,o<sup>qorgq.frfrtrY5q"rfr sPfd^qddergw^e11
e.s-rtdq-6seTo-t^qdfi^o-t-+t^fuqra
qffio-qrfiaorclEflsrqrrEC{r^Qn,
fttq-dfrqqfrtqi^qcnRI;IorrqT^qrclQn,
fu-S^qffioqie'r^qq3dfrqqtfi
rtrnfu-d1Tr-{r Tf,rRTdof r$fr,t^.fi

¶13

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	qfuqrffrtol sqRemr-€t gq,e-qotrisrfuirfi 12.10.2018d ergwsffi-,T'r^SfrT€\q; qeftqoTffio1rrTqxTficei-q3n+cT ftqrfirz.to.zota^{qfrofu-qr rrqr,}ffi entrn qr{qdqrruq-{ifr-f,frtqr^.rqrtI 10.or+ffifiseTor^qdfi^36-6e5B^fu qr1sroIPmTftErTfuil-fi27.03.201so)^tft iftrqgdsrod^qrwqrtBflw+fs^nfuo ftrqr^{rrqian,q\qrqs}{fr^eirqr,aqqqft qffi iflIdlro-trisr-toforffi yf,q&t-qwterifuoo-siorotqqfu-+tt ffi g-{dprne-6rRTdof.r$gq d(C?qlcl ffi rp+<rft=iroe.o4.zo24^nfr--dCd,^fu-s wsnEocasqRara^{gen,wofuvqfrqdw} T{^{tnfr(+eqqrftore}iqrT3lfun?r"l fu-qriqrBt 11.Grrrn<-f,se{or^3lF-f,el-ctfu^nft{{d qrd6zotqflel..rct/zotzofFrffi tlergqBe*rattgso-xqGnilq-r^qsTgrt u-rgofua<flqr^Gr-t{qrffi drqr€ttt
	12.^gqrGIE-m-{oro<sup>fuf,Eqe+qrd qe=Iqt
	tgli^qgBfu^{"cqr3nA-{frssTo-t3T1.4{ul}
	qqqTfitq-iqqT^qrr+qt3ltiffi^qeroJ ErFigXo^{sna-fiel..rct/zotzd o-rffi} q,-Tr1r{rq-{ilfi-f,r-€lgGTr'let.qd sffi.r'T,^q\gflfrEq^{Gnilfin 3ilt<filTT} t,^er.q.o1orffi t^or{REe}vq^qrftqR 3nnffirTuro]et.q.rct/zotttstBf,^qfi qsftqFPfqRqis12.10.201aqrsrt^q-r1ft Grerf,rft^gxriBaffi qaqrft{iorz.o+. zozqdqnqqtgurBr

¶17

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER 13.frhqoTrilfidr+relrrgofun^.ri srffistddq.767/2017of3ntyr^qFd-rtC o1^qqrFraqftiif,J-qt,fuq-derf*+xR=no 06.0e.2017o)^oil'd-dlfito i^qrsrg^oil{.S.fr vqe^1ee3d^{3trncgftu-o-r"rrtgofuut,} M^qffiqqofffi srodcltaq1) Rrrfi22.o1.zoraofsqReTfr&+eilmo frrnTnrfuiro22.01.20183TrtcT^qkotd
sr1qncffioqiordrlr{rosGIaItf,Es frfrETe-m-{urnenileo-.r.rdcrqnfudffi srcF^qlq-{{r€t3rrff,^qraqffio-qio+ot crfi^qqrTE{
g"r-flifudffi t{-d{r fur-roe.o4.2oz4
([email protected].,/s)mrfiagen,fu{rotuftq< Grrd-{6veriu-tgofuqrtt
1s.rrnT27^q{rrIser+q'f,eatlsqrql Gilil+orrurdfu[dwftt,ererta^gs3rBf,-{ur Errr^entqorrqo1^ei.q.767/zo17dft-{ro 22.01.2018o)sqRem6titgnfuda1^.r$ fu srin^ge'frfrqe-fi-{urdorico.r"rw affif,Elifroqqxunatud.ftr^-{fusro qrqtrq€ig{r 16.illvqtr-qund^g*rerf,te-dfr-f,fltB ofs{fr^.rdwflIfrsrffianr ift-o ot
T{ffi ratmrft=iroP.04.20243ir}iloTur
o)slRE\T$,olafdsi.q.rct/zot fr
orffi +drqnifudo1^.rTisttn^qfi
Gril{orrqo<sup>qlwg{d.ft,fuEi^g{T

