Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi — Bombay HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi — Bombay HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

Plaintiffs in the group matters (other than Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) Nos.5971 of 2023, 9196 of 2023, 16599/2023 and 23424/2023, which are already disposed of on consent terms) are granted six weeks to remove office objections; failing removal within that period the suits shall be dismissed without further reference to the Court; if the objections are removed in time, the suits shall be taken up for consideration in due course.

Issue for consideration

Whether the order passed on 04.02.2025 applies to the suits already disposed of on consent terms, namely Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) Nos.5971 of 2023, 9196 of 2023, 16599/2023 and 23424/2023. +1 more

Court's answer

In all the other matters, the plaintiffs are granted time of six weeks to remove the office objections, failing which the suits shall be dismissed without further reference to the Court.

Ratio / Principle

The order dated 04.02.2025 does not apply to Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) Nos.5971 of 2023, 9196 of 2023, 16599/2023 and 23424/2023, which stand already disposed of on the basis of consent terms.

Key takeaways

If the office objections are removed within the stipulated period of time, the suits shall be taken up for consideration in due course.ratio¶196

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

Bombay High Court, Commercial Division (Manish Pitale, J.), order dated 04.02.2025 in COMIP(L)/255/2023 and a large group of connected Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) matters along with Interim Applications (IA(L)), Commercial Revision Applications (CRR) and Lodging Petitions (LPETN): (i) the Court noted that Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) Nos.5971 of 2023, 9196 of 2023, 16599/2023 and 23424/2023 had already been disposed of on the basis of consent terms, and directed that the order passed that day shall not apply to those matters; (ii) in all the other matters, the plaintiffs were granted six weeks to remove office objections, failing which the suits were to be dismissed without further reference to the Court; (iii) if the office objections were removed within the stipulated period, the suits were to be taken up for consideration in due course.

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION IN ITS COMMERCIAL DIVISION

COMIP(L)/255/2023 a/w. IA(L)/1260/2025 a/w. IA(L)/24372/2023, a/w. CRR/390/2023 a/w. CRR/273/2023, COMIP(L)/372/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/5188/2023 a/w. IA(L)/5414/2023 a/w. IA(L)/400/2023, COMIP(L)/2010/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/2313/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/2529/2023,

COMIP(L)/2044/2023 a/w. IA(L) 2249/2023, COMIP(L) 2300/2023 a/w. IA(L)/2394/2023, COMIP(L)/2610/2023 a/w. CRR/206/2023,

COMIP(L)/2744/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/2986/2023 a/w. IA(L)/2982/2023, COMIP(L)/3091/2023 a/w. CRR/92/2023 a/w. IA(L)/3340/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)3213/2023, COMIP(L)/3457/2023 a/w. IA(L)/3545/2023, COMIP(L)/3632/2023 a/w. IA(L)/19551/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4522/2023, COMIP(L)/3958/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4398/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4428/2023,

COMIP(L)/4008/2023 a/w. CRR/100/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4208/2023,

COMIP(L)/4045/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4217/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/4285/2023 a/w. CRR/144/2023 a/w. CRR/111/2023, COMIP(L)/4086/2023 a/w. CRR/108/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4571/2023, COMIP(L)/4256/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/4471/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/4610/2023, COMIP(L)/4257/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/4404/2023

a/w. IA(L)/4341/2023, COMIP(L)/4369/2023, COMIP(L)/4385/2023 a/w. IA(L)/4597/2023,

COMIP(L)/4810/2023 a/w. CRR/233/2023 a/w. CRR/155/2023, COMIP(L)/4841/2023 a/w. IA(L)/5819/2023 a/w. CRR/22/2024 a/w. IA(L)/5125/2023 a/w. CRR/169/2023, COMIP(L)/5195/2023

a/w. IA(L)/5956/2023, COMIP(L)/5500/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/5992/2023, COMIP(L)/5536/2023 a/w. CRR/182/2023, COMIP(L)/5537/2023 a/w. IA(L)/5603/2023 a/w. CRR/145/2023

a/w. LPETN(L)/5756/2023, COMIP(L)/5971/2023 a/w.

