Sudhir Nivruttirao Paulkar Vs Sopan Madhavrao Paulkar Since Deceased through L.Rs. Jankabai Sopanrao Poulkar and Others

¶1

(1)

¶2

AO-50.2019.odt

¶3

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD

¶4

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 50 OF 2019

¶5

Sudhir Nivruttirao Paulkar (Deceased) Through legal representatives Renuka Sudhir Paulkar & others Appellants

¶6

Versus

¶7

Sopan Madhavrao Paulkar (Deceased) Through legal representatives Jankabai Sopan Paulkar & others Respondents

¶8

Mr. A.D. Wange, Advocate for the appellants. Mr. T.M. Venjane, Advocate for the respondents.

¶9

CORAM : SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE, J. Dated : 22 January 2024.

¶10

Order :

¶11

The original appellant Sudhir Paulkar, who was the original plaintiff in R.C.S. No. 180/2005, has preferred this appeal for challenging the judgment and order dated 25.09.2017 passed by the learned District Judge-1, Nilanga (hereinafter referred to as “the learned first appellate Court”) in R.C.A. No. 57/2010 whereby the learned first appellate Court has remanded the aforesaid civil suit for deciding it afresh on merit by quashing the judgment and decree dated 13.09.2010 therein of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nilanga (hereinafter referred to as “the learned trial Court”).

¶12

(2)

¶13

AO-50.2019.odt

¶14

Heard rival submissions. Also perused the

¶15

documents on record.

¶16

Learned Counsel for the appellants pointed out that though there was stay to the proceeding of R.C.S. No. 180/2005 granted by the learned Principal District Judge in one transfer petition, but it was not brought on record by the respondents, and therefore, the judgment and decree in the said suit passed by the learned trial Court was appropriate.

¶17

On the contrary, learned Counsel for the respondents/defendants, by filing certified copies of the proceedings on record, pointed out that despite stay granted by the superior Court, the learned trial Court proceeded with the suit and decided the same. As such, he supported the impugned judgment and order in R.C.A. No. 57/2010.

¶18

It is significant to note that the certified copies produced on record clearly indicate that defendant No.1 Sopan had filed transfer petition in respect of the aforesaid suit on 03.08.2010 and at that time the concerned learned Principal District Judge had granted stay to the proceeding of aforesaid suit on 04.08.2010. However, despite there being stay to the proceeding, the learned trial Court has decreed

¶19

(3)

¶20

AO-50.2019.odt

¶21

the aforesaid suit on 13.09.2010. The record shows that the defendants had already filed applications for adjournment on the ground of stay. However, it appears that the learned trial Court did not care to verify the same. As such, during pendency of stay, the act of learned trial Court of deciding the aforesaid suit was definitely not proper. Moreover, the learned first appellate Court has only remanded the matter to be decided on merit. As such, there is no finding on merit by the first appellate Court. An opportunity to the present appellants to establish their case before the learned trial Court is very much there, and therefore, this Court is of the opinion that the appellants cannot be said to be aggrieved by the impugned judgment and order of the learned first appellate Court. As such, no substance is found in the appeal and it stands dismissed. Record and proceeding be sent back to concerned Courts immediately.

¶22

(SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE, J.)

¶23

VD_Dhirde

Sudhir Nivruttirao Paulkar v. Sopan Madhavrao Paulkar Since Deceased through L.Rs. Jankabai Sopanrao Poulkar and Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Sudhir Nivruttirao Paulkar v. Sopan Madhavrao Paulkar Since Deceased through L.Rs. Jankabai Sopanrao Poulkar and Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Jammroot Bee Abdul Raheem Khan Died Lrs. Abbas Khan and Ors. Vs Bashir Khan Bhikan Khan Died Lrs. Yaqoob Khan and Ors.

Gram Panchayat Rajapur Thro Authorized Person Badshah Bikajii Hase Vs Pandurang Savleram Deshmukh Died Lrs. Vasant and Ors.

Prabhudayal Ramlal Jaiswal Vs Chitra Lalprakash Pardeshi and Another

Sudhir Nivruttirao Paulkar Vs Sopan Madhavrao Paulkar Since Deceased through L.Rs. Jankabai Sopanrao Poulkar and Others

Suresh Pundlik Wani (Sonje) Others Vs Subhash Dattatrya Wani (Musale) and Ors.

Vasant Krishnath Kave and Others Vs Shivaji Krishnath Kave and Others