Allowed

Sachin Dnyaneshwar Chougule v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Bombay HC15 Apr 2019APL/285/2019

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Kidnapping and rape proceedings were quashed in the circumstances of the applicant's marriage to the affected respondent, their long cohabitation, three children and her voluntary consent. The court allowed the application and also quashed the proclamation issued against the applicant.

What did the court decide?

Sessions proceedings against the applicant and the proclamation issued against him under section 82 of the Code of Criminal Procedure were quashed.

Sachin Dnyaneshwar Chougule Vs the State of Maharashtra and… — Quashing and FIR | Bombay HC (2019)

¶1

Apl-285/19

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY JUDICATURE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY AT BOMBAY CRIMIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDIC A TURE AT BOMBAY L APPELLATE JURISDICITON APPE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYL APPE L LATE JURISDICITON ATE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY JURISDICITON THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

¶3

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 285 OF 2019 APPL APPL I CATION NO. 285 OF 2019 CATION NO. 285 OF 2019 285 OF 2019 2019

¶4

Sachin Dnyaneshwar Chougule. Dn Dn y aneshwar Chougule. an Dnyan e shwar Chougule. shwar Chougule. Chougule. ..Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. Ver Chougule.sus

¶5

State of Maharashtra & Others. Mahar Chougule.ashtr Chougule.a & Others. Other Chougule.s. ..Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ts.

¶6

Mr Chougule . Adwait Bhon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.de f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t.

¶7

Ms. S. D. shin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.de, APP for the Respondent-State. APP f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. the Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t-State. Mr Chougule . Pr Chougule.atik Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3. Rajopadhye f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 3.

¶8

P. C. :

¶9

Hear Chougule.d the lear Chougule.n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d coun Dnyane s hwar Chougule. el f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t, APP for the Respondent-State. the lear Chougule.n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d coun Dnyane s hwar Chougule. el f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d lear Chougule.n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d APP f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. the Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t-State.

¶10

By this application Dnyaneshwar Chougule. filed un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 482 of Maharashtra & Others. the Code of Maharashtra & Others. Cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Pr Ch o ugule. cedur Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. 1973, APP for the Respondent-State. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t is seek Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g to quash the pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. s of Maharashtra & Others. Session Dnyane s Case N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.190 of 2003 of Maharashtra & Others. 20 of 2 0 03 3 pen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.din Dnyaneshwar Chou g on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the file of Maharashtra & Others. Addition Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Session Dnyane s Judge, APP for the Respondent-State. Pun Dnyan e shwar Chougule. . The said case has ar Chougule.isen Dnyaneshwar Chougule. f Maha r ashtra & Others. om : r Chougul e . gistr Chougule.ation Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R bear Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g CR. N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 56 of of Maharashtra & Others. 20 of 2 0 03 3 at Kothr Cho u gule. d Police Station Dnyaneshwar Chougule. at the in Dnyane s hwar Chougule. tan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce of Maharashtra & Others. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.2 again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d two other Chougule.s, APP for the Respondent-State. n Dny a neshwar Chougule. m : ely, APP for the Respondent-State. Chhaya An D n yaneshwar Chougule. a Kur C h ougule. ade an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Upen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.dr Chougule.a Basappa Buddhihal f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. the offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce pun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ishable un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. section Dnyane s 36 of3, APP for the Respondent-State. 36 of6 ofA an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d 376 of r Chougul e . ad with 34 of Maharashtra & Others.

1 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

the In Dnyaneshwar Chougule.dian Dnyaneshwar Chougule. Pen Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Code, APP for the Respondent-State. 186 of0 of 2003. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.2 at whose

¶15

in Dnyane s hwar Chougule. tan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce the said F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R is r Chougul e . gister Chougul e . d, APP for the Respondent-State. is m : other Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 3.

¶16

The gr Chougule.avam : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. allegation Dnyaneshwar Chougule. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R is that pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t alon Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. with two other Chougule. accused per Chougule.son Dnyane s k Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.idn Dny a neshwar Chougule. pped Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3, APP for the Respondent-State. who was 16 of year Chougule.s old. The allegation Dnyaneshwar Chougule. with r Chougul e . gar Chougule.d to com : m : ission Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce of Maharashtra & Others. r Chougule.ape is on Dnyaneshwar Chougu l e. y again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. The char Chou g ule. e-sheet was filed in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the subject F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. due cour Chougule.se, APP for the Respondent-State. the pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g was n Dnyaneshwar Cho u gule. m : ber Chougul e . d as Session Dnyane s Case N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.190 of 2003 of Maharashtra & Others. 20 of 2 0 03 3. However Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. as the