CRR/146/2023, COMIP(L)/6505/2023 a/w. IA(L)/9016/2023, COMIP(L)/6898/2023 a/w. IA(L)/6911/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/18923/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/6964/2023 a/w. CRR/218/2023 a/w. CRR/160/2023, COMIP(L)/6924/2023 a/w. CRR/162/2023

a/w. LPETN(L)/7008/2023 a/w. IA(L)/7064/2023, COMIP(L)/7101/2023 a/w. IA(L)/7196/2023,

COMIP(L)/7460/2023 a/w. CRR/58/2025 a/w. IA(L)/7491/2023 a/w. CRR/163/2023, COMIP(L)/7603/2023 a/w. CRR/170/2023

1/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

a/w. LPETN(L)/8039/2023 a/w. IA(L)/7798/2023, COMIP(L)/7657/2023 a/w. IA(L)/7783/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/7773/2023, COMIP(L)/8131/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/8314/2023 a/w. IA(L)/8393/2023, COMIP(L)/8132/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18147/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/15449/2023 a/w. IA(L)/8225/2023, COMIP(L)/8961/2023 a/w. IA(L)/10017/2023, COMIP(L)/9027/2023 a/w. CRR/166/2023

a/w. LPETN(L)/9121/2023, COMIP(L)/9191/2023 a/w.

CRR/185/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/9660/2023 a/w. IA(L)/9725/2023, COMIP(L)/9196/2023 a/w. CRR/177/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/9263/2023, COMIP(L)/9455/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/9859/2023 a/w. IA(L)/9861/2023,

COMIP(L)/9816/2023, COMIP(L)/10197/2023 a/w. CRR/194/2023 a/w. IA(L)/11074/2023, COMIP(L)/10238/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/10257/2023, COMIP(L)/10481/2023 a/w. IA(L)/10765/2023, COMIP(L)/10745/2023 a/w. CRR/209/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/10898/2023, COMIP(L)/10789/2023 a/w.

CRR/196/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/10871/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/10874/2023, COMIP(L)/11383/2023, COMIP(L)/11751/2023

a/w. IA(L)/19764/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21986/2023,

COMIP(L)/11788/2023 a/w. CRR/212/2023 a/w. CRR/404/2023

a/w. LPETN(L)/11936/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22183/2023 a/w. IA(L)/11911/2023, COMIP(L)/12106/2023,

COMIP(L)/12207/2023, COMIP(L)/12213/2023,

COMIP(L)/12232/2023 a/w. CRR/203/2023,

COMIP(L)/12235/2023, COMIP(L)/13067/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/13170/2023 a/w. IA(L)/13179/2023 a/w.

CRR/229/2023, COMIP(L)/13096/2023, COMIP(L)/13810/2023

a/w. IA(L)/13969/2023 a/w. IA(L)/29983/2023,

COMIP(L)/13824/2023 a/w. IA(L)/13958/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/13962/2023 a/w. COMIP(L)/24906/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/24976/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33193/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33188/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/25068/2023, COMIP(L)/13945/2023,

COMIP(L)/13953/2023 a/w. IA(L)/14329/2023,

COMIP(L)/14159/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/14162/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/14968/2023, COMIP(L)/14629/2023 a/w. IA(L)/14690/2023,

COMIP(L)/14766/2023 a/w. CRR/228/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/14858/2023 a/w. IA(L)/14861/2023, COMIP(L)/14901/2023 a/w. IA(L)/15208/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/16604/2023, COMIP(L)/15271/2023 a/w.

2/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

IA(L)/15330/2023 a/w. CRR/241/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/15314/2023, COMIP(L)/15788/2023 a/w. IA(L)/15942/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/15887/2023 a/w.

