Sukesh Chandrakar Son of Narsing Chandrakar v. Bank of Baroda

DRT22 Sept 2023RA/9/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

GONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REXIARK
22.09.2 23 gdvrz-<ro<^gs3i-q fdt-d i-63fi.FcetoG^si-q sTK.(.oel23 orileocmdfdqfr^ergwft+tt erBq-mrt g-tr{qrfrEqio1dftqfretN.g{. trqerBe-trrt
sf,rqrft^tnqis2vq3^dfuqfr ot$^{qfrfrB-d{€tt}
1.s+r-qsfio\fcffidroc^arrilfiqr ETr^TqlI 2.^{qo-{qo-tc[q-olm-{fu-qrrwt} 3.sltil{fi^qetHRI^{ftqrmz+.oe.zoztd} mSqffi{-{^sIfifivs.g.^sza,/zozsti crR-doTri$ft{16^{ro.oz.zozzd l+o-qu-tgo} origvcrRd^{srtqrft{16to.oz.zozed} oTrrrFTo-{^gs.g.s78l2ozs^o\gr,gro(i ftr-n^qdor^ergnufu-fl'rfl^Bt
4. qo{qorqdq{trqoxtfu srd-<-6^{q&Tgt-{ grr3lfufitrd rrqaqm} 17(1)^q{S,6v{d^{2oo2d YrqETrnd} ffi fuf,rs-srffir^{qrug{g[rTcrR-d} ontcrfuirfizo3s.2o23^{o\wrr<frtnqri} tgsTilfiftiro^{zz.oo.zozgo\u-qofu-+r} r-qrI^y-.F{uru-qd^{z6{itigVl+o<o'rerqt} frrn^qfifuuxrs^{Tqtflertsftqqa} eto.toyqotro{urtrqf,^frtqrIqTIT{ 96-r"rts.rq^ceno\E{r^{qrm-{qrR-dsnt{r}

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

Sukesh Chandrakar Son of Narsing Chandrakar versus Bank of Baroda — DRT (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶14

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REI'ARK
8. sarrkT:{sfug^{q1fdqRfu-qrqrrgt} Bfo^"eqrq-q(5{ffi-dYo.q^enil<q$Tq ftqrdsiqi^qmigqg"TdswEi^qri fr.qt"t
e.Ess<lii^{qevffiq t+t} 3lra-<-fi^qeraRI ^qFrftq sTiEre-t$ErSC a{r cYrsffifr vr$au frtu&^ft-t.a tozoravs.fr.S.tc{rqrs ^ittzt dcRlqtfudrod^{s-orrfrqrrr5 Tqf{r} stftFqqotvr*qor^{o-lse{r-srrqrB gq} qr+ftqqe=Tr 6rSJ EI{T +e{teEsTftfl tozs/zote frlfrqEqn ^{ffs-dqftq-{ frE} strgqr^{dflqAt 27frffil-rzora6\qrRd} frrn^.r$sr-tcrd^{gcffiqcarilfiqT} Eisr$^{o.-{igsqrflo-rio1Yrfrildid} s-fiRriadrqrrqr^{B,qqfuB-f,{qrfr} ttogrqt ^{qmfiqrl.c.s@ afl-qrr[rlo1qrfuf,r} E-qiwastg/zotato ^{ms'strsqr \rq3rq} ft-{-€ Tfissmin^{crR-dsntcr fuiro} 12.02.201s^{q1'Igqfido-rdgVgqm-6q} oTtifiEt^qrtfrrq cdri^ore-drq'rqt tr strfl-{
10.swl^seTof^{efrrtu-tgofttiTi} EETd^{c{eflfls-'teo-Ggq5flftoot} qotof+tr22(2) (g)31q.$'fr.9+-eroo3 qEcEf,ftqq5qt-.csffiRqc-d Ff€rqi)^{tgsgd erqqmr5fll-igseikotor} tn\so,axr^qrRdfrtn^{..risTiiqlo-l} gqfuoqo-{iof^{qrEilmflwt,orqorat} q5ffi6-<urqrT17(1)rl-ffi^g+ezoozd

