Louis Vuitton Malletier Vs Abdulkhaliq Abdulkader Chamadia, & Ors.

The present suit has been filed seeking relief of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from infringing the trademarks of the plaintiff, passing off along with other ancillary reliefs.

¶13

PROCEEDINGS IN THE SUIT

¶14

Summons in the suit were issued to the defendants on 5^th October, 2023. On the same date, an ex-parte ad interim injunction was passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.

¶15

The learned Joint Registrar has recorded in the order dated 6^th May, 2024 that the defendant no.1 was deemed to have been served on 16^th November, 2023 and the defendant no.3 was served on 15^th November, 2023 and closed their right to file written statement since the maximum

¶16

Signature Not Verified

¶17

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶18

Page 1 of 13

¶19

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶20

permissible period to file the same had lapsed. He further recorded the defendant no.2 would be deemed to have been served on 21^st March, 2024.

¶21

Vide order dated 3rd October, 2024, all the defendants were proceeded against ex-parte .

¶22

On 12^th November 2024, the present suit was decreed against the defendants in terms of the prayer clause contained in paragraphs no.41(a), (b), (c) and (d) of the plaint. On the said date, counsel for the plaintiff pressed for leading evidence in respect of the relief for declaration of the mark ‘LV ( i.e. , string of letters L and V)’ as a well-known mark as prayed for in prayer clause 41(e) of the plaint.

¶23

Accordingly, the plaintiff was directed to file an affidavit in support of its aforesaid prayer within two weeks. 7. In terms of the aforesaid order, an affidavit dated 31^st January, 2025, of the plaintiff’s witness Mr. Nandan Singh Syunary was filed.

¶24

On 25^th April, 2025, the plaintiff’s evidence was recorded by the learned Joint Registrar.

¶25

DECLARATION OF THE MARK ‘LV ( I.E. , STRING OF LETTERS L AND V)’ AS WELL-KNOWN TRADE MARK

¶26

The plaintiff-Louis Vuitton Malletier (“LVM”) is a company that manufactures, sells and distributes high-quality clothing, footwear, cosmetics, luggage and fashion accessories for men and women.

¶27

The plaintiff traces its history to the year 1854 when its founder, Mr. Louis Vuitton, established its business. Today, the plaintiff is part of the French Conglomerate, LVMH (Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy), which owns a portfolio of 75 world-famous brands. In 1896, Mr Vuitton’s son created

¶28

Signature Not Verified

¶29

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶30

Page 2 of 13

¶31

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶32

the highly distinctive logo featuring an interlocked string of letters L and V. The ‘LV’ Monogram comprises the initials of Mr. Louis

¶33

Vuitton, formed by the interlocking of the letters ‘L’ and ‘V’ , accompanied by three floral motifs. The hand-drawn typeface of the letter

¶34

in the toile monogram design has remained unchanged since its inception and is partially inspired by Roman typography. At present, the

¶35

plaintiff’s ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ mark, the toile monogram design ,

¶36

and the interlocking ‘LV’ logo are amongst the most globally recognised marks and constitute an integral and inseparable element of the plaintiff’s brand identity. ‘Louis Vuitton’ has over time been consistently shortened to ‘LV’ in reference to its business activities.

¶37

The plaintiff is considered as the world's most valuable luxury brand, ranked as the twelfth most valuable brand across all industries by credible fashion rating entities, and has a brand value of approximately USD 47.2 billion, as on date. The popularity of the plaintiff can be measured from the fact that it regularly features in the list of top fashion brands in surveys conducted by different credible fashion rating entities.

¶38

In India, the plaintiff has several registrations for its different

¶39

Signature Not Verified

¶40

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶41

Page 3 of 13

¶42

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶43

trademarks. The earliest registrations for the ‘LV’ marks date back to August 8, 1985. In particular, the plaintiff places reliance on the following registrations for its ‘LV’ marks in India:

¶44

S. No.	Marks	Application nos.	Classes	Date of application
1.	LOUIS VUITTON	448229	25	8^thAugust, 1985
2.	LOUIS VUITTON	2315405	3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 12, 25, 26 and 34	13^thApril, 2012
3.		441452	18	8^thAugust, 1985
4.		978462	9	20^thDecember 2000
5.		2316815	3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 12, 25, 26, and 34	17^thApril, 2012
6.		4879049	9 and 10	9^thDecember 2020
7.		3054827	9, 14, 18, 25, and 41	26^thNovember 2014

¶45

Signature Not Verified

¶46

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶47

Page 4 of 13

¶48

3888470 9, 14, 18, 8 th March, 2018
and 25
9. 4086627 3, 9, 14, 16, 17 th July, 2018
18, 24, 25,
35, 38, 41

¶49

12.1. Copies of the registration certificates/status sheets for the abovementioned marks extracted from the online records of the Trade Marks Registry have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/5 (Colly) . Copies of the registration obtained by the plaintiff in different jurisdictions have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/6 (Colly) .