CRR/227/2023, COMIP(L)/15865/2023 a/w. IA(L)/16219/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/16218/2023 a/w. CRR/264/2023, COMIP(L)/15922/2023, COMIP(L)/16024/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/16049/2023, COMIP(L)/16252/2023 a/w. CRR/250/2023 a/w. IA(L)/16335/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/16336/2023, COMIP(L)/16387/2023 a/w. CRR/257/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/16440/2023 a/w. IA(L)/16438/2023,

COMIP(L)/16407/2023 a/w. CRR/258/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/16418/2023, COMIP(L)/16599/2023 a/w. CRR/266/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/16710/2023, COMIP(L)/16756/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17230/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/17307/2023,

COMIP(L)/17015/2023 a/w. IA(L)/25432/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/21996/2023, COMIP(L)/17139/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17149/2023, COMIP(L)/17341/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/17994/2023 a/w.

CRR/278/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17729/2023, COMIP(L)/17344/2023

a/w. IA(L)/17928/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/17904/2023, COMIP(L)/17416/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17466/2023,

COMIP(L)/17623/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17905/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/17906/2023, COMIP(L)/17646/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/23141/2023, COMIP(L)/17691/2023 a/w. IA(L)/17759/2023, COMIP(L)/17913/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18162/2023,

COMIP(L)/17916/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/18109/2023, COMIP(L)/17925/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18167/2023, COMIP(L)/18000/2023 a/w. IA(L)/20621/2023,

COMIP(L)/18297/2023 a/w. IA(L)/24434/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/18426/2023 a/w. CRR/119/2024,

COMIP(L)/18482/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/18606/2023,

COMIP(L)/18620/2023 a/w. IA(L)/19036/2023,

COMIP(L)/18644/2023, COMIP(L)/18788/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/19034/2023, COMIP(L)/18877/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18924/2023

a/w. CRR/305/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/19196/2023,

COMIP(L)/18901/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18925/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/19202/2023 a/w. CRR/312/2023,

COMIP(L)/18911/2023 a/w. CRR/322/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/19216/2023 a/w. IA(L)/19279/2023,

COMIP(L)/18930/2023 a/w. IA(L)/9623/2024 a/w.

IA(L)/8895/2024 a/w. IA(L)/19684/2023, COMIP(L)/19750/2023

3/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

a/w. IA(L)/20946/2023, COMIP(L)/19758/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28280/2024 a/w. IA(L)/19983/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/19921/2023 a/w. CRR/339/2023, COMIP(L)/19865/2023 a/w. CRR/321/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/19991/2023 a/w. IA(L)/20138/2023, COMIP(L)/19913/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/19998/2023 a/w. CRR/318/2023 a/w. IA(L)/19995/2023, COMIP(L)/20230/2023, COMIP(L)/20248/2023 a/w. IA(L)/20629/2023, COMIP(L)/20251/2023, COMIP(L)/20254/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/20489/2023 a/w. IA(L)/20500/2023 a/w. IA(L)/32267/2023 a/w. CRR/327/2023, COMIP(L)/20359/2023

a/w. IA(L)/20473/2023 a/w. CRR/371/2023, COMIP(L)/21079/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/21353/2023 a/w. IA(L)/2240/2024 a/w. CRR/338/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21351/2023, COMIP(L)/21306/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21497/2023, COMIP(L)/21492/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21609/2023, COMIP(L)/21600/2023 a/w. CRR/347/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/21912/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21910/2023, COMIP(L)/21605/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/21845/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21846/2023 a/w. CRR/350/2023, COMIP(L)/21617/2023

a/w. IA(L)/21905/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33961/2024 a/w.

LPETN(L)/22747/2023, COMIP(L)/21695/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35149/2024 a/w. IA(L)/21920/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/21947/2023, COMIP(L)/21843/2023 a/w.

CRR/360/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21972/2023, COMIP(L)/21853/2023 a/w. IA(L)/19188/2024 a/w. IA(L)/22226/2023 a/w.

