The High Court dismissed numerous execution applications under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules as they were pending for over 12 months due to want of prosecution, with no costs awarded.
All execution applications are dismissed with no order as to costs for want of prosecution.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 1367 OF 2011
M/s. City Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Dipti Bhavanji Dedhia & Anr. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 140 OF 2012 M/s. K.K. Welding Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Mohanlal Bheraram Joshi & Anr. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 452 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Hardeep Singh Kuldip Singh Bindra ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 453 OF 2012
Vishwaprakash Apartments CHS Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Sami R. Chaudhary ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 455 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Rajendra Madhavdas Ashar ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 456 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant
1/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
Versus
Rajshri Swaminathan Srinivasan ... Respondent
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 457 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Manasi Suraj Yeshwantrao ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 458 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Gurudas Murlidhar Mangallore ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 459 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Zaverchand Punjalal Shah ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 460 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Bharat Mansraj Kothari ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 469 OF 2012 M/s. Peekay International … Applicant/Claimant Versus M/s. S.S. Enterprises ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 471 OF 2012
2/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
Bright Star Silk Industries Pvt. Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus M/s. Mentor Cotton Prop. Smt. Sushiladevi Chamadiya ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 474 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Kamlesh Sunderlal Shah ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 477 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Jagdish Shah ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 478 OF 2012 Kokan Mercantile Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Kazi Elyas Ali & Ors. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 495 OF 2012 M/s. Market Creators Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Varun Haresh Jashnani ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 496 OF 2012 M/s. Market Creators Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Gautam Tulsidas Jashnani ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 500 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Kausar Akram Shaikh ... Respondent
3/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 501 OF 2012
M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Vinod Ambaji Kungiri ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 502 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Ajay Nathuram Lanjekar ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 503 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Shankar R. Saanap ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 504 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Mohd Khalil Qureshi ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 505 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Abdul Wahid Penwala ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 506 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Sunil Gajadhar Mishra ... Respondent
4/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 507 OF 2012
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus Vicky Ramesh Gaba |
… ... |
Applicant/Claimant Respondent |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| EXECUTION | AND APPLICATION NO. |
508 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus Amit Shrikant Rao |
… ... |
Applicant/Claimant Respondent |
|
| EXECUTION | AND APPLICATION NO. |
509 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant | |
| Altaf Tasaddas Hussain | ... | Respondent | |
| EXECUTION | AND APPLICATION NO. |
510 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant | |
| Pawan Joginderpal Obhan | ... | Respondent | |
| EXECUTION | AND APPLICATION NO. |
511 | OF 2012 |
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant | |
| Jaswant Veerchand Mehta | ... | Respondent | |
| EXECUTION | AND APPLICATION NO. |
512 | OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… | Applicant/Claimant |
5/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
| Jacob George AND |
... Respondent |
|---|---|
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. | 513 OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
| Nishar Majid Barmare | ... Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
514 OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
| Tarique Anssari | ... Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
515 OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus Mayur N. Jagdale |
… Applicant/Claimant ... Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
516 OF 2012 |
| M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
| Aaditya R K. Putta | ... Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
517 OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
| Nisar Ahmed Noor Mod Shaikh | ... Respondent |
| AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. |
518 OF 2012 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank Versus |
… Applicant/Claimant |
6/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
Manisha Gregory Washalkar ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 519 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Santoshkumari Gayaprasad Gupta ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 520 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Ankita Vidhan Arya ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 521 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Bhaskar Motiram Yelve ... Respondent AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 525 OF 2012 M/s. City Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Anil Kumar Chunilal Doshi & Anr. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 527 OF 2012 Eros International Media ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Shree Ashtavinayak Cine Vision Ltd. & Ors. ... Respondents AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 528 OF 2012 Oshiwara Land Development Corporation Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. … Applicant/Claimant
7/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
Versus
State of Maharashtra Mantralaya & Ors. ... Respondents
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 536 OF 2012
M/s. Shriram City Union Finance Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Ganesh Vinod Wadekar ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 537 OF 2012
M/s. Asit C. Mehta Investment Intermediates Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus M/s. Airex Logistics And Express Services Pvt. Ltd.... Respondent
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 543 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Skygate Multi Technologies ... Respondent
AND EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 545 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Applicant/Claimant Versus Kailash Ramdas Kanse ... Respondent
AND
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 547 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank … Applicant/Claimant Versus Navnath Shankar Phad ... Respondent
8/9
Waghmare
5, 18-31, 33-56, 59-63,66-68.EXA.1367.11.gr.doc
CORAM : R.I. CHAGLA, J. DATED : 6th SEPTEMBER, 2019.
P.C. :
These Execution Applications have not been proceeded with for a period of over 12 months from the date of filing of these applications and have been placed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules before this Court for dismissal for want of prosecution. As none appears for the Applicants, the Execution Applications are dismissed with no order as to costs.
(R.I. CHAGLA, J.)
9/9
Waghmare
2 issues framed by the court
Whether execution applications remaining undisposed for over 12 months should be dismissed for want of prosecution.
What is the proper disposal of pending execution applications failing to appear by applicants.
1 provisions across 1 enactments
M/s. City Financial Consumer Finance India Ltd.
Dipti Bhavanji Dedhia
M/s. K.K. Welding Ltd.
Mohanlal Bheraram Joshi
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.
Hardeep Singh Kuldip Singh Bindra
R.I. CHAGLA
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