¶18

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
offif,rqgde}i^qrdenfe+flftgrqxur q-{I17 (z)w<ffi\rqd2oo2durotlr+rgT{ri eTx.S.fr.'{d1ee3tsFfdsrqqmfgs futorsEqxurorigvororBr
11.s-qfrfu-{^,figlfi-etocaTrilfiftqq
sg(2)S.em.0.ffiwr-f,{1ee3d
qrcqmrgil-r30ftqHdGi<tu-go*i qB$rrqDGTr-iqrfuirfi10.01.2023t
Tur-{ro{i^qqfuiro24.08.2023o)u-rgo fu-qr^rrqrs-{ffidrtr=TsTd-fisr-qB^qrfudB, fuS^qTTfiqEdET-ds@^qrqrdsdarsr
qrF+orqqtr,ssat/2023tcrRdGTrt{r ft{roos.oa.zozsd^qrtqqtGTrd-{ocHo) gqffiEcarnc{u-tgooritgfr^.d
EriTdrdrorcli^gnfi-oorroBfu
u-qo5+ffiwGnilfi6TXur<isw G-{m-{urfu-qr^qrflfrfuwq-oBt
12.^q6In?Fgqffio.cand-fid5"t
dso-re"{ctGTd-{rseT^gr-qt{fl
gqtr-dmqoTl'fi{tsFf(oeqids-+-relfr
advqr^.rqrtfo^gqoTBo-tq dr<r^gn.g.
is6/2020^itqrfudGr-iqrfrir6zs.tz:ozd
Gi-Tflr-ifuoqmqro-iurgf,srilfigudv
q{E-{qr{tg {rflfuqTr-qlBtsfl
EMT^{tv+rprfrqr+fiqsqf,qqrq[f,q}
, gNI Erdc{rcqrdfus-€ t-o.ds,gtrsqr
qq3pq(zoro) rgfl.fr.fr.o,gqfrqrF{d
e1ftq-66norttfrTf,oil-ffinrrgo
fuaqerqrsrd-fi{ffi sn-qt,fr"S
rqouriletftffifuqr^{\flt=ilqirteT}ZEBt

¶23

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
gSeinnqtrrgqffid}tr-{3rd-fiT+6Ro-t {d^e-f-{q{q^dsqiEt^qrttgg-c, ranfuf,frrn^qdo-r^ci-g{Mfu-qr^.rqrt^t 13.^zr-6T{iqtof^gssTFo-sq6rr^gq{. .^is6/2020i^{qrR-dentqlfrfl-ozs.rz.} zozzd3i-5sn^qrtT5^{qqf<T sTEB-qqq,t} sr+qf,rffi gq wgd fudqeFII 3[iEcuqifuae-6-iuriT$-o-rifu-qr^.rqrt, fuE^gq-dvnqfr^?rdfisffiq t^o1 qserBowr6nrYq.q.$6/2020^qqlRf, ,rttmf*23.12.2022tffiE^olfufrqqd Giffi^q-fi'{urwSf,FGtgsFf(mq qrqqftfl vqqrsrrz(r) w<dffi\r{d2oo2 dtrd^glsddri^qrds-f,{urd^rqsqd s-6-rcrfr^qms^qqtsro{EF-{qsfr^e-r+qdr d^qrcq{q
filfuTnffi sfttyn Mtuete^c[q
(zoos) zvs.fr.fr. 16e,crBqrdFod
fufr'sf{s-d^{qfrq-{ eTrw.gtrsql}lti^erq
Yfl^{.fr.fr.zoo+(z)}w.^{fr.va.d.+os gs3f,qq} Tqr fuq^{rrq(z016)14ys.fr.fr.sr+t}
qffi{doTffitoTsl-gyRqrfrfu-qlrrql arl
14.^qmfi-qsqf,q qrffifl+ft-o-ddno-q qtqtdq dgrr nfr^{.r$ q+en}d
ci-gsri^qrtt17(1)rn-ffi^g+ezoozd GTil,fds-tgf,5fiororsrilfi^q.c.r{.d trnTdffion {qisrd^qq6n
-qtqtdq d^qrqeru-qodi^qrdqrEqed ,"'

