Disposed
Dattaram Bala Naik v. United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. and Anr.
Bombay HCIA/1870/2021
Case brief
from the order text
What is this about?
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY…
What the court decided
AI extract
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Board Sr.No.:-21
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
COMPANY PETITION NO. 743 OF 1990
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S
Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 161 OF 2018 In COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
The Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER
V/S
Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd (in Liqn.)....RESPONDENT
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 536 OF 2016 In COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
The Collector, Thane ....PETITIONER V/S
Liquidator Of M/s Maftlal Engineering Industries Ltd. And The Court Receiver
....RESPONDENT
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 490 OF 2017 In COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Page 1/16
Nutan National Machinery Manufacturing ....PETITIONER Workers Co-operative Housing Society
V/S
The Official Liquidator, High Court, Bombay ....RESPONDENT Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2164 OF 2019 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Thane Municipal Corporation ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator ....RESPONDENT
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 162 OF 2018
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Thane Municipal Corporation Through The ....PETITIONER Commissioner
V/S
Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd. (in ....RESPONDENT Liquidation)
WITH
OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR REPORT NO. 137 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....PETITIONER Industries Ltd. (in Liquidation)
V/S
Page 2/16
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. (petitioner)
....RESPONDENT
WITH
OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR REPORT NO. 10 OF 2022 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering ....PETITIONER Industries Ltd. (in Liquidation)
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 4114 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Invest Asset Securitization And Reconstruction ....PETITIONER Pvt. Ltd.
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd And The Official ....RESPONDENT Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd And Anr
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 4915 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Chamber Constuctions Pvt. Ltd. (in Cirp) ....PETITIONER Through Resolution Professional R K Girdhar
V/S
Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering ....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd And United Metachem Pvt. Ltd.
Page 3/16
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 31865 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of M/s.mafatlal ....RESPONDENT Engineering Industries Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 26143 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Invent Assets Securitisation Reconstruction ....PETITIONER Pvt.ltd. - Applicant
V/S
Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering ....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 40504 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd And Anr
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 6635 OF 2023
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Page 4/16
Central Board Of Trustees Employees Provident....PETITIONER Fund Organisation Thane
V/S
Official Liquidaor Of Bombay High Court ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 28027 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER V/S
Maharashtra Housing And Area Development....RESPONDENT Authority And Ors
WITH
OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR REPORT NO. 33 OF 2023 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....PETITIONER Industries Ltd. (in Liquidation)
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. (petitioner) ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1012 OF 2023
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Ajit Narhari Chawathe ....PETITIONER
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH
Page 5/16
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1120 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Indumati Rajaram Khopkar (applicant) ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd.and Anr. And The ....RESPONDENT Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engg. Ind.ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1110 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Vandana Pradip Shardule (applicant) ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And The Official ....RESPONDENT Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engg Ind. Ltd. (in Liqn)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 9 OF 2017
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Nutan National Machinery Manufacturing ....PETITIONER Workers Chs (prop.)
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of M/s Mafatlal ....RESPONDENT Engineering Industries Ltd.
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 331 OF 2019
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Page 6/16
The Sub Divisional Officer,thane And Anr ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd (in Liqn) And Anr
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2014 OF 2022 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd.(pet)and Anr(rep)and....RESPONDENT Regional Provident Fund Commissioner Thane(prop Resp)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 26 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
The Sub Divisional Officer,thane And Anr. ....PETITIONER
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd(in Liquidation)
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2991 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Sharada Sanjay Gauri ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Anr ....RESPONDENT
Page 7/16
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 155 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Pravin Anant Shedge ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Another ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 163 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Blue Orbit Force (india) Pvt.ltd. - Applicant ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 153 OF 2022 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Sharad Motiram Bubera ....PETITIONER
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Ors ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 156 OF 2022
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Rajiv Prabhakar Naik ....PETITIONER V/S United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Ors ....RESPONDENT
Page 8/16
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1872 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Shushila Ganesh Khadaka ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Anr ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1873 OF 2021
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Laxmi Dnyandeo Kapurkar Widow Of Late Shri....PETITIONER Dnyandeo Bhau Kapurkar
V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Anr. ....RESPONDENT
WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1867 OF 2021 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Asset Reconstruction Company (india) Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd And Anr ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1869 OF 2021 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Chandrakant Shankar Wadekar ....PETITIONER V/S
Page 9/16
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Anr
....RESPONDENT
WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1870 OF 2021 In COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Dattaram Bala Naik ....PETITIONER V/S
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd. And Anr ....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2104 OF 2020
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Chandaben Maganlal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engg. Ind.....RESPONDENT Ltd. (in Liqn.)
