Disposed

Awadh Bihari Singh, v. Hindusthan Steel Works Construction Ltd.

Chhattisgarh HC4 Sept 2015WPS/1086/2007

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This Court disposed of a writ petition filed by numerous workmen of the respondent company, holding the present dispute is finally covered by existing decisions of this Court. No ad-hum relief was granted.

What did the court decide?

The writ petition was disposed of by applying the principles of previous decisions. No specific relief was granted.

Awadh Bihari Singh, Vs Hindusthan Steel… — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Chhattisgarh HC (2015)

¶1

¶2

NAFR

¶3

HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR

¶4

WP(S) No. 1086 of 2007

¶5

Awadh Bihari Singh, S/o Late Shri Dashrath Singh, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 17325, Electrician N-5 In H S C L, V R On 31.12.2002, R/o 16-F, Street N A V, Khuraipar, Zone - I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶6

Lahuri, S/o Late Hansraj, Aged About 47 Years P. No. 43272, Sr. S. I. In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o C/o Kiran Kirana Store, Camp - I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶7

Dilip Kumar Rathore, S/o Shri N. L. Rathore, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 44533, Armature Winder, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Bajrang Chowk Selud, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶8

Rekhalal, S/o Late Jaitu, Aged About 60 Years P. No. 44726, Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Shitla Mandir, Babulal Kirana Shop, Camp - I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶9

Hinchha Ram Sahu, S/o Late A. S. Sahu, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 43962, Fitter In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Q. No. Ews - 1261, Housing Board, Industrial Area, P. O. Housing Board, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶10

Gyanchand, S/o Late Hazara Singh, Aged About 58 Years P.No. 43353, Crane Operator In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o (As In Sl. No. 5 Above), P. O. Bhilai, Distt, Durg (C. G.)

¶11

R. B. Sharma, S/o Late R. S. Sharma, Aged About 61 Years P. No. 42445, Carpenter In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o C/o Gulab Kirana Store, Camp - I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶12

Jagarnath Singh, S/o Late B. Singh, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 16466, Fitter (Electircal) In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o C/o Sharma Ashram, Zone - I I I, Khusipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶13

Bodhan Ram, S/o Shri Charan Ram, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 46465, Electrician In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o C/o Tijau Ram Sahu ( Postman ), Sector - I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶14

10.R. K. Yadav, S/o Late S. B. Yadav, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 42844, Sr. S. K. In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o 43/11 Mother Teresa Nagar, Camp - I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶15

Yad Ali, S/o Jamiluddin, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 44296, S E O, H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Nizami Chowk, Fouzi Mohalla, Krishna Nagar, P. O. Supela, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶16

12.Ram Dular Prasad S/o Puranmasi, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 13636, Gas Cutter In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Balaji Nagar Zone-I I Khursipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶17

13.Ramji Netam, S/o Late Govardhan, Aged About 59 Years Camp I I, P. No. 44728, Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Krishna Chowk, Sharda Para, Camp I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶18

¶19

14.Churamanlal Nayak, S/o Shri Pusau Ram, Aged About 61 Years P. No. 46513, Lineman In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Near Poonam Talkies, Southi Nagar, P. O. Bhilai-3, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶20

15.Bindeshwari Singh, S/o Shri Moti Singh, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 10090, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Singh Kirana Stor, Bapu Nagar, Khursipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶21

16.Jagannath Ram, S/o Late G. Ram, Aged About 60 Years P. No. 12468, Fitter In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Balaji Nagar, Zone I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶22

17.Harsh Nath Rai, S/o Late D. S. Rai, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 44298 S E O, H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Sangram Chowk, Camp - I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶23

18.Ram Dayal Mahto S/o Late R K Mahto, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 15722, Rigger V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Labour Colony, Khursipar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶24

19.Prishram Singh, S/o Gouhar, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 45326, Electrician In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Nishad Niwas, Maroda Tank, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶25

20.Deo Dhar Ram, S/o Late Barelal, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 43606, Helper, H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o H S C L Colony, Station Maroda, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶26

21.S. U. Khan, S/o A. S. Khan, Aged About 48 Years P. No. 44812, Surveyor, Gr. I In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Noor Jahan Bhawan, H. No. 175, Taj Road, Farid Nagar, P. O. Supela, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶27

22.Kulwant Singh, S/o K. Singh, Aged About 51 Years P. No. 45274, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Model Town, P. O. Neru Nagar, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶28

23.Punit Ram, S/o Itwari, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 44204, Helper In H S C L, V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Village & Post Utai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶29

24.Tula Ram, S/o Late Shiv Bagas, Aged About 53 Years P. No. 45080, Helper In H S C L, V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Rigni, P. O. Nardha, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶30

25.Ram Ashray Rai, S/o Kamla Rai, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 13677, Gas Cutter In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o H S C L Colony, Zone - I I, Khursipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶31

26.Ganga Vishnu Prasad, S/o Late Kewal Prasad, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 10170, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Santoshi Para, Camp - I I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶32