¶28

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER
HSII^(D-Ifril'BYqsIqq^TTWI f{s-{ tl-qd trorutt^qrT+qvqilqqt-qrdqgr{I cffi{f,3rftqdder5uxsrEq-riteTrtr s qqj<tetftfiqqdsr+nqe-msqr-fr*t, efu^qr,Glfi-f,Vqsnd-fi+iyrffiqetd t^gs6-{rfig}s ^gmffirrE-c{ cr+$sd q-m'{qtqrl-+qs@cm -?.llqlC'lq gRI qftrkdsrftqdder5nxmEGrtsftqqd ffE^gtDrur91Edo-dofqFtosq-qqftql d^q-mr-eTi^qM5TqtflGrfufu{qdH[qrq sqEqsrq-qff-ddqrid, oqqrqra-qo<br>sqqfiflfuknRdo-Gorfrilfic-€r 16 qrdr I
15.w{Grkfi-rqHRr clCl^rl{qld 3tfi c-f,-i"ittgs.q.s7B/2023T{trdq6 EMoT^orqqrqr.rqrt^ofeTrqrfi⁽¹⁾ si$ffigqe2oo2dsiil,fdrqo*io-d
trfi-i"iiierrurs^qqiqrorEftqqdqrqEr-{ cfisqc-€i*iI{flEMqo-rHqQi{'fl q.s7l/202sfrcrfud3Triyrfuim
10.07.2023Sfio-trsfir12frqFffiqqqrs B!.IaIIqrEl,qn-fiqo-f,fr-f,tts@
-qlqldq \rq^qI-T+qdrarvaqrqraqd qq-gEt-do-rfi sdqfu-qr qq1g,
16.Gl-d-droseTo-r^qlqoildtot qITfiqi;Erf,qaIFIrf,q trMgtrs{rcdo'
fSEqc+drd^rilft-<!ft*1{r (zots) 3gfl.
fr.fr.zrz ^qdsrdrfl6qra^q{Nrfl-df{s-d
t-omw.gfuqrgierq (zoro)rvs.fr.fr.
+u,Icffi{dsrftqd^qqf+qrqfrr}G-{r

¶33

OATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	crRdsil-Avtfull6ro.oz.2o23gnffidls-{ot cRftfrBrsnrl<d^qs-fi^qrq{eidfqr T{r^slrflqqz6{dEq^sffiqt^ot qrdTfiRITFIcr{strrcr ft-s-q{-odm,
	gtrsqrdnoqqtEEToo1o-trs-orrd 3i-gri^qmft-qs@crrreEITcrrId^qqeT ffiq rq"r^QrTft^"cqrrr-{+ffi\qe2oo2 d ff( u-rgd^qrtT$Grfr-f,noTfi-fu fg{-d^{qiqriTro(r)rrt$nfrgqezooz}d Gio-.i(fuaqerq,frriqdorerkom^qlq B,orQtrrr&"?^ys@ tro.ft-s-d Trftf,rdd{r ds-+-{qtqtl-fi-qB@ilq .qlqldq drrqerffiq s+rarfu$cs ffi fgcd^dv+qerrtgofui^qrisra frfrEToTrndlrifrera-<qu-tgoori^ttgq fuoqaerqrftri^qriorro^qrwt, orarqrrSI,+flrE1^qrqEETf,ofoF-sorr vq^ot^er+ffiqtrr€^qRfufuiot ft-qf,rdo_rsq^qn-ftqvqilq^qrqroqd qrqEeiilqrdrfiqrn-r fr--s-dtofrF itrsqrTs ^{gtr€q-{d-o.} fut-q^q-fi-sras6, fiqqnn{zerdgv5flfidtnrqotot sTra-q-o^qeT6\tr€s-mrrrts-mEETdin qffi{dRr<ra\fiq6.rSffir
	17.^qrraoGnlcf,^q&TFr-rt^qr+ftqq.s. s@^{qr-il-dqq"sfi-d}s+dtrqereiko frEETe-6-{q4104/2023i^qrR-d3r-trT ft{16z+.02.2023^qtq{rto1^gsor-tnt tSat$ frtu^H-qqrF-drfft,ftmd^eilEr-r
	werlt<oseTor16ild{+oxr^qrvrd

