Nutan Tyagi v. State

Delhi HC1 Aug 2025CRL.REV.P./763/2016

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Delhi High Court; criminal petition (matter prefix 'CRL', number illegible) under CrPC Ss. 397/401 (plus section printed '482'); seeks setting aside of Special Judge-07 (Central) appellate judgment (Ms. Poonam Chaudry) confirming MM-04 (Central) conviction under IPC Ss. 279/304A; FIR No. 49/20??, P.S. Sarai Rohilla; fatal accident near Zakhira Flyover/Pul red light involving bus DL1P7563 and a scooter, victim declared 'Brought Dead' at Agrasen Hospital, Punjabi Bagh (MLC Ex. PW-8/A); eyewitness account of sudden right turn by bus; accident attributed to the petitioner's driving. Heavily OCR-degraded source: party names, advocates, exact dates, case number and fine amounts not reliably extractable; no holdings or disposition in the provided pages (excerpt ends at page 3, background section).

Nutan Tyagi Vs State — Corruption | Delhi HC (2025)

¶1

$~
* IN THE HIG COURT OF DELHI AT NEWDLHI
Resrvd on: 1 7 th May , 20 5
Pronuced : 1 st Augst , 205
+ 3/201EVP 7 6 C R L .
YGI TA N U P eti onr .
roug: T h Sh,AdvwnKu m P a M r.
s Ver
AE S T dtR e spo n.
roug: T h ,AfS oth lpG r. Pa dM e
Ro .i ks h ,I Om Pra A S
CORAM:
HON ' BLE MR.JUSTICAH
JUDGMENT
AMIT SHR, J.
1. e pr Th ntio sudSec s 397 n da 401r e hScon482 it w
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973Cr . P . C .‘) se k the
-
ayes:wing p r f ol
—1. Set Aside The Impugned Judgment
& 0 8 .1 26 Pa s ed By Ms. P o nam C ha udry, Ld. Special
Judge - 07 (Central) (PC Act Ca s e of ACB, GNCTD) , Tis H a zri
Courts, Delhi in el bearing no. ap 0 8/216 ginst the judgment a
and o r de of con v i t pa s ed by Ld. Me t r o plian M a gis t - 04,
(Central - D i s t rc) Tis H a zri, Delhi On 2 3 .0 915 and 1 4 .0 826,
in Case FIR No. 49 /2 0 U/S 279/304a IPC, P . S S a ri Rohi l a,
Delhi Wh e rby Ld. A pel at Court Confirm The O r de Of The
C on v i ct And Convicted The P eti onr For The O fe nc Under

¶2

Page 1 of 27

¶3

Section 279/304 A IP C an d mo i f et hs n c o f S . IO2 month
fo r th e ncU/S279 IP C and S . IO f 2m onth r ef cU/S
304A IPC;
to p he T i. b r ncqudfm aC g279304AIP / U s
i . Anyoth er lif or d i e c tn,w h y o u r ld s hip m ayd e fit
and proe b a l s pedin f av o ur t h e p i o n r t hef a cs nd
circumstances of the present case.“
BACKGROUND
2. -
w: l b in up rhe casoft T
2.1 O n 946 .02 , upon vng r e c i No. 18 D P Inderlok, ASI Mohd.
jiq longwith R a C onstable Ashok Kumar r ea chd t he spot , e, i . Red Light
n ear kh iFlyZvCw o and o uf t hne B u s earingto bN.
DL1P7563 and scter No. DL8SM7 o 4 w 5 e r lying in an identl ac
ondi t ac the injured person mely , na suR i w as dy lr ea kno t the
hrj M a as en HopitlAgr , PunjbiBgh a . Thaft, er ASI Mohd.Rajiq left
C onstable k Kum shoa rA t ep a n ocu d e thMLCNp r o 0 . 816/2 (Ex.
PW 8/A) qua the injured Ra d su i , S/o Sh. Inyt Ali, a rinwh e , the dctr o
ha d made his bservatin o adin the r e g injured as —Brought Dead “. In the
hrj Agrasen HM a ospital itself , one person , namely, Tej hdur S/o Sh. a B
hvir M a was aed to bes t the e y witne of the a s ident. c The I tig ves n
icerO f /ASI Mohd. Rajiq d co re the mn s et a of the complt Tej na i
hdur, B a o s h wed ta on thed af i at bou0:2P 5 . M . when
he wasoin g towards Bhus a Mndi fro m hi s houe , a t abou5:4 0 M P . he
r e achd at r ed l ight unde Z r khi a Pul , and one bus bearingNo. DL1P7563
s wa oming cfr heda p sulyt o rn ft uoml e si da tr
gsi nc r o the dl , ith n e o r ct suw dhie r v o fsct