27.Shiv Balak Prasad, S/o B. R. Prasad, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 13663, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Labour Colony, Zone - I I I, Khursipara, P. O, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶33

28.Dharam Ram, S/o Sudershan, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 45977, Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Kheraha, Surdung, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶34

¶35

29.B. C. Debnath, S/o Late J. K. Das, Aged About 55 Years P. No. 45580, Fitter I I, In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Milan Chowk, Sharda Para, Camp- Ii, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶36

30.Lal Bahadur Ram, S/o Hari Nath Ram, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 11227, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Fulmati Bhawan, Baikunth Nagar, Camp - Ii, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶37

31.S. D. Ram, S/o Late Snehi Ram, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 14669, Sr. Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o C/o Sheshnath Mourya Kirana Store, Sector - I I, Zone - I I, Khursipar, P. O, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶38

32.Pandurang Pamaji Darokar, S/o Late Pamaji Darokar, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 44329, S E O In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o 2- E (T B), Sector - 4, Street - 5, P. O, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶39

33.N. B. Choudhary, S/o Late J. N. Choudhary, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 44390, S E O In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o 24 - A, Street - 28, Sector - 4, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶40

34.Ramjee Patel, S/o Late Sakharam Patel, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 45425, Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Jalebi Chowk, Jairam Kirana Store, Camp - I, P. O. Supela, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶41

35.Ram Nagina Choudhary, S/o Late Lakhu Choudhary, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 14377, S E O In H S C L , V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Sharda Para, Baikunth Nagar, Camp - I I, P. O,. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶42

36.Dhananjai Singh, S/o Late K. N. Singh, Aged About 57 Years P. No. 18302, Welder In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Shubham Electricals, Risali Bhata, B R P Back Side, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶43

37.Mukund Lal, S/o Kedar Nath, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 44316, S E O In H S C L, V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Shop No. 28- B Gurudwara Road, Camp - I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶44

38.Dalip Narayan Yadav, S/o Late B. P. Yadav, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 44537, Sarang In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Sangam Chowk, Camp - I, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶45

39.Ishwar Das, S/o Agar Das, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 45682, Watchman In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Achanakpur, P. O. Tarra, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶46

40.Mani Sah, S/o Late R. P. Sah, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 11021, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Kurud Road, Purani Basti, Kohoka, P. O. Supela, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶47

41.P. R. Bhagat, S/o Late B. R. Bhagat, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 40468, Electrician In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Khamariya Bhata, P. O. Jaora, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶48

42.Dina Nath Prasad, S/o Late R. S. Prasad, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 13884, Electrician In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o L. C. 65 - A, Khursipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶49

¶50

43.Jagdish Singh, S/o Deepa Singh, Aged About 52 Years P. No. 43440, Lineman N - 5 In H S C L, Vr On 31.5.2004 R/o C/o Salamat Pan Dukan, Khursipar, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶51

44.Mahavir Mandal, S/o Shircharan Mandal, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 10524, Gas Welder In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Sharma Kirana Store, Camp - I, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶52

45.Chhabilal, S/o Salik Ram, Aged About 53 Years P. No. 46307, Helper In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Subha Roa, Street - 43, Z. No. 4 A, Sector - 5, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶53

46.Ram Vilas Chouhan, S/o Raj Kumar Chouhan, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 42385, Mason In H S C L, V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Q. No. 6 F, Street - 21 - A, Sector - 7, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶54

47.Laxman Singh, S/o Late C. Singh, Aged About 52 Years P. No. 46521, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Mohan Tent House, Shantipara, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶55

48.Kishori Lal, S/o Ram Prasad, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 44481, Rigger In H S C L, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Sinha Cycle Store, Nehru Chowk, Camp - I, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶56

49.Bali Ram, S/o Mehataru, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 44722, Helper, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Suryanagar, Station Road, Maroda, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶57

50.Jain Lal, S/o Late Pusau Ram, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 44170, Helper, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Chandsi Dawa Khana, Station Maroda, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶58

51.Kailash Thakur, S/o Sunder Thakur, Aged About 55 Years P. No. 44875, S E O, V R On 31.12.2002 R/o Near Kohoka Sanskritik Bhawan, Kohoka, P. O. Supela, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶59

52.R. K. Thakur, S/o Suba Thakur, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 17216, Portable Tool Opr., V R On 30.9.2003, R/o Near Shiv Mandir, Brinda Nagar, Camp - I, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶60

53.Bed Lal, S/o Jhumuk Lal, Aged About 54 Years P. No. 46123, Helper, V R On 31.3.2005, R/o Ghogsihdih, P. O. Khopli, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶61

54.Ahmed Ali, S/o Late Mohd. Hussain, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 16672, Electrical Fitter, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Krishna Nagar, Sayad Baba Magar, Kohoka, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶62

55.Bhagirath Das, S/o Late Gena Das, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 19908, Rigger, R/o Netaji Subhash Road, Ramnagar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶63