CRR/373/2023, COMIP(L)/21883/2023, COMIP(L)/21887/2023

a/w. IA(L)/22131/2023 a/w. CRR/328/2023,

COMIP(L)/21944/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22002/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/22001/2023 a/w. CRR/342/2023,

COMIP(L)/22068/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22541/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/22975/2023 a/w. CRR/356/2023, COMIP(L)/22188/2023 a/w. CRR/367/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/22285/2023, COMIP(L)/22195/2023 a/w. CRR/361/2023

a/w. IA(L)/22309/2023, COMIP(L)/22293/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/22359/2023 a/w. CRR/355/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/22343/2023, COMIP(L)/22320/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/22574/2023 a/w. CRR/385/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/22579/2023, COMIP(L)/22339/2023, COMIP(L)/22356/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22640/2023, COMIP(L)/22481/2023 a/w.

4/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

COMIP(L)/5109/2024 a/w. CRR/352/2023, COMIP(L)/22556/2023 a/w. CRR/366/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22797/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/25455/2024, COMIP(L)/22588/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22743/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/22739/2023 a/w. CRR/379/2023,

COMIP(L)/22810/2023, COMIP(L)/22868/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22868/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22898/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/22932/2023, COMIP(L)/22973/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/2498/2024 a/w. IA(L)/23172/2023 a/w. CRR/380/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/28688/2023, COMIP(L)/23085/2023, COMIP(L)/23292/2023 a/w. CRR/376/2023,

COMIP(L)/23388/2023 a/w. CRR/265/2024 a/w.

LPETN(L)/24071/2023, COMIP(L)/23424/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/23638/2023 a/w. CRR/375/2023,

COMIP(L)/23473/2023 a/w. IA(L)/13127/2024 a/w.

IA(L)/13397/2024 a/w. IA(L)/13268/2024 a/w. IA(L)/8719/2024 a/w. IA(L)/8247/2024 a/w. IA(L)/7980/2024 a/w.

IA(L)/24015/2023, COMIP(L)/24103/2023, COMIP(L)/24330/2023 a/w. IA(L)/24518/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/24514/2023 a/w.

CRR/381/2023, COMIP(L)/24344/2023 a/w. IA(L)/24666/2023 a/w. CRR/383/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/24667/2023,

COMIP(L)/24481/2023 a/w. IA(L)/24595/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/24673/2023, COMIP(L)/24789/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/24923/2023, COMIP(L)/24974/2023 a/w. CRR/412/2023 a/w. IA(L)/24999/2023, COMIP(L)/25033/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/25170/2023, COMIP(L)/25205/2023 a/w. IA(L)/37580/2024 a/w. IA(L)/37401/2024 a/w. IA(L)/25477/2023 a/w.

CRR/434/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/25629/2023 a/w. CRR/67/2024, COMIP(L)/25338/2023, COMIP(L)/25340/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/25492/2023 a/w. IA(L)/25488/2023 a/w.

CRR/411/2023, COMIP(L)/25620/2023 a/w. CRR/440/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/25785/2023, COMIP(L)/25635/2023 a/w. IA(L)/25638/2023,

COMIP(L)/25724/2023 a/w. IA(L)/26017/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/25937/2023 a/w. CRR/496/2023,

COMIP(L)/25766/2023 a/w. IA(L)/29256/2023,

COMIP(L)/25799/2023, COMIP(L)/25829/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/25906/2023, COMIP(L)/25873/2023 a/w. IA(L)/25915/2023, COMIP(L)/26056/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33190/2023 a/w.

CRR/427/2023 a/w. IA(L)/26691/2023, COMIP(L)/26272/2023 a/w. CRR/420/2023 a/w. IA(L)/26689/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/26373/2023, COMIP(L)/26500/2023 a/w.

5/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

LPETN(L)/26918/2023 a/w. CRR/426/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/26713/2023, COMIP(L)/26602/2023 a/w. IA(L)/27523/2023, COMIP(L)/26934/2023, COMIP(L)/27056/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/27184/2023 a/w. CRR/436/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/27185/2023, COMIP(L)/27330/2023 a/w. IA(L)/15682/2024, COMIP(L)/27488/2023 a/w. IA(L)/27620/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/27680/2023 a/w. IA(L)/21371/2024 a/w. CRR/209/2024 a/w. CRR/185/2024, COMIP(L)/27543/2023 a/w. CRR/441/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/27726/2023 a/w. IA(L)/27724/2023, COMIP(L)/27871/2023 a/w. IA(L)/2479/2024 a/w.

