Allowed

Vijay S/O Ramratan Jaiswal v. the State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Amravati and 2 Others

Bombay HC23 Apr 2024FA/623/2012

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Appellant appealed against an award of Rs.18.28 lakhs for land acquired for a Sewerage Treatment Plant. The Reference Court allowed a higher claim but capped compensation at the claimed limit. This court allowed the appeal, directing respondents to pay the full additional compensation of Rs.51,466/- determined as entitled. The court relied on a Co-ordinate Bench decision.

What did the court decide?

Respondents directed to pay additional compensation of Rs.51,466/- with statutory benefits to be deposited within four months from the date of uploading the order.

Vijay S/O Ramratan Jaiswal Vs the State of Maharashtra… — Land Acquisition | Bombay HC (2024)

¶1

2024:BHC-NAG:5123

¶2

1.FA.623.2012. Judgment.odt

¶3

¶4

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

¶5

FIRST APPEAL NO. 623 OF 2012

¶6

APPELLANT

¶7

: Vijay S/o. Ramratan Jaiswal, Aged 46 Years, Occ. Agriculturist, R/o. Bhaji Bazar, Amravati.

¶8

//VERSUS//

¶9

RESPONDENTS : 1. The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Amravati.

¶10

The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Upper Wardha Project No.4, Collector Office, Amravati, Tq. & Distt. Amravati.

¶11

The Deputy Director, Town Planning, Amravati, Municipal Corporation, Amravati, Tq. & Distt. Amravati.

¶12

¶13

Mr. S.S. Shingane, Advocate for the Appellant. Ms. Kavita H. Bhondge, AGP for Respondent Nos.1 & 2. Mr. A.P. Kalmegh, Advocate for Respondent No.3.

¶14

************************************************************** CORAM : G. A. SANAP, J. DATED : 23rd APRIL , 2024.

¶15

ORAL JUDGMENT

¶16

. In this appeal, the appellant/claimant has challenged the judgment and award dated 2^nd March, 2012, passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Amravati (for short “the Reference Court”).

¶17

1.FA.623.2012. Judgment.odt

¶18

¶19

02] The land of the appellant bearing Survey No.38/3, admeasuring 0.91R, situated at Mouje Gambhirpur was acquired for Sewerage Treatment Plant by the Municipal Corporation, Amravati. Respondent No.2 passed the award on 27^th May, 2003 and determined the market price of the acquired land, and awarded total compensation of Rs.18,28,447/-.

¶20

03] The appellant, being aggrieved by the inadequate amount of compensation determined by respondent No.2, filed the reference before the Collector, Amravati. The Collector, Amravati, made over the reference to the Civil Court for adjudication. The Reference Court has held that the market price of the acquired land would be Rs.20,66,667 per hectare. The Reference Court further held that the appellant is entitled to get the additional compensation of Rs.5,51,466/- along with all statutory benefits. The Reference Court allowed the reference to the extent of Rs.5,00,000/-, inasmuch as the claim was restricted to Rs.5,00,000/-, though the appellant was found entitled for a compensation of Rs.5,51,466/-.

¶21

04] Learned advocate for the appellant, relying upon a decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in First Appeal No.604/2012 [Vasant S/o. Laxmanrao Dalal Vs. The State of

¶22

1.FA.623.2012. Judgment.odt

¶23

¶24

Maharashtra Through Collector, Amravati & Others, decided on 19.06.2019] , submitted that, in this case, the Co-ordinate Bench, after considering the decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the cases of Ambya Kalya Mhatre (Dead) through Lrs. and others Vs. State of Maharashtra [(2011) 9 SCC 325] and Chandrashekhar and Others Vs. Additional Special Land Acquisition Officer [(2009) 14 SCC 441], has held that though the claim was restricted by the claimant towards specific amount, the Reference Court was duty bound to direct the Authority to pay the compensation which the claimant was found entitled to get, subject to the order as to the payment of deficit court fee.

¶25

05] Learned AGP for the State as well as learned advocate for respondent No.3 have hardly any objection as to the legal position.

¶26

06] In my view, this appeal is covered by the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in First Appeal No.604/2012. The legal position, which can be culled out from the decisions in the case of Ambya Kalya Mhatre (Dead) through Lrs. and others and Chandrashekhar and Others, supports the submission advanced by learned advocate for the appellant. In view of this, the following order is passed :

¶27

1.FA.623.2012. Judgment.odt

¶28

¶29

a) The appeal is allowed .

¶30

b) The respondents are directed to pay the additional compensation of Rs.51,466/- (Rs. Fifty One Thousand Four Hundred Sixty Six Only) to the appellant with statutory benefits, provided under the Land Acquisition Act.

¶31

c) The deficit court fee has already been paid in the appeal.

¶32

d) The amount be deposited within four months from the date of uploading of this order.

¶33

07] The first appeal is disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

¶34

(G. A. SANAP, J.)

¶35

Vijay

Vijay S/O Ramratan Jaiswal v. the State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Amravati and 2 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Vijay S/O Ramratan Jaiswal v. the State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Amravati and 2 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

The Exe. Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division, Pusad, Yavatmal vs Ganesh Deosing Rathod and Others

Maha. State Electricity Generation Co. Ltd., Thr. by. Executive Engineer, Paras, Akola vs Mohd. Ayyaz Ab. Munaf and Others

The Executive Engineer, Purna Medium Project, Presently Medium Minor Irrigaion Division, Achalpur vs Ramrao Gopalrao Nahal (Dead) Thr. Lrs. Baburao S/O Ramrao Nahal and Others

Anmol S/O Shrawan Umratkar Vs the State of Maharashtra through Collector, Yavatmal and Others

V.I.D.C. through the Executive Engineer, Nimn Painganga Project Division (Bembla Project, Yavatmal) vs Shri Dattatraya Nanaji @ Narayan Yende and Others

V.I.D.C. Thr. Exe. Engineer, Canal Division, Bembla Project, Yavatmal and Another vs Chindu Narayan Thawari and Others