¶50

The plaintiff’s have successfully obtained orders by this Court against the infringers wherein the coordinate benches of the court have observed the ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ and ‘LV’ marks as ‘well-known marks’, which have been filed as document 8 of the documents filed along with the plaint. Further, the ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ mark is included in the list of ‘well-known marks’ of the Trade Marks Registry of India, and the same has been filed as document no. 9 of the documents filed along with the plaint.

¶51

Section 11(6) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 (hereinafter the ‘Act’) sets out the factors to be considered while determining whether a mark is a well-known trade mark. For ease of reference, the same is set out below:

¶52

“Section 11 –

¶53

… (6) The Registrar shall, while determining whether a trade mark is a well known trade mark, take into account any fact which he considers relevant for determining a trade mark as a well-known trade mark including—

¶54

Signature Not Verified

¶55

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶56

Page 5 of 13

¶57

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶58

(i) the knowledge or recognition of that trade mark in the relevant section of the public including knowledge in India obtained as a result of promotion of the trade mark;

¶59

(ii) the duration, extent and geographical area of any use of that trade mark;

¶60

(iii) the duration, extent and geographical area of any promotion of the trade mark, including advertising or publicity and presentation, at fairs or exhibition of the goods or services to which the trade mark applies;

¶61

(iv) the duration and geographical area of any registration of or any application for registration of that trade mark under this Act to the extent that they reflect the use or recognition of the trade mark;

¶62

(v) the record of successful enforcement of the rights in that trade mark, in particular the extent to which the trade mark has been recognised as a well-known trade mark by any court or Registrar under that record.”

¶63

Section 11(7) of the Act lists the factors that the Registrar of Trade Marks need to consider while deciding whether a mark is known or recognised in the relevant section of the public for the purposes of Section 11(6) of the Act. The same is also set out below:

¶64

“Section 11 –

¶65

(7) The Registrar shall, while determining as to whether a trade mark is known or recognised in a relevant section of the public for the purposes of sub-section (6), take into account—

¶66

(i) the number of actual or potential consumers of the goods or services;

¶67

(ii) the number of persons involved in the channels of distribution of the goods or services;

¶68

(iii) the business circles dealing with the goods or services, to which that trade mark applies.”

¶69

Counsel for the plaintiff has drawn the attention of this Court to the following data, from the documents filed in the present suit, to satisfy each of the factors enumerated in the aforesaid sub-sections as being relevant in deciding whether the ‘LV’ marks ( i.e. string of letters L and V) are eligible to be declared as well-known trade marks:

¶70

Signature Not Verified

¶71

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶72

Page 6 of 13

¶73

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶74

I. Knowledge and recognition in the relevant section of the public in India obtained because of promotion [Section 11(6)(i)]

¶75

a. Extracts from the plaintiff’s website have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/1 (Colly) . Extracts from the plaintiff's website showing the use of ‘LV’ marks have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/3 (Colly).

¶76

b. Return hits of the ‘LV’ marks on the leading search engines have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/2 (Colly) .

¶77

c. Copies of third-party articles and extracts from social media highlighting the use of ‘LV’ have been exhibited as Exhibit PW1/4 (Colly) .

¶78

d. Distinguished individuals belonging to the upper echelons of Indian society used the products crafted by the plaintiff. In early 1926, the plaintiff created a tea case for the Maharaja of Baroda which features the ‘LV’ logo. Copy of an article evidencing that the plaintiff’s products bearing the ‘LV’ marks were known in India as their goodwill had percolated into India as early as l900s has been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/7 .

¶79

e. Brand reports conducted by different credible fashion rating entities, featuring the ‘LV’ marks in the list of top fashion brands in surveys, have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/8 (Colly) .

¶80

f. Plaintiff’s Financial Report for 2023, evidencing the growth and presence in markets worldwide, is annexed and marked as Exhibit PW-1/10.

¶81

II.The duration, extent and geographical area of any use of that trade mark [Section 11(6)(ii)]

¶82

Signature Not Verified

¶83

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶84

Page 7 of 13

¶85

a. Copies of the registration certificates/status sheets for the ‘LV’ marks extracted from the online records of the Trade Marks Registry have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/5 (Colly) . Copies of the registration obtained by the plaintiff in different jurisdictions for its ‘LV’ marks have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/6 (Colly).

