Shri Parth Sarthi Naidu v. State Bank of India

DRT13 Jun 2023SA/41/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER ..41/2023
13.06.20 g onteo^qeToffr{tfronil6di-d 3TfuqffiII Bffii-qrfrsHdftCfrqFd{+{ 3rfus-ffirI
1. sq-qceT6)fl+aqeffirenilecaffg.c. 60/2023u)XasnA-fi^qsrfrGsar+or* qqfudB,nreifrfudqffirorricn811/2023 cilfudrE-srffi rdtamcrRf,oni{r ft+rooz.ro.zorsdssiwtsffidtgq err{.c.ett/2023ffirr{3n'ffi,sr.lfred.c. B1o/2oz3terr{sfiifiqignrrrqrBI 2. slIi-q-fiCeIERTftiroos.orzozso) gqsTfus-{qdsqmqRT17(1)s{S!ft:rc zoozdcr-qqHtdoiilrfdu-gofu-d.riqs c-s{ord^qrtqqt ffi offi6qrozzo.oa. zozzd^qcrwfu-qqriofUqsfl-{f,rd spr^qidfuo3TrEq-iqofffi o)orAEr dR-dfrri^qriofrroErdrerSGtr
1.^{l-srurtrEdo-{i qgqfumqo}erqr} kF-q^qrqETi{orffq-{dqrqu-gnH.rd stclr{q3Tr{({60/2023ffiOOZ.O1.ZOZSd qtqqtoTR-opTqfu-qrrrqrtofq-dqEft qfuEd mg-dqqteng-swotdoatu-+ ETIT^qIlri"rctrgft-qrrrqrefl,vst{s Gft

¶5

REMARK

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE

Shri Parth Sarthi Naidu versus State Bank of India — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶10

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER ddrd^qeTtffu6-q^q,ilqq-{rfic-Errfu-qrqr To.r^BITfl^cni<-ot^rqo'qFrcrqdsqer EqrrRr^qqrqrrior^q=Frftqren,fu-dsqi T4q^qrTqrmqr€lfo-qrterqqq:g?hruT[kld o{ sryftnrffidt.t-oriorffi fuqr^qr16rt,^q-qfuno-qt-s-',f$derd Ef,^{tqrEdt r g€enErritw u-qou-o-<"r} $-d^i01oTrqfuiftT$trffiqerqr 3lril{no-ryar-6frqqrqu-gofuqrr;q1t, qqredqqqtGTrcfud^-6iffi.r$t01 u-qnfuv^.riu-6-r"rttgq fomqoierqrfrri qrioroI$uruxrfrB,qsgEonnq-6i W..223/201sddF{f,€i d dRrq 22,oo,oool-(qrfflarv)aoraqqr o-GCds qr6d3l-qrqryfuurUrrf,Ho-ri oroqc ftqr,fo-{oicifr^qEFTo'r^q-6qrfrfu-qr,fu-i 5q^{rfrqfud grtrc-{gdfr;d.rdc-6-{"r} orsW^grqgsona-{6o)en,ilqEflGTri-{o or^q66er{fuXamfiqkdFRr{d q1q-6rftfrnfu{rq-6{"rt{rfu-qr rrqr,Tffi d.qoefiT€iBIfudr^q@cFrir^qrR-d ontcrdftq-q^gqFrqrEfoqrrrqrtfuWd c-6-{urt^.ftonicrfrqioozro.zorso)oile}fud frri^qdoTonilfi^qcrftrqrrirTer,n-stgs olrileod3lrcr6rEFrratBI u-qoerHr offt{6frrn^qriorergtu fuqr^rrqrBr	REMARK
5.^qoftffiCotof^qs3lril<o,Xazut q-diffidmrJ-dwqerfsV.sq;lrc rdt-q gMt'fitftftq-ixqo-rqqmilEnt,e{efd frqHrrarc-fl-to-rTs^qer6'REUfr^qkd qBqqtfr3nA-{oqqFcrERT'ftqfrf,ol tfu{dtB-ffiqrftd-6^trKrfudof^.r$zq qWro.ffioren*frc o-GorErqr6tr-at tr
6. sri{q-6^qai ws-m{old^qrsqqi {otffotffift{15^{zz.oa.zozzo\elqrr<frri} qri fg5€q s6r{rdrqrfr.rgBtfuouq++ irtrfudtc{ fo-qrrqrtt 1q-i@1^q,/z)\rf,'q

DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
ddrd^qeTtffu6-q^q,ilqq-{rfic-Errfu-qrqr
To.r^BITfl^cni<-ot^rqo'qFrcrqdsqer
EqrrRr^qqrqrrior^q=Frftqren,fu-dsqi
T4q^qrTqrmqr€lfo-qrterqqq:g?hruT[kld
o{ sryftnrffidt.t*-oriorffi
fuqr^qr16rt,^q-qfuno-*qt-s-',f$derd
Ef,^{tqrEdt r g€enErritw u-qou-o-<"r}
$-d^i01oTrqfuiftT$trffiqerqr
3lril{no-ryar-6frqqrqu-gofuqrr;q1t,
qqredqqqtGTrcfud^-6iffi.r$t01
u-qnfuv^.riu-6-r"rttgq fomqoierqrfrri
qrioroI$uruxrfrB,qsgEonnq-6i
W..223/201sddF{f,€i
d
dRrq
22,oo,oool-(qrfflarv)aoraqqr o-GCds
qr6d3l-qrqryfuurUrrf,Ho-ri oroqc
ftqr,fo-{oicifr^qEFTo'r^q-6qrfrfu-qr,fu-i
5q^{rfrqfud grtrc-{gdfr;d.rdc-6-{"r}
orsW^grqgsona-{6o)en,ilqEflGTri-{o
or^q66er{fuXamfiqkdFRr{d
q1q-6rftfrnfu{rq-6{"rt{rfu-qr rrqr,Tffi
d.qoefiT€iBIfudr^q@cFrir^qrR-d
ontcrdftq-q^gqFrqrEfoqrrrqrtfuWd
c-6-{urt^.ftonicrfrqioozro.zorso)oile}fud
frri^qdoTonilfi^qcrftrqrrirTer,n-stgs
olrileod3lrcr6rEFrratBI u-qoerHr
offt{6frrn^qriorergtu fuqr^rrqrBr

REMARK

5.^qoftffiCotof^qs3lril<o,Xazut
q-diffidmrJ-dwqerfsV.sq;lrc rdt-q
gMt'fitftftq-ixqo-rqqmilEnt,e{efd
frqHrrarc-fl-to-rTs^qer6'REUfr^qkd
qBqqtfr3nA-{oqqFcrERT'ftqfrf,ol
tfu{dtB-ffiqrftd-6^trKrfudof^.r$zq
qWro.ffioren*frc o-GorErqr6tr-at
tr

6.
sri{q-6^qai ws-m{old^qrsqqi
{otffotffift{15^{zz.oa.zozzo\elqrr<frri}
qri fg5€q s6r{rdrqrfr.rgBtfuouq++
irtrfudtc{
fo-qrrqrtt
1q-i@1^q,/z)\rf,'q

¶21

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
10.ts_d{qrficeTqfi oit{t {s3nileq futETo.-{d Eqs-Edfril.rnu+rqdurEaq 3ncfu(d 6-{rfrqrTottofenilq-oqeT Fs^sTrtcr615FI 1-dtrsrtrnqo sqlTlfrrStr
iDEFD<II138 Yq +mn rfrfrqfr.r sTr$tsr gtrsfit-o. oimf{q vs 3i-q^qrfuorEqio' 3251,/zorodtilfro trq Ho65.99.2619 3lq-d-qfrqtI crg+c frft	s fus-d
y e-6-{ure-qdoritgqqqfrqrBs ft{mt^yrcrftt,ffift-qmqn o-rqqftr.Boqkd gntenqrdtgsq-m-{or dffi sffiffi622.e6.2022derfuo frti^qriigsrsoruroTrieodorct$ fiarftq-+crsrtrrlthlyFTfi-i@r/2)d qtqqd eligqrfitfrenrrrfl er,fryfi sr-a-q-o.^qerifuliR-o+sftqofot-qBd3i<s ffi orffi furo 22.08:022dU+O T$lfuqrt',a-qft-qi622.08.2022fr^rrumro-r 45fu{so1orqfu^q-fi-did^qrqfr^qrfdor