¶4

Page 2 of 27

¶5

came under the bus. The ct na impl o k ou the sc t ter andsc o ter o r ide
and saw ha the injured was his neighbour and his name is Raisu t i n. The
laint e pco m dypu t h ein jurd t hre wl d n a r e at the
hrj M a rase n HopiAglw th e doct o r vdobs e ha t th e injurd person
w as —brought d “. T heacn ts bid e cau s ed ut o vng fbuswith dr i
ig sp hedn eg alicby the ntpre s i . Onthe mn as et of

¶6

Page 3 of 27

Procedural history

How this case reached the court

AI extract

Order under challenge
Judgment and order dated 08.12.?? (printed as '& 0 8 .1 26'; year partly illegible) passed by Ms. Poonam Chaudry, Ld. Special Judge-07 (Central) (PC Act Case of ACB, GNCTD), Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, in appeal bearing no. ...08/2016 (printed as 'ap 0 8/216'; partly illegible), whereby the Ld. Appellate Court confirmed the order of conviction and convicted the petitioner for the offences under Sections 279/304A IPC.¶1
Ld. Special Judge - 07 (Central) (PC Act Case of ACB, GNCTD), Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi
Prior proceeding
Police response to the accident: upon receiving a message (printed as 'No. 18 D P Inderlok'; wording partly illegible), ASI Mohd. Rajiq along with Constable Ashok Kumar reached the spot at the red light near the Zakhira Flyover, where a bus bearing No. DL1P7563 and a scooter (registration partly legible) were lying; the injured person had already been taken to Agrasen Hospital, Punjabi Bagh.¶2.1
Prior proceeding
ASI Mohd. Rajiq left Constable Ashok Kumar to prepare the MLC (number printed fragmentarily as '0 . 816/2'; partly illegible) (Ex. PW-8/A) qua the injured (name printed as 'Ra d su i', S/o Sh. Inyt Ali; spelling partly illegible), in which the doctor had made his observation regarding the injured as 'Brought Dead'.¶2.1
Prior proceeding
At Agrasen Hospital itself, one person (name printed as 'Tej hdur S/o Sh. a B hvir M a'; partly illegible) was pointed out as the eyewitness of the accident, and the Investigating Officer/ASI Mohd. Rajiq recorded the statement of the complainant.¶2.1
Prior proceeding
Content of the eyewitness statement: the complainant was going towards the market (printed 'Bhus a Mndi'; partly illegible) from his house and at about 5:40 PM reached the red light under Zakhira Pul, where bus No. DL1P7563 coming from the opposite side suddenly turned right and the scooter came under the bus.¶2.1
Prior proceeding
The complainant lifted the scooter and its rider and saw that the injured was his neighbour, whose name is printed as 'Raisu...' (partly illegible).¶2.1
Prior proceeding
The complainant took the injured to Agrasen Hospital, Punjabi Bagh, where the doctor observed the injured person as 'brought dead'; the accident was stated to have been caused due to the driving of the bus (speed/negligence wording partly illegible) by the present petitioner.¶2.1
Prior proceeding
The case was registered as Case/FIR No. 49/20?? (year partly illegible) under Sections 279/304A IPC, P.S. Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.¶1
Prior proceeding
Trial before the Ld. Metropolitan Magistrate-04 (Central District), Tis Hazari, Delhi resulted in an order of conviction passed on 23.09.15 and 14.08.?? (second date partly illegible), convicting the petitioner for the offences under Sections 279/304A IPC; the recited sentence included fines for the offences (amounts illegible in the source).¶1

Nutan Tyagi v. State

Case brief

What is this about?

Nutan Tyagi v. State

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Rahul Kumar & Ors. Vs Director, Central Government Health Scheme & Anr.

Ms Sarita Vs Ms Angel Bhati Chauhan

Vishal & Ors. Vs Director, Central Government Health Scheme & Ors.

M/S Bali Towers Private Limited Vs Sonalika Jiwani IAS

Lokesh Kumar Malhotra Vs Mitsubishi Corporation India Private Limited & Anr.

Ranveer Singh Chauhan Vs Dr S B Deepak Kumar and Others