¶86

b. Copies of invoices selected at random showing sales of the products under the ‘LV’ Marks for the FY 2022-2024 in India have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/9. The plaintiff has given its sales turnover for the financial years 2022- 24, which is set out below:

¶87

PRODUCTS BEARING LV MARKS	TOTAL SALES TURNOVER (2022-2024) (IN RUPEES)
LV INITIALES	262,571,875
BELT
LV OPTIC BELT	65,588,780
LV JEWEL SUNGLASSES	48,490,678
LV WAIMA SUNGLASSES	37,897,882
LV 3 STEPS BELT	32,203,372
LV TRAINER SNEAKER	26,802,967

¶88

Signature Not Verified

¶89

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶90

Page 8 of 13

¶91

LV ASH SUNGLASSES	15,204,661
DAMIERLVBELT	15,184,322
LV GOLDEN MASK SUNGLASSES	7,755,085
LV SHAKE BELT	6,758,483
LV MATCH SUNGLASSES	6,271,610
LV ICONIC EARRINGS	5,556,796
LV FLORAGRAM BRACELET	5,543,690
LV RISE SUNGLASSES	5,188,560
LV SLIM BRACELET	5,175,146
LV CLASH SUNGLASSES	4,881,355
LV LOVERS PERFUMES	3,430,170

¶92

c. Plaintiff’s Financial Report for 2023, evidencing the growth and presence in markets worldwide, is annexed and marked as Exhibit PW-1/10.

¶93

d. Distinguished individuals belonging to the upper echelons of Indian society used the products crafted by the plaintiff. In early 1926, the plaintiff created a tea case for the Maharaja of Baroda

¶94

Signature Not Verified

¶95

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶96

Page 9 of 13

¶97

which features the ‘LV’ logo. Copy of an article evidencing that the plaintiff’s products bearing the ‘LV’ marks were known in India as their goodwill had percolated into India as early as l900s has been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/7 .

¶98

III. The duration, extent and geographical area of any promotion of the trade mark including advertising or publicity and presentation, at fairs, or exhibition of the goods or services to which the trade mark applies [Section 11(6)(iii)]

¶99

a. Copies of third-party articles and extracts from social media highlighting the use of ‘LV’ have been exhibited as Exhibit PW1/4 (Colly) .

¶100

b. Brand reports conducted by different credible fashion rating entities, featuring the ‘LV’ marks in the list of top fashion brands in surveys, have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/8 (Colly) .

¶101

c. Plaintiff’s Financial Report for 2023 evidencing the growth and presence in markets worldwide, is annexed and marked as Exhibit PW-1/10.

¶102

d. Plaintiff’s products featuring the ‘LV’ marks are routinely endorsed by well-known figures in the entertainment and fashion industries, such as Madonna, Sean Connery, Michelle Williams, Jennifer Connelly, Angelina Jolie, Gisele Bündchen, David Bowie, and Deepika Padukone (Louis Vuitton’s first Indian brand ambassador) [ Para 16, Pg 13 of the Affidavit ]

¶103

e. The plaintiff has also led extensive advertising campaigns in renowned fashion publications such as Elle , Vogue , and Vanity Fair . The plaintiff has also engaged prominent creatives in its

¶104

Signature Not Verified

¶105

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶106

Page 10 of 13

¶107

marketing initiatives—for instance, its first television commercial was directed by acclaimed French director Bruno Aveillan and translated into thirteen languages. Additionally, celebrated fashion photographer Annie Leibovitz has photographed several internationally recognised personalities, including Steffi Graf, Andre Agassi, and Catherine Deneuve, for the plaintiff’s print advertisements. [ Para 16, Pg 13 of the Affidavit ]

¶108

IV. The duration and geographical area of any registration of or any application for registration of that trade mark under this Act to the extent they reflect the use or recognition of the trade mark [Section 11(6)(iv)]

¶109

a. Return hits of the ‘LV’ marks on the leading search engines have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/2 (Colly) .

¶110

b. Copies of the registration certificates/status sheets for the ‘LV’ marks extracted from the online records of the Trade Marks Registry have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/5 (Colly) . Copies of the registration obtained by the plaintiff in different jurisdictions for its ‘LV’ marks have been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/6 (Colly).

¶111

c. Distinguished individuals belonging to the upper echelons of Indian society used the products crafted by the plaintiff. In early 1926, the plaintiff created a tea case for the Maharaja of Baroda which features the ‘LV’ logo. Copy of an article evidencing that the plaintiff’s products bearing the ‘LV’ marks were known in India as their goodwill had percolated into India as early as l900s has been exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/7 .

