The Court dismissed multiple execution applications under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules for want of prosecution as they remained unproceed for over 12 months without appearance by the applicants.
Execution applications dismissed for want of prosecution under Rule 329; no order as to costs.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 786 OF 2012
The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Sayedali Saukatali Siddiqui ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 787 OF 2012
The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Wahid Ali Ibrahim Ali Khan & Ors. ... Respondents
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 788 OF 2012
The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Laxmikant Gopalbhai Jetjwa & Ors. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 792 OF 2012
The Bharat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Narayanbhai Khumabhai Patel & Ors. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 793 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Vishnu Govind Adivarakar ... Respondent
1/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
| EXECUTION AP | AND PLICATION NO. |
794 | OF 2012 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant | |
| Manoj Govind Waghela | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
795 | OF 2012 |
|---|---|---|
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Hitendra Laxman Mewada | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
796 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Harish Ramjibhai Parmar | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
797 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Milind Ramesh Patil | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
798 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Parvez Haider Shamin H Sayed | ... | Respondent |
AND
2/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank |
799 OF 2012 … Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Versus | |
| Pankaj Shah | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 800 OF 2012
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Chandrakant Sakharam Tandel | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 801 OF 2012
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Alex Vaz | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 802 OF 2012
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Bharat Jeevalal Mehta | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 804 OF 2012
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Nelson Camil D’souza & Anr. | ... Respondents |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 805 OF 2012
3/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited … Applicant/Claimant Versus Harkant Jugatram Raval ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 807 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited … Applicant/Claimant Versus Gryphon Strategic Mktg. Ltd. ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 813 OF 2012 The Bharat Co-Op. Bank Limited … Applicant/Claimant Versus Ajit Vijay Durafe & Ors. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 826 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Limited … Applicant/Claimant Versus Kalpana Sanjay Shah ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 827 OF 2012 Magma Housing Fianance … Applicant/Claimant Versus Abdul Hamid Munnaradin Shaikh & Anr. ... Respondents
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 835 OF 2012
The Bharat Co-Op. Bank Limited … Applicant/Claimant
4/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
Versus
Shantaram Mangesh Pednekar & Ors.
... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 837 OF 2012
M/s. Citi Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus
Vinod T. Upadhyay & Anr. ... Respondents
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 839 OF 2012
M/s. Citi Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus
Arif Yusuf Patel & Ors.
... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 841 OF 2012
M/s. Citi Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus
Prakash K. Muley & Anr. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 842 OF 2012
M/s. Citi Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus
Hemal L. Gala & Ors. ... Respondents
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 843 OF 2012
Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Suresh Parmanand Amlani & Ors. ... Respondents
5/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
845 | OF 2012 |
|---|---|---|
| Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Deen Mohammad Qureshi & Anr. | ... | Respondents |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
846 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Limited Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Hitesh Ratanshi Soni | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
847 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Prakashma Bhanwerlal Jain | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
848 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Pravin Amarchand Sheth | ... | Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
849 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Shriram City Union Finance Ltd. Versus Subhashini Kanman |
… ... |
Applicant/Claimant Respondent |
6/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 850 OF 2012 M/s. Shriram City Union Finance Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Merchant Wali Mohd. Miyan Ahmed ... Respondent
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
851 | OF 2012 |
|---|---|---|
| M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Shirish Bachubhai Thakore & Ors. | ... | Respondents |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
853 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Ajit Ramachandra Ghanekar & Ors. | ... | Respondents |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
854 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Rajesh Shantilal Amlani & Ors. | ... | Respondents |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
855 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
| Amol Baliram Kadam | ... | Respondent |
AND
7/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 856 OF 2012
M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Alliulla Raza Khan & Ors. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 857 OF 2012
M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Farida qureshi & Ors. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 858 OF 2012
M/s. Shriram Chits (Mah.) Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Prakash Vasant Kasar & Anr. ... Respondents
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 863 OF 2012
M/s. Clothing Intelligence Agency … Applicant/Claimant Versus M/s. Laxmi Garments ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 864 OF 2012
M/s. Clothing Intelligence Agency … Applicant/Claimant Versus M/s. Sai Creation ... Respondent
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 865 OF 2012
8/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Usha Ramlala Singh | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 867 OF 2012
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Muzammil Khalil | ... Respondent |
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 868 OF 2012
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
|---|---|
| Pramod Kumar Pubby | ... Respondent |
None for the Applicants.
CORAM :R.I. CHAGLA, J.
DATED : 3rd SEPTEMBER, 2019.
P.C. :
for a period of over 12 months from the date of filing of these applications and have been placed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules before this Court for dismissal for want of prosecution. As none appears for the Applicants, the Execution Applications are dismissed with no order as to costs.
9/10
Waghmare
4-6, 9-23, 28-53.EXA.786.12 .doc
(R.I. CHAGLA, J.)
10/10
Waghmare
1 issue framed by the court
Whether execution applications filed over 12 months prior without appearance by applicants should be dismissed under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules.
The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-Op. Bank Ltd.
Sayedali Saukatali Siddiqui
Wahid Ali Ibrahim Ali Khan
Laxmikant Gopalbhai Jetjwa
Narayanbhai Khumabhai Patel
Vishnu Govind Adivarakar
R.I. CHAGLA
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
