Execution applications were reportedly pending for over twelve months. The Prothonotary placed them under Rule 329 for dismissal. With no parties appearing, the court dismissed the applications for want of prosecution without costs.
Execution applications dismissed with no order as to costs.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
jsn
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.371 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Ganesh Chandayya Shetty … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.372 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Mukesh Bholanath Sharma … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.373 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Mahendra N. Solanki … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.374 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Kirti Jadavji Khakhar … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.375 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Damodar Chamboldas Tolani & Anr. … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.390 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Mr. Rais Miyan Qureshi … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
1/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.391 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Manish C. Sharma … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.392 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Pankaj Shah … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 393 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Rupesh Birbahadur Ram Thapa … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.394 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Manish Naraindas Kalro … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.395 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Vinit Amrutlal Khandhar … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.401 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Poonam Santosh Dube … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.402 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder
2/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
(Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Manoj Narayandas Gupta … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.403 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr Ramrao Ashanna Gaddi … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.409 OF 2012 The Saraswat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. P.S. Khadpe … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.410 OF 2012 The Saraswat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Parshuram Arjun Kadam & 2 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.411 OF 2012 The Saraswat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Jayprakash Parasnath Gautam & 3 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.412 OF 2012 The Saraswat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Nilesh Rajendra Jhaveri & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.413 OF 2012 The Saraswat Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
3/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
V/s. Mr. Sopan Arjun Jadhav & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.414 OF 2012
Ventura Securities Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Shantilal Devilal Kothari … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.419 OF 2012 The Kapol Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Chandrakant Kanu Karkare & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.420 OF 2012 New India Co-operative Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Klastar Hospitalities Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.422 OF 2012
The Cosmos Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Foram Distributors … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.423 OF 2012
The Cosmos Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
4/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Mr. Jeevan Rama Tayade & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.424 OF 2012
Magma Fincorp Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Altaf Shahabuddin Dadani & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.425 OF 2012
Magma Fincorp Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Anish Ghanashyam Choksi & Ors … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.430 OF 2012
M/s. New Asian Construction Co. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mohammed Rafique Khatri & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.434 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sachin Girish Shah … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.435 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori.
5/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Claimant)
V/s. Pradeep Sitaram Gangan … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.436 OF 2012 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Anandkumar Pravinchandra Shah & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.437 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Chandrika Hasmukh Solani … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.438 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Nitin Bokefode … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.439 OF 2012
Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Kishore Vishanji Lodaya … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.440 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s.
6/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Mr. Shaikh Akaram Shaikh Hussain … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.441 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Angles Rita G. Menezes … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.442 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Deepak Jagabhai Ravariya … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.443 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Vicky T. Pathan … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.444 OF 2012 M/s. Neha Printers … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Syndicate Overseas Pvt. Ltd. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.445 OF 2012 NO R & P M/s. Mansi Creation … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Abida Fashions … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
7/8
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.448 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Larry Borthwick … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.449 OF 2012 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Lenin Verghese Parakel … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
None for the parties.
CORAM: R. I. CHAGLA, J. DATE: 5TH SEPTEMBER, 2019. PC:-
These Execution Applications have not been proceeded with for a period of over 12 months from the date of filing of these applications and have been placed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules before this Court for dismissal for want of prosecution. As none appears for the Applicants, these Execution Applications are dismissed with no order as to costs.
( R I. CHAGLA, J. )
8/8
1 issue framed by the court
Whether execution applications filed over 12 months ago should be dismissed for want of prosecution on their own motion.
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.
Ganesh Chandayya Shetty
Mukesh Bholanath Sharma
Mr. Mahendra N. Solanki
Mr. Kirti Jadavji Khakhar
Mr. Rais Miyan Qureshi
R. I. Chagla
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court