¶17

pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t was n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t available at that tim : e, APP for the Respondent-State. on Dnyaneshwar Chougu l e. y accused N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYos. 2 an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d 3 wer Chougul e tr Chougule.ied by the Session Dnyane s Cour Chougule.t at Pun Dnyan e shwar Chougule. . By the judgm : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d or Chougule.der Chougule. dated 29^th Apr Chougule.il 20 of 2 0 03 4, APP for the Respondent-State. accused N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYos. 2 an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d 3 cam : e to be acquitted in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the said case. The in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.vestigatin Dnyaneshwar Chou g officer Chougule. was, APP for the Respondent-State. however Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. dir Chougul e . cted to file separ Chougule.ate char Chou g ule. e-sheet again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. It was f Maharashtra & Others.ur Chougule.ther Chougule. dir Chougul e . cted that eviden Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce of Maharashtra & Others. PW 1 to PW 4 recorded in Sessions Case No. 190 of 2003 at the 1 to PW 1 to PW 4 recorded in Sessions Case No. 190 of 2003 at the 4 r Chougul e . cor Chougule.ded in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. Session Dnyane s Case N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 190 of 2003 of Maharashtra & Others. 20 of 2 0 03 3 at the tim : e of Maharashtra & Others. tr Chougule.ial, APP for the Respondent-State. shall be substan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tive eviden Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. his tr Chougule.ial.

¶18

At this stage, APP for the Respondent-State. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t has appr Ch o ugule. ached this Cour Chougule.t f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. quashin Dnyaneshwar Chou g the subject session Dnyane s case again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t him : by con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t of Maharashtra & Others. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3. It is the case of Maharashtra & Others. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t as well as Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 that im : m : ediately af Maharash t ra & Others. er Chougule. the in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ciden Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.

2 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

question Dnyaneshwar Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. they got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 30 of 2003^th Jan Dnyaneshwar Cho u gule. ar Chougule.y 20 of 2 0 03 3, APP for the Respondent-State. they ar Chougul e stayin Dnyaneshwar Chou g together Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d out of Maharashtra & Others. their Chougule. wedlock Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3., APP for the Respondent-State. thr Chougul e . e childr Chougul e . n Dnyaneshwar Chougule. ar Chougul e bor Chougule.n Dnyaneshwar Chougule Ther Chougul e . f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 have join Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tly in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.vok Rajopadhy e for Respondent No. 3. d the jur Chougule.isdiction Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. this Cour Chougule.t un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. Ar Chougule.ticle 226 of of Maharashtra & Others. the Con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. titution Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. In Dnyaneshwar Chougule.dia an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 482 of Maharashtra & Others. the Code of Maharashtra & Others. Cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Pr Ch o ugule. cedur Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. 1973 seek Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g to quash the pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. s of Maharashtra & Others. the subject session Dnyane s hwar Chougule. case by con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t.

¶23

Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 has accor Chougule.din Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. ly filed an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. affidavit dated 26 of^th Mar Chougule.ch 20 of 200319. She has r Chougul e . iter Chougule.ated that she has got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied with the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d that they ar Chougul e leadin Dnyaneshwar Chou g happy m : ar Chougule.ital lif Maharashtra & Oth e rs. . She has also given Dnyaneshwar Chougule. n Dnyaneshwar Ch o objection Dnyaneshwar Chougule. to quash the pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. s of Maharashtra & Others. subject session Dnyane s case again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. She has also stated that at the tim : e of Maharashtra & Others. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ciden Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. question Dnyaneshwar Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. ther Chougul e was love affair Chougule. between Dnyaneshwar Chougule. her Chougule.self Maharashtra & Others. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d ther Chougul e . af Maharash t ra & Others. er Chougule. she has got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied with the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d r Chougul e . sidin Dnyaneshwar Chou g together Chougule. with the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. last 16 of year Chougule.s. It is also stated that Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.2 is her Chougule. m : other Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d she is n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. talk Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g ter Chougule.m : s with her Chougule. as she was an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d is again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.iage between Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 as they do n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t belon Dnyaneshwar Chou g to the sam : e caste.