¶25

DATE OESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER g-qdo-{io'rEfiGTrd-{4' ceTq}Torttero: oTra-{fiwrgRrq-qdfumqamoiilere1-g* 6o/202s{ffi cil.qc vrigqft-{wfuqr qmrB,Hrsrfr3Tra-{o.qeTAr$ q-r{f,q6 Tsr onnfifior-qfuErkdil{rftErfRd#qntEr 13.^qaic-ofuarEwrffi {d{trM crRdfrdTdonicrftqrfioz.ro.zoleorss{ t,wentwoTEt=rdoTrn<-6o)w3ril<-fi gMTdrgourfuorys..223/201ed+{H frd^.rqren,Sffo1ontyrcFd-6rfur6 12.12.201s1q-i@rq,/1)isFfdB,n-qGTrieo selor^q6oatiWlo,orseqBofs-moniv oTril{o^qeldgnic-trqrtqqfrqcrrtrt qrfuorfrfiqEsrfuf,t,n-caTri{fiqero)& qrfufiInricitnrqooGErfiEm.ylsrfi T6^qrdrtts.-cswoTrnq-rceTsffoftt e-Ed niilRq3ni-{qefi.g,.atz/zozsfiF-irtnr ift-{wfuqr^qrentr 14.^qRunqwsqoilt<oqero1efttu-go €f,arcrdRqofiild-{811/202s, atoTzizt fr-qnq zil.qc dritftqre"rfrri "^ti
-rd 15.oTril<o^qeTErtrc-rEdq6c-6-{qvs.g. 41/2023or-{Bqrfud*i tentwr dq w fr-qruT+.qr-€lElit{Swrqrnrwmqr qrorBt
16.VIEICeT3FrilsIrlTIqKarqcrqot)I 6p^qftupqdfu-qrqrqryq-o-{ur 17.rmTq eft&*r.nrt -So/.'- (ffiffiq.Id) $.ew.O^q.q.gsuffisr.ra

DATE
OESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
g-qdo-{io'rEfiGTrd-{4' ceTq}Torttero:
oTra-{fiwrgRrq-qdfumqamoiilere1-g*
6o/202s{ffi
cil.qc vrigqft-{wfuqr
qmrB,Hrsrfr3Tra-{o.qeTAr$ q-r{f,q6 Tsr
onnfifior-qfuErkdil{rftErfRd#qntEr
13.^qaic-ofuarEwrffi {d{trM
crRdfrdTdonicrftqrfioz.ro.zoleorss{
t,wentwoTEt=rdoTrn<-6o)w3ril<-fi
gMTdrgourfuorys..223/201ed+{H
frd^.rqren,Sffo1ontyrcFd-6rfur6
12.12.201s1q-i@rq,/1)isFfdB,n-qGTrieo
selor^q6oatiWlo,orseqBofs-moniv
oTril{o^qeldgnic-trqrtqqfrqcrrtrt
qrfuorfrfiqEsrfuf,t,n-caTri{fiqero)&
qrfufiInricitnrqooGErfiEm.ylsrfi
T6^qrdrtts.-cswoTrnq-rceTsffoftt
e-Ed niilRq3ni-{qefi.g,.atz/zozsfiF-irtnr
ift-{wfuqr^qrentr
14.^qRunqwsqoilt<oqero1efttu-go
€f,arcrdRqofiild-{811/202s, atoTzizt
fr-qnq zil.qc dritftqre"rfrri
"^ti

-rd
15.oTril<o^qeTErtrc-rEdq6c-6-{qvs.g.
41/2023or-{Bqrfud*i tentwr dq w
fr-qruT+.qr-€lElit{Swrqrnrwmqr
qrorBt

16.VIEICeT3FrilsIrlTIqKarqcrqot)I
6p^qftupqdfu-qrqrqryq-o-{ur
17.rmTq
eft&*r.nrt
-So/.'-
(ffiffiq.Id)
$.ew.O^q.q.gsuffisr.ra

Shri Parth Sarthi Naidu v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

A G Garments versus Idfc First Bank Ltd.

Ms Nanesh Collection versus Fullerton India Credit Company Ltd.

Laxmi Narayan versus Capri Global Finance Pvt. Limited

Mr Yogesh Gupta versus Bank of Baroda

Shri Parth Sarthi Naidu v. State Bank of India

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

A G Garments versus Idfc First Bank Ltd.

Ms Nanesh Collection versus Fullerton India Credit Company Ltd.

Laxmi Narayan versus Capri Global Finance Pvt. Limited

Mr Yogesh Gupta versus Bank of Baroda

Mr Manoj Malviya Son of Mr Shankarlal versus Punjab National Bank

Siddharth Harirmani versus Union Bank of India