The High Court of Judicature at Bombay dismissed multiple execution applications (Nos. 1248-1344) of 2011 for want of prosecution, as none appeared before the Court after they had remained pending for over 12 months.
Execution applications dismissed for want of prosecution with no order as to costs.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
jsn
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1248 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Omprakash Baijnath Yadav … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1249 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Kamaraj Pechimuthu Nadar … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1251 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Kamlesh Laherchand Madhani … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1265 OF 2011 Indiabulls Financial Service Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Kirpalkaur Chaddha & Anr … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1266 OF 2011 Indiabulls Financial Service Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Ravi Organics & Ors. … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1267 OF 2011 Indiabulls Financial Service Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
1/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
V/s. Ceal Shipping and Logistics Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1271 OF 2011 Prerana Sahakari Patsanshta Mydt. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ramshankar Rajpati Jaiswal & Ors. … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1272 OF 2011
Mangaidevi Sahakari Pathpedhi … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Virendra Sakharam Pawar & Ors. … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 1273 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Anil Kumar Basani Mishra … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1274 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sanjay Kalpanath Rai … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1275 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Bhavesh Govind Vayani … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1276 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
2/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
V/s. Ulfat Shaikh Ali … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1277 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Ltd.
… Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Mr. Rajendraprasad Ganesh Yadav … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1280 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
Mr. Jesu Raj Paul Nadar … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1281 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Pravin Maruti Mahadik … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1283 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Mr. Chetan Shriddhar Belwalkar … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1284 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Mr. Sanjay R. Pathak … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1285 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
3/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Mr. Khan Zubair Ahmeed … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1286 OF 2011 M/s. Royal Bank of Scotland M.V. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Yogesh Manohar Surve … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1287 OF 2011 M/s. Royal Bank of Scotland M.V. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Dipti Dedhia … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1293 OF 2011 Abhyudaya Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Rajesh Avdhut Vengurlekar & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1294 OF 2011 Abhyudaya Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sheela Sales Corporation & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1307 OF 2011 M./s, Religare Finvest Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Shruti Art Pvt. Ltd. & 2 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
4/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1308 OF 2011
M./s, Religare Finvest Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Shruti Art Pvt. Ltd. & 2 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1309 OF 2011
Kokan Mer. Co-Op. Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mr. Patil Prakash Gangaram (Borrower) & … Defendants Ors. (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1310 OF 2011
Mahesh D. Thakkar (Rughani) & Anr. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Bhagwanji D. Thakkar (Rughani) & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1311 OF 2011
Shkti Indulated Wires Pvt. Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ekta Shakti Developers & 5 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1315 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
5/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Radhakishan Shanmukakanin Adar … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1316 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sudhir Kanti Lal Zaveri … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1318 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sanjaya Senapaty … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1319 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mohsin Masroor Shah Khan … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1321 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mita Rajesh Tolia … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1331 OF 2011
M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Nirav Bipin Parekh … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
6/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1332 OF 2011 Bright Star Silk Industries Pvt. Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Shree Shyam Synthetics Mills Prop Smt. … Defendants Sushiladevi Chamdiya & Anr. (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1333 OF 2011 M/s. Harshil Textiles … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Fabric World, Mr. Kumar Mehta … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1335 OF 2011 M/s. Harshil Textiles … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. S.R. Clothing Mr. Dipesh Mansukhlal … Defendants Mehta (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1336 OF 2011 M/s. D. M. Fabrics India … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s.Sri B.S. Roadlines & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1337 OF 2011 M/s. Micron Synthetics … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Global Fashion Clothing … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1338 OF 2011 (NO R & P)
7/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
K.S. Abdul Sattar … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. R.V. Deshmukh … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1341 OF 2011 M/s. S.R. Thilagavathe Handloom Textiles, … Decree Thru Its Partner G. Karunaith Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ashok Damani Sree Venkatesh & Co. & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1343 OF 2011 The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Radha Medical and General Stores Prop. … Defendants Mr. Rajendra B. Soni & 2 Ors. (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1344 OF 2011 The Punjab and Maharashtra Co-op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. N.Vasfield Industrial Suppliers Pro Mr. … Defendants Mohinderpal Singh & 3 Ors. (Ori. Respondent)
None for the parties.
CORAM: R. I. CHAGLA, J. DATE: 22ND AUGUST, 2019
PC:-
These Execution Applications have not been proceeded with for a period of over 12 months from the date of filing of these
8/9
4-53-EXA-GROUP.DOC
applications and have been placed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules before this Court for dismissal for want of prosecution. As none appears for the Applicants, these Execution Applications are dismissed with no order as to costs.
( R I. CHAGLA, J. )
9/9
1 issue framed by the court
Whether execution applications pending for over 12 months be dismissed for want of prosecution under Rule 329 of Bombay High Court Original Side Rules.
HDFC Bank Ltd.
Omprakash Baijnath Yadav
Indiabulls Financial Service Ltd.
Kamaraj Pechimuthu Nadar
R. I. Chagla
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