¶24

6 of. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 is per Chougule.son Dny a neshwar Chougule. lly pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t bef Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e the Cour Chougule.t. On Dnyaneshwar Chougule. specific quer Chougule.y m : ade by us, APP for the Respondent-State. she subm : itted that she has m : ade the said affidavit on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. her Chougule. own Dnyaneshwar Chougule. f Maha r ashtra & Others. ee will, APP for the Respondent-State. without ther Chougul e

3 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

bein Dnyaneshwar Chou g an Dn y pr Chougul e . ssur Chougul e or Chougule. un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.due in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.fluen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce. She has f Maharashtra & Others.ur Chougule.ther Chougule. con Dnyaneshwar Chougule.fir Chougule.m : ed that she has n Dnyaneshwar Ch o objection Dnyaneshwar Chougule. f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. quashin Dnyaneshwar Chou g the subject cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. s in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.itiated by her Chougule. again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. She has r Chougul e . iter Chougule.ated whatever Chougule. is m : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tion Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d her Chougul e . in Dny a neshwar Chougule. bove. She has on Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce again Dnyaneshwar Chougule. r Chougul e . quested to quash the pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g of Maharashtra & Others. subject session Dnyane s hwar Chougule. case again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t – her husband. her Chougule. husban Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d.

¶29

L APPELLATE JURISDICITONast tim : e, APP for the Respondent-State. we dir Chougul e . cted lear Chougule.n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d APP to in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule.m : whether Chougule. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 have got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d stayin Dnyaneshwar Chou g together Chougule Accor Chougule.din Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. ly, APP for the Respondent-State. lear Chougule.n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d APP has placed on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. r Chougul e . cor Chougule.d r Chougul e . por Chougule.t dated 14^th Apr Chougule.il 20 of 200319 m : ade by the Police Sub In Dnyane s hwar Chougule. pector Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. Kothar Cho u gule. d Police Station Dnyaneshwar Chougule The r Chougul e . por Chougule.t shows that the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the year Chougule. 20 of 2 0 03 3 an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d they have given Dnyaneshwar Chougule. bir Chougule.th to thr Chougul e . e childr Chougul e . n Dnyaneshwar Chougule

¶30

Alon Dnyaneshwar Chou g with this application Dnyaneshwar Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t has placed on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. r Chougul e . cor Chougule.d bir Chougule.th cer Chougule.tificates of Maharashtra & Others. his thr Chougul e . e childr Chougul e . n Dnyaneshwar Chougule The bir Chougule.th cer Chougule.tificates show that the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t is the f M a harashtra & Others. ther Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 is their Chougule. m : other Chougule It suppor Chougule.ts the con Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ten Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. both the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 3.

¶31

The Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t is also pr Chougul e . sen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t bef Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e the Cour Chougule.t. He also states that ther Chougul e was love affair Chougule. between Dnyaneshwar Chougule. him : self Maharashtra & Others. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo. 3 an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 willin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. ly accom : pan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ied him : . He also subm : itted that on Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 becam : e

4 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

m : ajor Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. he got m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied with her Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d they ar Chougul e r Chougul e . sidin Dnyaneshwar Chou g togther Chougule. happily sin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce last 16 of year Chougule.s. He also stated that he an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 have given Dnyaneshwar Chougule. bir Chougule.th to thr Chougul e . e childr Chougul e . n Dnyaneshwar Chougule

¶36

It is tr Cho u gule. e that the offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 376 of of Maharashtra & Others. IPC is of Maharashtra & Others. ser Chougule.ious n Dny a neshwar Chougule. tur Chougul e an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d is an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t society. Con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. equen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tly, APP for the Respondent-State. such an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce can D n yaneshwar Chougule. ot be quashed by con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t. N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYon Dnyan e shwar Chougule. theless, APP for the Respondent-State. it would be advan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.tageous to r Chougul e . f Maharashtra & Oth e rs. r Chougule. to Par Chougule.agr Chougule.aph 28 of Maharashtra & Others. N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYar Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. Sin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. h vs. State of Maharashtra & Others. Pun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jab [20 of 200314 AIR SCW 1 to PW 4 recorded in Sessions Case No. 190 of 2003 at the 20 of 20036 of5], APP for the Respondent-State. wher Chougul e . in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the Apex Court has held as under : Cour Chougule.t has held as un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. :

