Disposed

Constable Chandra Shekhar Dara v. Union of India and Ors.

Delhi HC14 Mar 2017W.P.(C)/2170/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court of Delhi allowed a writ petition filed by a Constable in BSF regarding his disqualification from the Sub-Inspector post due to poor distant vision in the medical examination. The Court directed a review medical examination at Army Research and Referral Hospital resolving conflicting medical reports.

What did the court decide?

Referral for review medical examination at Army Research and Referral Hospital; disposal of writ petition and stay application.

Constable Chandra Shekhar Dara Vs Union of… — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Delhi HC (2017)

¶1

$~42

¶2

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

¶3

W.P.(C) 2170/2017 & CM No. 9434/2017 (stay)

¶4

CONSTABLE CHANDRA SHEKHAR DARA ..... Petitioner Through Mr. Ajai Bhalla and Mr. Satya Saharawat, Advocates

¶5

versus

¶6

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS ..... Respondents Through Ms.Biji Rajesh for Mr. Gaurang Kanth, Advocates

¶7

CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE INDIRA BANERJEE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHAWLA

¶8

O R D E R

¶9

% 14.03.2017

¶10

Notice. Ms. Biji Rajesh accepts notice on behalf of the respondents.

¶11

The petitioner is a Constable in the Border Security Force. The petitioner applied for selection to the post of Sub-Inspector (General Duty) through Limited Departmental Competitive Examination, 2016.

¶12

The petitioner’s application was short listed and the petitioner was called to appear for the First Phase Examination on 7.9.2016 which was a written examination. The result of the written examination was published on 5.10.2016. The petitioner was successful.

¶13

By a letter dated 18.10.2016, the petitioner was informed that the petitioner had qualified the First Phase Examination i.e. the written examination held on 7.9.2016 and called to appear for the

¶14

Second Phase Selection test i.e. Documentation, Physical Measurements, Physical Efficiency Test and Medical Examination commencing w.e.f. 7^th November , 2016 at BSF Academy at Tekanpur, Gwalior District in Madhya Pradesh. According to the petitioner, before appearing for the Second Phase selection Test in Tekanpur, the petitioner had appeared before the Chief Medical Officer of the 142 Battalion at Border Security Force for Annual Medical Examination on 3.11.2016. The Chief Medical Officer on conducting the Annual Medical Examination declared the petitioner fit and in SHAPE-1.

¶15

According to the petitioner, the petitioner cleared all aspects of the Second Phase Test on 7.11.2016 after which he was asked to appear for the medical examination. The Medical Officer, however, declared the petitioner unfit on the ground of Poor Distant Vision (B/L 6/9). The petitioner has referred to prescriptions of other Government hospitals declaring the petitioner visually fit. It is stated that the distant vision of the petitioner was within 6/6 which is the permissible upper limit.

¶16

Considering that there are divergent reports of different doctors, and in particular, considering the fact that in the Annual Medical Examination the doctors of the BSF had declared the petitioner physically fit and in SHAPE-1, which meant that his distant vision was found to be within permissible limits, we deem it appropriate to refer the petitioner for a Review Medical Examination at the Army Research and Referral Hospital, New Delhi at the earliest, preferably within two weeks from the date of communication of this order.

¶17

The Army Research and Referral Hospital shall constitute a Medical Board which shall include a qualified Ophthalmologist for measuring and/or checking the vision of the petitioner. The candidature of the petitioner shall abide by the result of the Review Medical Examination by the medical board constituted by the Army Research and Referral hospital.

¶18

The writ petition and the pending application are disposed of. A copy of this order be given Dasti under the signatures of Court Master.

¶19

INDIRA BANERJEE, J

¶20

ANIL KUMAR CHAWLA, J

¶21

MARCH 14, 2017/mw

Constable Chandra Shekhar Dara v. Union of India and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Constable Chandra Shekhar Dara v. Union of India and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Anurag Gill Vs Bar Council of India & Anr.

Narain Dass Vs Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board & Ors.

Satish Kumar Khetarpal Vs Director General Cisf & Ors.

Dr. Barkatullah Khan Vs University of Delhi

Gaffar Mandal Vs New Delhi Municipal Council (Ndmc) & Ors.

Rajeshwari & Anr. Vs Savitri Public School & Ors.

Mirza Sahzad Beg Vs New Delhi Municipal Council (Ndmc) & Ors.

Gurdev Singh Vs South Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors.

Nitish Kaushik Vs Staff Selection Commission & Anr.

Supreme Housing and Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Vs Srs Private Investments Powai Ltd. & Anr.

M/S Gupta Synthetics Ltd. Vs Union of India

Syndicate Bank Vs M/S Ssp Tradex Private Ltd. & Ors.

Ratnesh Kumar Vs Union of India & Ors.

Subheh Singh Yadav Vs Union of India & Ors.