56.Ram Pal Bisen, S/o Late Latti Bisen, Aged About 55 Years P. No. 45325, Helper, V R On 31.01.2005, R/o Sunder Nagar, Kohoka, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶64

57.Mehtar Ram, S/o Late Sillu Ram, Aged About 56 Years P. No. 45350, Helper, V R On 30.11.2002, R/o Ramnagar, Muktidham, Debangon Pan Bhandar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶65

¶66

58.Shambhu Nath Singh, S/o Shiv Pratap Singh, Aged About 58 Years P. No. 42735, Mechanic, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o E. W S - 2012, M P H B, Industrial Area, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶67

59.Suraj Nath Choudhary, S/o Late S. K. Choudhary, Aged About 59 Years P. No. 90420, Fitter, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o 57 - B, K L C, Zone - Ii, Khursipar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶68

60.Hem Raj, S/o Late Ram Prasad, Aged About 53 Years P. No. 44561, Rigger, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Bihar Colony, New Khursipar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶69

61.Ganesh Prasad, S/o Late Mathura Seth, Aged About 60 Years P. No. 65689, Sr. Chargeman ( M ), V R On 30.11.2002 R/o 91 - C, Ruabandha Sector, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶70

62.Ramayan Prasad, S/o Late Janki Prasad, Aged About 60 Years P. No. 18114, Rigger, V R On 30.11.2002 R/o Near Kunti Public School, Brinda Nagar, Camp - I, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶71

63.Smt. Sudhia, W/o Late Kartik Yadav, P. No. 43818, Armature Winder, V R On 30.11.2002, Ramnagar, Budhdha Chowk, P. O. And Distt. Raipur (C. G.) (Since The Husband Has Expired After V R, The Wife Is Made The Petitioner)

¶72

---- Petitioners

¶73

Versus

¶74

Hindusthan Steel Works Construction Ltd. Through Chairman - Cum - Managing Director, 5/1, Commissariat Road, Hastings Kolkata

¶75

Hindusthan Steelworks Construction Ltd ( Unit At Bhilai ) Through General Manager, P. O. Bhilai, Distt. Durg (C. G.)

¶76

---- Respondents

¶77

For Petitioners : Mr. Uttam Pandey, Advocate. For Respondents : Mr. Vinod Deshmukh, Advocate

¶78

Hon’ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal

¶79

Order on Board

¶80

04/09/2015

¶81

1. Learned counsel appearing for the parties jointly submit that the dispute involved in the instant writ petition is finally covered by the decision rendered by this Court in Writ Petition No.02/2001 affirmed in Writ Appeal Nos.574 & 575 of 2013 and also by W.P.(S) No.3499/2006, therefore, the present writ petition may be disposed of in terms of the aforesaid decisions of

¶82

¶83

this Court.

¶84

2 . This Court in case of Rudal Yadav Vs. Hindustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. and others 1 states as under:-

¶85

“4. Considering the rival submissions of the parties, the present writ petitions disposed of directing the petitioner to file a detailed representation before respondent No. 1 & 3 within one month form today along with a copy of this order and that of the orders passed in Writ petition No. 02 /2001 and Writ Appeal No. 64 of 2014. In the eventuality of filing any such representation by the petitioner, respondents No. 1 to 3 are directed to decide the same expeditiously, preferable within a period of six months form the date of receipt of the representation, in accordance with law considering all aspects of the case including the eligibility of the petitioner as observed by this Court in Writ petition No. 02/2001. The respondents are further directed to release the back–log salary of the petitioner as mentioned in Annexure R/2 after adjusting all dues relating to quarter of the company. The petitioner is also directed to vacate the quarter within two months form the date of receipt of the back-log salary as mentioned in Annexure R/2 after adjusting all dues relating to quarter. In case, the petitioner does not vacate the quarter even after receipt of the back-log salary, the respondents would be at liberty to take recourse to the proceedings available under the law.”

¶86

3 . Accepting the submissions made by the parties, in terms of the above orders and also in terms of the order dated 11.2.2015 passed in W.P. (S) No.3499/2006 (Rudal Yadav Vs. Hundustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. and others), this writ petition stands disposed of. Order passed in Rudal Yadav (surpa) be made part of this order. No order as to cost(s).

¶87

4 . Certified copy as per rules.

¶88

Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal) JUDGE

¶89

B/-

¶90

1 W.P. (S) No.3499/2006 decided on 1.2.2015

Awadh Bihari Singh, v. Hindusthan Steel Works Construction Ltd.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Awadh Bihari Singh, v. Hindusthan Steel Works Construction Ltd.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Jamuna Bai Vs State of Chhattisgarh

C.R.kamlesh Vs Smt.kunti Kamlesh And Ors.

Smt.kunti Kamlesh And Ors. Vs C.r.kamlesh

Mangan and Ors. Vs State of Chhattisgarh

A.K.Bhattacharjee and Ors. Vs Hindustan Steel Work Construction andANR

Shivraj Vs State Of Chhattisgarh