On the application of the Prothonotary, the Court dismissed multiple execution applications filed by decree holders for non-prosecution due to the absence of counsel for applicants and lapse of over 12 months.
Execution applications dismissed with no order as to costs.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
jsn
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1160 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ashwin Magalal Mehta … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1161 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Shri Kunal Dayashankar Singh … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1162 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Shri Usman Lal Mohmad Sheikh & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1163 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Manmeet Singh Narendra Sethi … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1164 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Narendra Natwarlal Gor … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1171 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
1/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
V/s. Umesh Chintamani Patil … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1172 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Haroon Chaudhary … Defendant (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1174 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Helan Ephania Aruldas … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO. 1177 OF 2011 M/s. Bableshwar Films Indore … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Monalisa Films Mumbai … Defendant (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1192 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sanjay Champalal Jain … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1193 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sahllo Rahul Barar … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1194 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
2/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
V/s. Shriniwas R. Shetty … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1195 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Kavita Sreedharan Nair & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1196 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Padma Hotchand Taurani … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1197 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Taurani Ramchandra … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1198 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Taurani Ramchandra … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1199 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ms. Meena Rajesh Katke … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1200 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
3/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Zephyrinus John Crasto & Anr. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1201 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holder (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ms. Meena Rajesh Katke … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1202 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Mira Arun Dhir … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1204 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Irfan Sakhiani … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1205 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Ketan Vishnu Tambe … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1206 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Jineshchandra Jethalal Shah … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
4/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1207 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Chetan Dwarkadeas Gandhi … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1208 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Pranay Aggarwal … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1209 OF 2011
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Chandan Ram Sumaya & 5 Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1212 OF 2011
The Cosmos Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Rang Creation (Prop. Mr. Ashwin Ramji … Defendants Gogri & Anr.) (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1213 OF 2011
The Cosmos Co-Op Bank Ltd. Vile Parle … Decree Branch Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
5/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Mr. Ashutosh Chandrakant Punekar & Ors. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1215 Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. V/s. |
OF 2011 … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) |
|---|---|
| Nandkishore Shivaji Chavan | … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) |
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1216 M/s. Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. V/s. |
OF 2011 … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) |
| Sachin Nana Ovhal | … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) |
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1217 | OF 2011 |
| Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. V/s. |
… Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) |
| Mr. Khurshid Ahmed Siddiqui | … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) |
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1218 | OF 2011 |
| Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. V/s. |
… Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) |
| Mr. Cementwala Kaizar Abdul | … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) |
| EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1219 | OF 2011 |
| Kotak Mahindra Bank V/s. |
… Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) |
| Satyadeo Banwari Jha | … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) |
6/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1220 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Vimukt Singh Bisht … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1222 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Latesh Lal Chetnanai … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1223 OF 2011 Kotak Mahindra Bank … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Paustine Marcel Pinto … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1227 OF 2011 The Cosmos Co-Op. Bank Ltd … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Parshwa Stationery Mart (Prop. Mr. … Defendants Nemchand K. Shah) & Ors. (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1228 OF 2011 The New India Co-Op Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. M/s. Vedansh Hospitality & Reports (P) Ltd. … Defendants (Ori. Respondent) EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1235 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree
7/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Rakash Badrinath Mishra … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1236 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Shehnaz Sohel Khan … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1237 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Khan Abdul Raheem … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1239 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
Nargis Abdulhafeez Khan … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1241 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s. Pawan Arun Sinha … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1242 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant)
V/s.
8/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Krishna Mukund Thanvi … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1243 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Babulal Nihalchand Jain … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1244 OF 2011 HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sirajahmed Abdul Rashid Ansari … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
EXECUTION APPLICATION NO.1246 OF 2011
HDFC Bank Ltd. … Decree Holders (Ori. Claimant) V/s. Sandeep Singh Dalpatia … Defendants (Ori. Respondent)
None for the parties.
CORAM: R. I. CHAGLA, J. DATE: 19TH AUGUST, 2019
PC:-
These Execution Applications have not been proceeded with for a period of over 12 months from the date of filing of these applications and have been placed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original
9/10
4-54-EXA-GROUP.DOC
Side Rules before this Court for dismissal for want of prosecution. As none appears for the Applicants, these Execution Applications are dismissed with no order as to costs.
( R I. CHAGLA, J. )
10/10
1 issue framed by the court
Whether execution applications filed under Rule 329 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules should be dismissed for want of prosecution due to non-appearance.
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. and Others
Various Defendants
R. I. CHAGLA
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