IA(L)/2480/2024 a/w. IA(L)/27898/2023, COMIP(L)/27974/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28268/2023 a/w. LPTEN(L)/28288/2023 a/w. CRR/455/2023, COMIP(L)/27982/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/28274/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28277/2023 a/w. CRR/84/2024, COMIP(L)/28036/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28270/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/28301/2023 a/w. CRR/131/2024,

COMIP(L)/28275/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28392/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/28393/2023 a/w. CRR/451/2023,

COMIP(L)/28363/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28569/2023,

COMIP(L)/28453/2023 a/w. IA(L)/28562/2023 a/w. CRR/456/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/28533/2023,

COMIP(L)/28714/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/28878/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/28960/2023 a/w. CRR/475/2023, COMIP(L)/28861/2023

a/w. IA(L)/29095/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/29104/2023, COMIP(L)/29260/2023 a/w. IA(L)/30251/2023 a/w.

CRR/489/2023, COMIP(L)/29378/2023 a/w. IA(L)/29615/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/29420/2023 a/w. CRR/445/2023,

COMIP(L)/29762/2023 a/w. CRR/82/2024 a/w. IA(L)/29982/2023 a/w. CRR/446 of 2023, COMIP(L)/29767/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/29889/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/29993/2023 a/w. CRR/65/2024

a/w. CRR/464/2023, COMIP(L)/29772/2023,

COMIP(L)/30195/2023 a/w. IA(L)/30262/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/30263/2023, COMIP(L)/30209/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/30438/2023 a/w. CRR/449/2023, COMIP(L)/30426/2023

a/w. IA(L)/30507 OF 2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/30497/2023,

COMIP(L)/30722/2023 a/w. CRR/486/2023 a/w. IA(L)/30755/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/30758/2023, COMIP(L)/31085/2023 a/w. IA(L)/31221 of 2023, COMIP(L)/31109/2023 a/w. IA(L)/31125 of 2023, COMIP(L)/31223/2023 a/w. IA(L)/31282/2023 a/w.

6/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

CRR/466/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34550 of 2023, COMIP(L)/31504/2023 a/w. IA(L)/31827 of 2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/31710/2023,

COMIP(L)/31774/2023 a/w. IA(L)/32382/2023 a/w. CRR/3/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/32380 of 2023, COMIP(L)/32040/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/32335/2023 a/w. CRR/6/2024 a/w. IA(L)/32771/2023, COMIP(L)/33742/2023 a/w. IA(L)/9001/2024 a/w. CRR/40/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/33831/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33856/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/33829/2023, COMIP(L)/33765/2023 a/w. IA(L)/33874/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/33887/2023 a/w. CRR/86/2024, COMIP(L)/33977/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34084/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/34087/2023 a/w. CRR/51/2024, COMIP(L)/34017/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34099/2023 a/w. CRR/44/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/34101/2023, COMIP(L)/34116/2023, COMIP(L)/34200/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34258/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/34287/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34282/2023 a/w. CRR/38/2024, COMIP(L)/34263/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34321/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/25077/2024, COMIP(L)/34317/2023 a/w. IA(L)/11706/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/34392/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34390/2023 a/w. CRR/50/2024, COMIP(L)/34318/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34393/2023 a/w. CRR/52/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/34394/2023, COMIP(L)/34502/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34786/2023 a/w. IA(L)/18187/2024 a/w. CRR/72/2024

a/w. LPETN(L)/34789/2023, COMIP(L)/34566/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34712/2023 a/w. CRR/49/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/34671/2023, COMIP(L)/34571/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34906/2023 a/w. CRR/98/2024

a/w. LPETN(L)/34907/2023, COMIP(L)/34601/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/34684/2023, COMIP(L)/34652/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34803/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/34802/2023 a/w. CRR/56/2024, COMIP(L)/34711/2023 a/w. IA(L)/34944/2023,

COMIP(L)/34905/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35172/2023 a/w. CRR/61/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/35581/2023, COMIP(L)/34947/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35235/2023 a/w. LPETN(L)/35330/2023 a/w.