¶38

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
fu{sorko-{ur^{grrgfl..578/2onI} crtrdontsTfrqrr^ro.oz.zo:sd^l+t-<u-qo g{sTffi-mq 3nile{{ffi rqtt 18.^qsfrqavr@tol5{i^3lkfi{qo'I sTTifrsn+crotgr{Tffimc6{i^ot tthild^qrr22(r)€)^arx.0.ft\r{e^1ee3 d^qrqqmrjrlr{ur<,t,^n,,-g5{iTfr-aY{^A YrfrildE+qnfr{flfro+frt^3leltf,qq Grtrf,{q^{griTqrftd3niqr}n^{gerrrf,: treIH} ZE^{noeEY-ftd -qGnicr 47ftqqr rft.fr.} fr. tsFfd^qrqtrn)d^3tr(e-gd grqTm@q3nlc{eqFroildrB,^ml qrR-dGntcrfifun.riermq.tgel-oot$ sil-tcrfufl^ulTcthdlt.r^gnfrslii^stsf, df6'I9fsft-r-€^{orEid ercdr(zors) 2 ({I.} fr.fi.egot^{qffif,Grfrqf,Gr-qEiq-ftqt t} flTftqBucklq an-qTd-rr+ENI gI0
q-fl'qFr{q Erftfu{-q ilfra-{rg Y[q\if erq^(zot+)s^gs.S.zsd^s-o-{qt^3rftTa fuqrrqrBfu^{fu-s eiltcroTgflImo-dq} qr6lrt-rtTt,wrGrTTn^"get3ryt€3fr-i +-flmtrerr$r"^{3lrrkoTti$d u-eua-o:}1fr cffitrdEt{r"TB<br>oratQrTdNf,ut sTri{r/FPtq @.I3TIqRT€fd qr+fiqBEKrq q6RI $rdorftftfr anqrtrq6RI.Yrift ot<€rc crftc tutu& f{s-q oTNIrrIdc frrfrdrg (zozo)z{s.fr.fr.ozz$vsrqfr^etftqo frqrrqTt'fu^wqs-.qeTZE^srffisw foqqncd,^{orfrro-+efo</sup>}

DATE
DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER

REMARK

fu{sorko-{ur^{grrgfl..578/2onI}
crtrdontsTfrqrr^ro.oz.zo:sd^l+t-<u-qo
g{sTffi-mq 3nile{{ffi
rqtt
18.^qsfrqavr@tol5{i^3lkfi{qo'I
sTTifrsn+crotgr{Tffimc6{i^ot
tthild^qrr22(r)€)^arx.0.ft\r{e^1ee3
d^qrqqmrjrlr{ur<,t,^n,,-g5{iTfr-aY{^A
YrfrildE+qnfr{flfro+frt^3leltf,qq
Grtrf,{q^{griTqrftd3niqr}n^{gerrrf,: treIH}
ZE^{noeEY-ftd -qGnicr 47ftqqr rft.fr.}
fr. tsFfd^qrqtrn)d^3tr(e-gd
grqTm@q3nlc{eqFroildrB,^ml
qrR-dGntcrfifun.riermq.tgel-oot$ sil-tcrfufl^ulTcthdlt.r^gnfrslii^stsf,
df6'I9fsft-r-€^{orEid ercdr(zors) 2 ({I.}
fr.fi.egot^{qffif,Grfrqf,Gr-qEiq-ftqt t}
flTftqBucklq
an-qTd-rr+ENI
gI0

q-fl'qFr{q Erftfu{-q ilfra-{rg Y[q\if
erq^(zot+)s^gs.S.zsd^s-o-{qt^3rftTa
fuqrrqrBfu^{fu-s eiltcroTgflImo-dq}
qr6lrt-rtTt,wrGrTTn^"get3ryt€3fr-i
+-flmtrerr$r"^{3lrrkoTti$d u-eua-o:}1fr
cffitrdEt{r"TB<br>oratQrTdNf,ut
sTri{r/FPtq
@.I3TIqRT€fd
qr+fiqBEKrq
q6RI $rdorftftfr
anqrtrq6RI.Yrift ot<€rc crftc tutu&
f{s-q
oTNIrrIdc
frrfrdrg
(zozo)z{s.fr.fr.ozz$vsrqfr^etftqo
frqrrqTt'fu^wqs-.qeTZE^srffisw
foqqncd,^{orfrro-+efo</sup>}

