Commercial Suit disposed based on consent terms entered between plaintiff and some defendants, who were permitted to remain in the case while others were deleted.
Suit disposed in terms of consent terms. All interim/orders vacated. Notice of motion disposed.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
coms-859-19(production).doc
1 / 65
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY AND ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION COMMERCIAL SUIT NO.859 OF 2019
WITH
COMMERCIAL NOTICE OF MOTION NO.1492 OF 2019
Mayank J Shah
..Plaintiff
Vs.
Satara Properties (India) Ltd & Ors
..Defendants
Mr. Zubin Behramkamdin a/w Mr. Aziz Khan, Mr. G. S. Sethi and Mr. Anogh
Pradhan i/b Divya Shah Associates for Plaintiff
Mr. Mayank Shah – Plaintiff present
Mr. R. K. Satpalkar a/w Ms S. Avasie and Ms S. Moghul i/b M/s Mulla and
Mulla and Craige Blunt and Caroe for Defendant Nos.1 to 3
Mr. Ashok Purohit i/b Ashok Purohit and Co. for Defendant No.4
Mr. Praful Satra – Director of Defendant No.1, Mr. Praful Satra – Defendant
No.2, Ms Minaxi Satra – Defendant No.3 and Mr. Jignesh Shah, Directors of
Defendant No.4 are present in court
CORAM : K.R.SHRIRAM, J. DATE : 8th AUGUST 2019
P.C.:
1 Not on board. Upon mentioning taken on production board.2 At the outset, counsel state that defendant nos.5 to 8 have noteven entered appearance and the settlement being arrived at between
plaintiff and defendant nos.1 to 4, shall in no way or manner affect the
rights of defendant nos.5 to 8. Mr. Behramkamdin for plaintiff seeks leave
to delete defendant nos.5 to 8. Mr. Satpalkar has no objection. Leave
granted. Amendment to be carried out forthwith.
3Plaintiff and defendant nos.1 to 4 have entered into consent
terms dated 8-8-2019. The consent terms signed by plaintiff, Director of
defendant no.1, defendant no.2, defendant no.3 and Director of defendant
no.4 and their respective advocates is taken on record and marked “X” for
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
2 / 65
identification. Mr. Behramkamdin and Mr. Satpalkar states that the
signatories are present in court and identify them.
4For ease of reference, the said consent terms is scanned and
reproduced hereinbelow.
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
3 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
4 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
5 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
6 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
7 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
8 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
9 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
10 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
11 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
12 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
13 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
14 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
15 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
16 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
17 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
18 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
19 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
20 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
21 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
22 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
23 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
24 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
25 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
26 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
27 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
28 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
29 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
30 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
31 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
32 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
33 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
34 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
35 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
36 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
37 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
38 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
39 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
40 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
41 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
42 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
43 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
44 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
45 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
46 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
47 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
48 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
49 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
50 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
51 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
52 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
53 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
54 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
55 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
56 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
57 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
58 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
59 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
60 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
61 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
62 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
63 / 65
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
64 / 65
5Order in terms of the consent terms. All undertakings given in
the consent terms are accepted and so ordered. All statements are accepted
as undertaking to this Court.
Meera Jadhav
coms-859-19(production).doc
65 / 65
6Suit stands disposed in terms of the consent terms. No order as
to costs. Notice of motion accordingly stands disposed. All
interim/adinterim orders also stand vacated. Refund of court fees, if any in
accordance with rules.
7Mr. Ashok Purohit undertakes to file vakalatnama on behalf of
defendant no.4. Undertaking accepted.
(K.R. SHRIRAM, J.)
Meera Jadhav
Mayank J Shah
Satara Properties (India) Ltd
Satra Properties (India) Ltd Ors
K.R. SHRIRAM
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court