¶112

Signature Not Verified

¶113

Digitally Signed CS(COMM) 700/2023 By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶114

Page 11 of 13

¶115

d. Plaintiff’s Financial Report for 2023 evidencing the growth and presence in markets worldwide, is annexed and marked as Exhibit PW-1/10.

¶116

V. The record of successful enforcement of the rights in that trade mark in particular, the extent to which the trade mark has been recognised as a well-known trade mark.

¶117

a. Copies of the orders passed by this Court against infringers wherein the coordinate benches of the court have observed the ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ and ‘LV’ marks as ‘well-known marks’ are filed as document 8 with the plaint.

¶118

I have heard the submissions made by counsel for the plaintiff and gone through the material placed on record.

¶119

On the strength of the averments made in the plaint as well as the nature and volume of the documents placed on record, I am of the view that the plaintiff has established well beyond doubt that the LV ( i.e. string of letters L and V) mark have acquired the status of well-known trade marks within the meaning and scope of Section 2(1)(zg) of the Act.

¶120

The standalone letters ‘L’ and ‘V’, as the central elements of the interlocked logo, have acquired substantial recognition and distinctiveness, such that their use immediately evokes an association with the plaintiff’s products, owing to their long-standing connection with the plaintiff’s heritage and goodwill.

¶121

The letters ‘L’ and ‘V’ have evolved beyond merely functioning as an acronym for ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ and have come to serve as independent and distinctive source identifiers of the plaintiff’s luxury brand. This distinctiveness is the result of extensive and prominent use in global

¶122

Signature Not Verified

¶123

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶124

Page 12 of 13

¶125

CS(COMM) 700/2023

¶126

advertising campaigns, product branding, and cultural references, further reinforcing the association of ‘L’ and ‘V’ with the plaintiff. In addition to their registration as part of the interlocked monogram, the combination of the letters ‘L’ and ‘V’ has also been prominently and independently used in connection with a wide array of the plaintiff’s luxury goods, including leather products, clothing, eyewear, watches, and accessories. It is pertinent to note that the mark ‘LOUIS VUITTON’ has been declared as a wellknown mark by the Registrar of Trade Marks, and the mark ‘LV’ serves as an acronym for the name ‘LOUIS VUITTON’.

¶127

The long duration for which the ‘LV’ mark have been in use by the plaintiff, wide geographical area of their use, their knowledge among the general public and their goodwill and reputation due to the extensive promotion, publicity and extensive revenue generated by the plaintiff, in India as well as other countries, the ‘LV’ marks have achieved the status of well-known trade marks. Accordingly, the plaintiff fulfils all the criteria set out in Section 11(6) read with Section 11(7) of the Act for declaring the ‘LV’ marks as well-known trade marks in respect of leather goods, apparel, footwear, watches and accessories.

¶128

Accordingly, in terms of prayer clause contained in paragraph no.41(e) of the plaint, a decree of declaration is passed declaring the ‘LV’ mark (i.e. string of letters L and V) as well-known trade mark within the meaning of Section 2(1)(zg) of the Act. 23. Let the decree sheet be drawn up.

¶129

AMIT BANSAL, J

¶130

MAY 15, 2025

¶131

Signature Not Verified

¶132

Digitally Signed By:VIVEK MISHRA Signing Da te:2 8.05.2025 19:22:05

¶133

Page 13 of 13

¶134

CS(COMM) 700/2023

Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Abdulkhaliq Abdulkader Chamadia, & Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Abdulkhaliq Abdulkader Chamadia, & Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Why is it important?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. Vs Reliance Broadcast Network Limited

Astra Zeneca Ab and Anr. Vs Natco Pharma Limited

Joy Creators LLP Vs S P International and Ors.

Ms. Shazia Rehman Vs Mr. Anwar Elahi & Ors.

Dassault Systemes S.E & Ors. Vs Heidelberg Cement India Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

Zydus Wellness Products Ltd. Vs Abony Healthcare Ltd.

Women Economic Forum and Anr. Vs Marriott Hotels India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

J.C. Bamford Excavators Limited Vs Master Alloys Limited & Ors.

Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. Vs Reliance Broadcast Network Limited

Astra Zeneca Ab and Anr. Vs Natco Pharma Limited

Romil Gupta Trading as Sohan Lal Gupta Vs Registrar of Trade Marks & Anr.

Kudos Pharmaceuticals Limited & Ors. Vs Natco Pharma Limited

Adidas Ag & Anr. Vs Aman Kumar Prajapati Trading as Aman Footwear

Kusum Electricals Prop Ram Karan Yadav Vs Deputy Registrar Trademark & Anr.