Disposed

Mithun Roy v. State of West Bengal and Ors.

Calcutta HC5 Dec 2024MAT/1706/2024

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Teacher's transfer application stalled after suspension of the Utsashree Online Portal; writ petition was dismissed. The Division Bench held that suspension of the portal does not extinguish the statutory right to seek transfer, set aside the impugned order, and directed manual processing of the application within two months.

What did the court decide?

Impugned order set aside; appellant to submit downloaded transfer application to school authorities within one week; authorities to process it manually, issue NOC and forward to the Commission, comple

Mithun Roy Vs State of West Bengal and Ors. — Service and Employment | Calcutta HC (2024)

¶1

FORM NO. J (2)

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE

¶3

Present:

¶4

THE HON’BLE JUSTICE HARISH TANDON

¶5

And

¶6

THE HON’BLE JUSTICE PRASENJIT BISWAS

MAT 1706 OF 2024

with

CAN 2 OF 2024

MITHUN ROY

Vs.

THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

¶13

FOR THE APPELALNT : MR. SAKTI PADA JANA, ADVOCATE MR. SUBHAJYOTI DAS, ADVOCATE MRS. SUDIPTA PRAMANIK, ADVOCATE FOR THE STATE : MRS. JHUMA CHAKRABORTY, ADVOCATE MR. ARITRA GHOSH, ADVOCATE FOR THE CENTRAL : MR. SOURAV MITRA, ADVOCATE SCHOOL SERVICE COMMISSION HEARD ON : DECEMBER 05, 2024 JUDGMENT ON : DECEMBER 05, 2024 THE COURT:

¶14

The writ petition was dismissed solely on the ground that “Utsashree Online Portal” is under suspension. The grievance of the appellant relates to keeping an application for transfer on general ground in suspended animation as no decision was taken thereupon by the competent authorities.

¶15

The learned Single Judge observed that though the application has reached to the West Bengal School Service Commission, but no decision has taken thereupon, which according to the appearing counsels, is factually incorrect.

¶16

What is discerned from the respective submissions of the counsels is that the application filed by the appellant was uploaded on the said portal, but, thereafter no steps were taken thereupon and in the mean time, the State

¶17

CT-08 DL-23 ID-266048 RBHAR

¶18

Page 1

¶19

(MAT 1706 OF 2024 – DISPOSED OF – 05.12.2024 - THURSDAY)

¶20

Government has taken a conscious decision to suspend the operation of the said portal.

¶21

The right to apply for transfer is recognized in the statutory Rules which has neither been amended nor repealed by a subsequent legislation.

¶22

A teacher is entitled to seek for a transfer and such right emanates from the statutory provisions. It is obligatory on the part of the authorities concerned to take a conscious decision thereupon.

¶23

All the counsels before us are uniform in their submissions that mere suspension of the said “Utsashree Online Portal” does not ipso facto suspend the rights conferred by a statutory provision and, therefore, the entitlement to seek transfer by making an application cannot be undermined nor be taken away.

¶24

There is no quarrel to the proposition of law, but once the statute creates a right for seeking transfer by a teacher, mere devise to the means of access to such entitlement is only for the administrative convenience and subsequently, if such facilities are suspended, it do not take away the statutory right bestowed upon the teacher under the West Bengal School Service Commission (General Transfer, Transfer on Special Grounds and Reallocation) Rules, 2015.

¶25

There is a fundamental distinction between a means and/or facilities provided by the authorities to exercise the statutory right conferred upon the teacher and the right recognized in the statute and the Rules provided in dealing with such applications.

¶26

Mere suspension of the facilities and/or access cannot ipso facto repeal the statutory provisions nor can curtail such statutory right and therefore, it is obligatory on the part of the State to take a conscious decision on the application made by the appellant. Even if the portal is suspended, there is no difficulty on the part of the State or the Commission to take a printout of the said application and can process the same manually strictly in terms of the statutory Rules and/or Act provided in this regard.

¶27

The order impugned is, thus, set aside.

¶28

We, hereby, direct the appellant to submit the downloaded copy of an application from the said portal and shall annex the documents which form part of an attachment to the said application at the time of uploading the

¶29

CT-08 DL-02 ID-266048 RBHAR

¶30

Page 2

¶31

(MAT 1706 OF 2024 – DISPOSED OF – 05.12.2024 - THURSDAY)

¶32

same, when the portal was active, to the school authorities within one week from date.

¶33

The school authorities shall take a conscious decision on the said application and being satisfied shall issue a No Objection Certificate and also forward all such documents to the concerned D.I. of Schools (S.E.), Uttar Dinajpur who shall, thereafter, forward the same to the West Bengal School Service Commission for making the appropriate recommendation.

¶34

It goes without saying that all the authorities shall strictly adhere to the statutory procedures and/or norms provided for each tier of the mechanism for processing the transfer application.

¶35