¶42

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	3rra-qqdltLqqr\Ec,s€^qr_iie'Isdt-i ofeUqnTfrfruTrrf,ftt,fu{^q{EiT qro-qeirtcrftqrwg-orBr
	19.^qn-ft'qs@dq^qrtilcrqd^gRI sq-(tff^qqeTdfrq-ffi fu-didid q-orcriqqerilEoqeTaRrrrgdfrrnTi y-ftaw or-ic{tsFfdoeqfwfr-drifrrqr qlndgrrGrkfi-{vrh-r3rftqdtfu oril<o^qelsflsnilfid^qrtqqtv€ oeal6fi-dd'rrrreTs1sdo-r^(6rB.fu{ ceqlmTsd-s3ri@^qeTaM{dyfl.q. qprfrrtgofiri d{itilqq yqter.rl qd-fidqnqqr\sorqrrqrtgs{s slEf,$rrdagrrgr,rqenifiwfr-qrvovd HTqsdr$^.rioea)d^q-+-I{rfrontql^qrR-d fu-qr^rrqrtt
	20.sq-{tfrmeaids-mrsltnfi-s or q-oBofwrerD'o-qrrErqrgfl.g.s7B/2023 ttcrR-dsniqrfu-6rc.07.2023frtrftot$ rcqersfiZefr-sqTqr-frB,ffi eTrETn qrqdGrBfi-r'TgqffiEcat{frBf,yrfurq} dGtrTerq-iErT^qrkdGntsrfrTr610. 07.2023oryffio<6-rGTTTNflorigv \rs..578l2ozso<sup>gn,UqdsriUtuli tggc'cerTfr-floqe-dI
	21.^rrFrcmq3nd-q-6^geTHrtt^q-rEf, gnffimcaTrififrwflfrqrqrortr
	22.srri@^qeTilRlurgonioRrGTrd-fi 4340/2023rTTer^qTarfriro5fu-i^qrddt

Sukesh Chandrakar Son of Narsing Chandrakar v. Bank of Baroda

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Ms Ritu Jewels N Lifestyle Pvt. Ltd. through Co. Vikaram Mehendiratta versus Sfmg India Credit Company Ltd. Formerly Known as Fullerton Credit India Ltd.

Smt Sapna Singh Tanwar versus Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited

Mr Santosh Jha Son of Late Shri Ramnarayan Jha versus Housing Development Finance Corporation Ltd. Also Hdfc Limited

Sbm Bank Mauritius Limited versus Shri Ishar Alloy Steels Limited

Sukesh Chandrakar Son of Narsing Chandrakar v. Bank of Baroda

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Ms Ritu Jewels N Lifestyle Pvt. Ltd. through Co. Vikaram Mehendiratta versus Sfmg India Credit Company Ltd. Formerly Known as Fullerton Credit India Ltd.

Smt Sapna Singh Tanwar versus Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Private Limited

Mr Santosh Jha Son of Late Shri Ramnarayan Jha versus Housing Development Finance Corporation Ltd. Also Hdfc Limited

Sbm Bank Mauritius Limited versus Shri Ishar Alloy Steels Limited

Phoenix Arc Private Limited versus M/S Gdr Educational Society and Others

Idbi Bank versus Khemlal Thakur

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	23.^{gtillqeT3IqqT3rqflqqq-6=I} ottr
	24.^qRqTqd fuqr^vTlfi{ TM'{UI srfueqrrltrn$ftq{q^qFII s'fD
	(ffinfi-.rdtu) S.qR.E^q.q.vsud-stra