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2103 OF 2020 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Vasant Shidoo Jadhav ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1815 OF 2020 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Page 10/16
Santosh Ganpat Lokhande ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Engg. Ind. Ltd. (in....RESPONDENT Liqn.)
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1386 OF 2020 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Ramdas Naga Pawar ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engg. Ind.....RESPONDENT Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1955 OF 2020 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Jayashri Anant Mhatre ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd.
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 868 OF 2020
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Cecil Jerome Rodriques - Applicant ....PETITIONER
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of Mafatlal Engineering ....RESPONDENT Industries Ltd.
Page 11/16
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 253 OF 2013
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Smt. Manisha Waman Kadwakar, W/o Of Late ....PETITIONER Shrei Waman K. Kadwadkar
V/S
The Official Liquidator, High Court Of Bombay....RESPONDENT Of M/s.mafatlal Engg.ind.ltd. In Liqn.
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1105 OF 2007
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Madhav Narayan Samarth ....PETITIONER V/S
The O. L. Of M/s. Mafatlal Engg. Ind. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1265 OF 2007
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER V/S
The O. L.. Of Mafatlal Engg.. Ind. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1307 OF 2007
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bombay Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER
Page 12/16
V/S
Official Liquidator,high Court, Bombay
....RESPONDENT
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 384 OF 2008 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Mrs. Vrunda Balakrishna Keni --a ....PETITIONER
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of M/s. Mafatlal ....RESPONDENT Engineering Industries Ltd. (in Liqun)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 679 OF 2008
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Mumbai Mazdoor Union--a ....PETITIONER V/S
The O.l. Of Mafatlal Engineering Industies Ltd.. .RESPONDENT . (in Liquidation)--r
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 624 OF 2008
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Trimbak D. Tendulkar ....PETITIONER
V/S
The O.l. Of M/s. Mafatlal Engg. Ind. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1021 OF 2008
In
Page 13/16
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Anita Co-operative Housing Society Limited. ....PETITIONER V/S
The O. L. Of Mafatlal Engineering Industries ....RESPONDENT Ltd.
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1289 OF 2008 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Bambai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER
V/S
The O.l. Of Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd... RESPONDENT . (in Liqn.)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1288 OF 2008 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Mumbai Mazdoor Union ....PETITIONER
V/S
The O.l. Of Mafatlal Engineering Industries Pvt... RESPONDENT . Ltd. (in Liqn.)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1541 OF 2008 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Kapil D. Jain And Anr. ....PETITIONER V/S
The Officail Liquidator Of M/s. Mafatlal Engg.
Page 14/16
Industries Ltd. (in Liqn.)
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1551 OF 2008 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Smt. Smita Chandrakant Kelkar ....PETITIONER V/S
The O.l. Of M/s. Mafatlal Engg. Ind Td. (in ....RESPONDENT Liqn)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1627 OF 2008
In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Sandeep Promod Shah And Anr. ....PETITIONER V/S
The Official Liquidation Of Mafatlal ....RESPONDENT Engineering Industries (in Liqn.)
WITH
COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 1247 OF 2009 In
COMPANY PETITION 743 OF 1990
Mafatlal Engineering Industries Employees ....PETITIONER Union
V/S
The Official Liquidator Of M/s. Mafatlal Engg. ..RESPONDENT . Industries Ltd. (in Liqn.)
Mentioned
Mr.Sanjay Singhvi,Senior counsel a/w Ms.Rohini.,Ms.Ashwini....RESPONDENT
Page 15/16
Rane for Applicant in I.A.(L)NOS.40504,28027/2022, and I.A.(L)No.31865/2023 Mr.Sankalp Shrivastav Ritesh Hegde and A Purushottam i/b Parth Shah for Invent Asset Mr.Ravi Rattesar for EPFO �
CORAM : HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MANISH PITALE J DATE : 13th October, 2023
P.C. : S. O. to 03/11/2023 ( at 2.30 pm).
( ASSOCIATE )
Page 16/16
United Metachem Pvt. Ltd.
Mafatlal Engineering Industries Ltd.
The Bambal Mazdoor Union
The Collector, Thane
The Official Liquidator
Thane Municipal Corporation
Manish Pitale
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court