CRR/292/2024, COMIP(L)/35079/2023, COMIP(L)/35309/2023 a/w. IA(L)/22715/2024 a/w. IA(L)/35432/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/22272/2024 a/w. CRR/59/2024, COMIP(L)/35311/2023 a/w.

LPETN(L)/35455/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35434/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/21467/2024 a/w. IA(L)/22751/2024 a/w. CRR/74/2024, COMIP(L)/35315/2023 a/w. CRR/60/2024 a/w. IA(L)/12098/2024

a/w. LPETN(L)/35450/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35431/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/21937/2024, COMIP(L)/35347/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35426/2023 a/w. CRR/97/2024, COMIP(L)/35465/2023,

7/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

COMIP(L)/35466/2023 a/w. IA(L)/31891/2024 a/w. CRR/73/2024, COMIP(L)/35502/2023 a/w. IA(L)/35570/2023 a/w. CRR/62/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/35579/2023, COMIP(L)/35592/2023 a/w.

IA(L)/35625/2023, COMIP(L)/36054/2023, COMIP(L)/36110/2023 & COMIP(L)/36316/2023 a/w. IA(L)/111/2024 a/w. LPETN(L)/113/2024 a/w. CRR/219/2024

Ms. Janhvi Chadha a/w. Ms. Preeta Panthaki and Mr. Atif Sayyed, i/b. Krishna & Saurastri Associates LLP for plaintiff in COMIP(L)/2010/2023.

Ms. Neeti Nihal, i/b. Saikrishna & Associates for defendant No.2 in COMIP(L)/2010/2023, for defendant No.8 in COMIP(L)/8132/2023, defendant No.2 in COMIP(L)/11383/2023 and defendant No.4 in COMIP(L)/25829/2023.

Mr. Minesh Andharia a/w. Mr. Atif Sayyed, i/b. Krishna & Saurastri Associates LLP for plaintiffs in COMIP(L)/4045/2023, COMIP(L)/4257/2023, COMIP(L)/18877/2023, COMIP(L)/18901/2023, COMIP(L)/25205/2023 and COMIP(L)/29767/2023.

Mr. Rahul Punjabi for defendant in COMIP(L)/5500/2023.

Ms. Chinmayee Ghag, i/b. Zastriya for plaintiff in COMIP(L)/6505/2023.

Ms. Tanvi Nandgaonkar, i/b. Bar and Brief Attorneys for plaintiffs in COMIP(L)/8132/2023 and COMIP(L)/21492/2023.

Mr. Rishi Mody a/w. Ms. Archi Gala, Ms. Sanjana Krishnasarma, i/b. VMH & Associates for defendant No.4 in COMIP(L)/8132/2023.

Ms. Niyati Fatehpuria,i/b. Saikrishna & Associates for defendant No.7 in COMIP(L)/8132/2023 and COMIP(L)/14629/2023 and defendant No.6 in COMIP(L)25289/2023.

Mr. Nishad Kulkarni a/w. Mr. Aasif Navodia, Ms. Khushboo Jhunjhunwala, Ms. Jaanvi Chopra and Ms. Rakshita Singh, i/b. Khaitan & Co. for plaintiffs in COMIP(L)/13067/2023, COMIP(L)/15788/2023, COMIP(L)/21843/2023 and COMIP(L)/22293/2023.

Ms. Pratiksha P. Thakur a/w. Mr. Hiren Trivedi (through videoconferencing) for defendant in COMIP(L)/15865/2023.

C. Keswani a/w. M. Sharma for defendant No.3 COMIP(L)/17139/2023 and defendant No.2 in COMIP(L)/24789/2023.

Ms. Mansi Kaku a/w. Ms. Nikita Rathi, i/b. Solaris Legal for defendant No.7 in COMIP(L)/17916/2023.