¶27

DATE 23.07.2024^{o\u-rgd fo-qrerl,ffigo:fltN{} dfuqTI^{qrq-ftq-s@q-qmqgrgrqrtrf,} etirrn=no^{053r'Rflzozal3flil{fiqet6</sup> "^{.t-,n ot{RTlerf,drtrErqr{to1'rgB'} 3iarfa{fl^{3rts'f,{urC gsfrfrqtrf,r"TS} PEod^{qqqttwolqr<sfl-l-dTqforoo:} fuitkdo-rcrt^t 21.n<sup>qRsllnq-6qeri wnfr3IErf,rfram} stqfrEs^{dqrtqqt VrslBolvrd go} qefi-qoifrqeiresroTf,rqdi^ft{1oso'o+' zoz+t^soFfl{^{d3r<Rqr+fi-qsa -qlql c{q} dsqa^{erqi-f,fu{i630-05'2024(oqrfufil} s-rgdFrfi+fr,^{q ftxftfiq1n5fa6e} d^{q{rq{g-q-r{dr 6-1QtlT3II-}@ sq{o-{} e-f,ar^erT,frtd^{fu{w2307.2024 @'rqrfr=mT} u-qoof^{.r{,sEq 3sft;+rd sier{€tefi} Ts^{qrrft-qsaqlqrdqd griiqqqrrq} ryqrfrfrqqi^{3nil<-o.qe+o\of{frIlqd-dT} " aof^{.r{t,aqAffiqfuflqot} r{6qdr$-6^{3ffiesTq€tfttflqIlltnclrI} ,r1,.",t<, qeTifuf,qrqrfr;i^q,dtg DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
sqderc-€t+i^{otftsofrd qrqsFF3i-ff1}
dffif,Ei^?fi,qsfu{rr^etn{ulfrs< qdqq-rrvtdIift-f,of^.dM gr-fislq-s

DATE
23.07.2024^{o\u-rgd fo-qrerl,ffigo:fltN{}
dfuqTI^{qrq-ftq-s@q-qmqgrgrqrtrf,}
etirrn=no^{053r'Rflzozal3flil{fiqet6</sup>
"^{.t-,n ot{RTlerf,drtrErqr{to1'rgB'}
3iarfa{fl^{3rts'f,{urC gsfrfrqtrf,r"TS}
PEod^{qqqttwolqr<sfl-l-dTqforoo:}
fuitkdo-rcrt^t
21.n<sup>qRsllnq-6qeri wnfr3IErf,rfram}
stqfrEs^{dqrtqqt VrslBolvrd go}
qefi-qoifrqeiresroTf,rqdi^ft{1oso'o+'
zoz+t^soFfl{^{d3r<Rqr+fi-qsa -qlql c{q}
dsqa^{erqi-f,fu{i630-05'2024(oqrfufil}
s-rgdFrfi+fr,^{*q ftxftfiq1n5fa6e}
d^{q{rq{g-q-r{dr 6-1QtlT3II-}@ sq{o-{}
e-f,ar^erT,frtd^{fu{w2307.2024 @'rqrfr=mT}
u-qoof^{.r{,sEq 3sft;+*rd sier{€tefi}
Ts^{qrrft-qsaqlqrdqd griiqqqrrq}
ryqrfrfrqqi^{3nil<-o.qe+o\of{frIlqd-dT}
" aof^{.r{t,aqAffiqfuflqot}
r{6qdr$-6^{3ffiesTq€tfttflqIlltnclrI}
,r1,.",t<,
qeTifuf,qrqrfr;i^q,dtg
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER

sqderc-€t+i^{otftsofrd qrqsFF3i-ff1}

dffif,Ei^?fi,qsfu{rr^etn{ulfrs<
qdqq-rrvtdIift-f,of^.dM
gr-fislq-s

¶32

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	Tfr g{	EtrFnqolBfr-{qoirilffirnlo)vq q.07/202sctsnqlq.rnEMq t anqrfu-f,orior6tgsPddentm+€lcrdrt 2s.{qfuonil{f,rfqo{fttgf,€srcnd qrtqqtfrfu{rs22.01.2018o)BqRerf,e}i tg^-)tr-flilfidE\ g-orwvq^erfrftmwt $qrsT(^q:d^qrtqqt^,rftfrE{]dr+f,+{r qfqrUt-i{T,OXq+tr1TfiqBuEkl-rI qlqrdq daxr ^q-frddrEERGerq6.6^qfte-rdo sITS' zoos^{(s)gq.ft.w.d.}osd^qmd tfr^.T{qcr{€rldeErrrisq+re.Iri^itqrqfi q=IeFIq-&{rrTrrrxq-{t wsT{dqvt e-olRrad^qHw,fu-n^qfutrqq'w{ot drft-o-rrflrFddB,ca^{tra q$t}o-avro-orot s$wqrzn^qa+twrmlfrnfr^?ft,cqifu^q6 {fir.rr{^q-arS^qGdTerT,3T?rif,GrCEo sef6r qaa-dfifrDr{rragsrffi m'qTfrt fu^qqrsrrc.ad^+rnqqt^q-f,lFrflfiEror frv+^gnq&gGTT,oRuro1vsd^.r-st rrrrr'4i{c-,ffif,rfrotI 24.n<sup>qqGil'dq-{^qeio}^gf,qeftqsil-trT erqnnoqri Aftr rriu^q-qdo-ri otvrqq fiqrfrirfiPlo.2o1lr) srr"{d^qrfr,fu{-$ sofu{qdGr-{toleridfu{rfi^p.11.zo1ldq s_m-{oTtr{Sf,d^qrqr "TRq e.TT,dn-+- 07.08.2024Crtgogen,eruln 6nr1q6^qg qtTfudBgolrt,wqfu3{r-d-{f,JTUTss €nrd-cfuoqoferqrfr;it&"tg wvr{flfrar{q^qcilqrifr entqeitI
	2s.^qm+qsqilq^qrnerqdarErstrdl o1-orqttrsersffiqM fufu	s fr-{-d