Ms. Drshika Hemnani, i/b. Jhangiani Narula & Associates for applicant in IA(L)/9623/2024.

Mr. Shrey Fatterpekar a/w. Ms. Nirav Shah, Mr. Vivek Singh and Ms. Digisha M., i/b. Solicis Lex for defendant Nos.1, 2, 3 and 12 in COMIP(L)/22973/2023.

8/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

Ms. Shailendra S. Kanetkar for plaintiffs in COMIP(L)/24103/2023.

Mr. Shrikant Rathi for defendant in COMIP(L)/25340/2023.

Mr. Farheen Mustafa, i/b. Jayesh Mestry for defendants in COMIP(L)/25635/2023 and COMIP(L)/28275/2023.

B. Bharadwaj, i/b. Saikrishna & Associates for defendant No.5 in COMIP(L)/25289/2023.

Mr. Rajuram Kuleriya for defendant No.2 in COMIP(L)/26056/2023.

Ms. Vasudha Gupta (through video-conferencing), i/b. YNA Legal for plaintiff in COMIP(L)/26602/2023.

Ms. Revati N., i/b. Ms. Shivani Shah for applicant-Bank in IA(L)/30262/2023.

Ms. Rooppreet Dhamija, i/b. Crawford Bayley & Co. for defendant in COMIP(L)/31109/2023.

Ms. Raina Gajria, i/b. Gajria & Co. for defendant Nos.2 and 3 in COMIP(L)/33977/2023.

Mr. Hiren Kamod a/w. Mr. Vaibhav Keni, Ms. Neha Iyer and Ms. Proutima Ray, i/b. Legasis Partners for plaintiffs in COMIPL/2744/2023, COMIP(L)/3091/2023, COMIP(L)/4008/2023, COMIP(L)/4256/2023, COMIP(L)/9191/2023, COMIP(L)/13824/2023, COMIP(L)/21079/2023, COMIP(L)/21944/2023, COMIP(L)/24330/2023, COMIP(L)/27543/2023 and COMIP(L)/34566/2023 and for defendants in COMIP(L)/14629/2023, COMIP(L)/29378/2023 and COMIP(L)/36110/2023.

Ms. Charushila Vaidya, 2^nd Assistant to the Court Receiver in COMIP(L)/255/2023, COMIP(L)/2610/2023, COMIP(L)/3091/2023, COMIP(L)/4008/2023, COMIP(L)/4045/2023, COMIP(L)/4086/2023, COMIP(L)/4810/2023, COMIP(L)/4841/2023, COMIP(L)/5536/2023, COMIP(L)/5537/2023, COMIP(L)/5971/2023, COMIP(L)/6898/2023, COMIP(L)/6924/2023, COMIP(L)/7460/2023, COMIP(L)/7603/2023, COMIP(L)/8131/2023, COMIP(L)/9027/2023, COMIP(L)/9191/2023, COMIP(L)/9196/2023, COMIP(L)/10197/2023, COMIP(L)/10745/2023, COMIP(L)/10789/2023 and COMIP(L)/11788/2023.

CORAM : MANISH PITALE, J. DATE : 04^th FEBRUARY, 2025

P.C. :

. Amongst these matters, it is found that Commercial IP Suit (Lodging) Nos.5971 of 2023, 9196 of 2023, 16599/2023 and 23424/2023, have been already disposed of on the basis of the

9/10

67-278_COMIPL_255_23 & group.doc

consent terms. The order being passed today shall not apply to the said matters.

As regards, all the other matters, the plaintiffs are granted time of six weeks to remove the office objections, failing which the suits shall be dismissed without further reference to the Court.

In the event, the office objections are removed within stipulated period of time, the suits shall be taken up for consideration in due course.

(MANISH PITALE, J)

Priya Kambli

Signed by: Priya Kambli Designation: PA To Honourable Judge Date: 06/02/2025 14:41:20

10/10