¶36

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER trffq^gAst{ (zo'rs)o gfl.+.ft.412d i-o--"rt^{qNI3 {ql-{r3lBfrqq ofqrqt} h"teq^qq-{enfi'r$^{atfudqfitrt3f,srE,} sTfi-f,lcTA-qq^{Psfour qrcr} "TEq, trdfr Fttt^{,.i rrqqryq14t3ncfun B-drfrd I} E^{qEt gsftsorq-ot o1cmBqrBa} q6 vq'.<sup>,rqAswgi^{q-dfr'qr€iB gq} A-"= Gnileqr$-fl-i frtd^qiiorot{ 3ilqrir€ttr 26.Eq^{qRR,Qrfr;qin 3Tlil{fiqeroffri t} urgf,sidRq^{3{rifi3lr{'g'srao'l2024r.$-m-R} ata,aor^ot{srdd\ti^{q-flrft3rqr{S} t,^{3rrltd3ltt{f,-rmgMtr{gdqEfqhq trfitut} ci-qts^qlBdt,^{ereri(g'TAsqqent}Si^qfi d.q^q-St^t 27. s-fi-{sq^{snifficeTaxtrrgofro<} efirGtrilfi^{en{.g.srao,zzoz+eiltnr&cqro-t} ft-qqf,fuqT^qrcnt^{tnrqfr3{tilffiq&TgM} gq$ft{f,{^q{ftwfl^{ofqrfrt t} 28.sqq^{qssltl-{loil[qTqqq5q6ttt}
	2s.^qRqlqd fuqr^q-6-ts-'F{uI 3rFreqriritSiftfl^ssrqrit ({qfu{R{ ^q.d) qonfl-r3lPrf,ft $.eix.E^q.q.Ts^s-ffi-s-'rd

DATE

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
trffq^gAst{
(zo'rs)o gfl.+.ft.412d
i-o--"rt^{qNI3 {ql-{r3lBfrqq ofqrqt}
h"teq^qq-{enfi'r$^{atfudqfitrt3f,srE,}
sTfi-f,lcTA-qq^{Psfour qrcr}
"TEq,
trdfr
Fttt^{,.i rrqqryq14t3ncfun B-drfrd I}
E*^{qEt gsftsorq-ot o1cmBqrBa}
q6 vq'.<sup>,rqAswgi^{q-dfr'qr€iB gq}
A-"=*
Gnileqr$-fl-i frtd^qiiorot{
3ilqrir€ttr
26.Eq^{qRR,Qrfr;qin 3Tlil{fiqeroffri t}
urgf,sidRq^{3{rifi3lr{'g'srao'l2024r.$-m-R}
ata,aor^ot{srdd\ti^{q-flrft3rqr{S}
t,^{3rrltd3ltt{f,-rmgMtr{gdqEfqhq trfitut}
ci-qts^qlBdt,^{ereri(g'TAsqqent}Si^qfi
d.q^q-St^t
27. s-fi-{sq^{snifficeTaxtrrgofro<}
efirGtrilfi^{en{.g.srao,zzoz+eiltnr&cqro-t}
ft-qqf,fuqT^qrcnt^{tnrqfr3{tilffiq&TgM}
gq$ft{f,{^q{ftwfl^{ofqrfrt t}
28.sqq^{qssltl-{loil[qTqqq5q6ttt}

2s.^qRqlqd
fuqr^q-6-ts-'F{uI
3rFreqriritSiftfl^ssrqrit
({qfu{R{ ^q.d)
qonfl-r3lPrf,ft
$.eix.E^q.q.Ts^s-ffi-s-'rd

Narmada Prasad Mohar v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Hdfc Bank versus Amit

Axis Bank versus Tofan Singh Padihar

Bank of India versus Saroj Singh Chouhan

State Bank of India versus Dilip Singh Pawar

Narmada Prasad Mohar v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Hdfc Bank versus Amit

Axis Bank versus Tofan Singh Padihar

Bank of India versus Saroj Singh Chouhan

State Bank of India versus Dilip Singh Pawar

Sheikh Abid Son of Sheikh Ajmeri versus Centram Housing Finance Ltd.