¶37

“28. Havin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. said so, APP for the Respondent-State. we would hasten Dnyaneshwar Chougule. to add that though it is a ser Chougule.ious offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce as the accused per Chougule.son Dnyaneshwar Chougule.(s) attem : pted to tak Rajopadhy e for Respondent No. 3. the lif Maharashtra & Oth e rs. of Maharashtra & Others. an Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. ther Chougule. per Chougule.son Dnyaneshwar Chougule./victim : , APP for the Respondent-State. at the sam : e tim : e the cour Chougule.t can D n yaneshwar Chougule. ot be oblivious to har Chougule.d r Chougul e . alities that m : an Dn y aneshwar Chougule. tim : es when Dnyan e shwar Chougule. ver Chougule.ther Chougul e . is a quar Chougule.r Chougul e . l between Dnyaneshwar Chougule.the par Chougule.ties leadin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. to physical com : m : otion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d sustain Dnyaneshwar Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. of Maharashtra & Others. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jur Chougule.y by either Chougule. or Chougule. both the par Chougule.ties, APP for the Respondent-State. ther Chougul e . is a ten Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.cy to give it a slan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t of Maharashtra & Others.an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule.Section Dnyaneshwar Chougule.30 of 20037 IPC as well. Ther Chougul e . f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. on Dnyaneshwar Chougu l e. y because F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R/Char Chou g ule. e-sheet in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.cor Chougule.por Chougule.ates the pr Ch o ugule. vision Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. Section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 30 of 20037 IPC would n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t, APP for the Respondent-State. by itself Maharashtra & Others., APP for the Respondent-State. be a gr Ch o ugule. un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d to r Chougul e . ject the petition Dnyaneshwar Chougule. un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 482 of Maharashtra & Others. the Code an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d r Chougul e . f Maharashtra & Others.use to accept the settlem : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t between Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the par Chougule.ties. W 1 to PW 4 r e corded in Sessions Case No. 190 of 2003 at the ar Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. ther Chougul e . f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. of Maharashtra & Others. the opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule.that while tak Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. a call as to whether Chougule.com : pr Ch o ugule. m : ise in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. such cases should be effected or Chougule. n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t, APP for the Respondent-State. the High Cour Chougule.t should go by the n Dny a neshwar Chougule. tur Chougul e . of Maharashtra & Others. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jur Chougule.y sustain Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d, APP for the Respondent-State. the por Chougule.tion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. the bodies wher Chougul e . the in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jur Chougule.ies wer Chougul e . in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.flicted (n Dny a neshwar Chougule. m : ely whether Chougule. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jur Chougule.ies ar Chougul e . caused at the vital/delicate par Chougule.ts of Maharashtra & Others. the body) an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d the n Dny a neshwar Chougule. tur Chougul e . of Maharashtra & Others.weapon Dnyane s hwar Chougule. usedetc. On Dnyaneshwar Chougule.that basis, APP for the Respondent-State.if Maharashtra & Others.it is f Maharashtra & Others.oun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.dthat ther Chougul e . is a str Ch o ugule. n Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. possibility of Maharashtra & Others.pr Ch o ugule. vin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. the char Chou g ule. e un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. Section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 30 of 20037 IPC, APP for the Respondent-State. on Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce the eviden Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce to that effect is led an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jur Chougule.ies pr Ch o ugule. ved, APP for the Respondent-State.the Cour Chougule.t should n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. t accept settlem : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t between Dnyaneshwar Chougule.the par Chougule.ties. On Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the other Chougule. han Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d, APP for the Respondent-State. on Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the basis of Maharashtra & Others. pr Chougule.im : a f M a harashtra & Others. cie assessm : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t of Maharashtra & Others.the af Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e . saidcir Chougule.cum : stan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ces, APP for the Respondent-State.if Maharashtra & Others.the High Cour Chougule.t f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule.m : s an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that pr Ch o ugule. vision Dnyane s hwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. Section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 30 of 20037 IPC wer Chougul e . un D n yaneshwar Chougule. ecessar Chougule.y in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.cluded in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the char Chou g ule. e sheet, APP for the Respondent-State. the Cour Chougule.t can Dnyaneshwar Chougule. accept the plea of Maharashtra & Others. com : poun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.din Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. of Maharashtra & Others. the offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce based on Dnyaneshwar Chougule.

5 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

settlem : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t between Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the par Chougule.ties.”

¶42

. The decision Dnyaneshwar Chougule. of Maharashtra & Others. the Apex Court has held as under : Cour Chougule.t, APP for the Respondent-State. thus, APP for the Respondent-State. m : ak Rajopadhy e for Respondent No. 3. s it clear Chougule. that the Cour Chougule.t can D n yaneshwar Chougule. ot declin Dnyan e to quash the F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R / cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l pr Ch o ugule. ceedin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. s m : er Chougul e . ly because the F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.cor Chougule.por Chougule.ates a par Chougule.ticular Chougule. pr Ch o ugule. vision Dnyaneshwar Chougule. which is a ser Chougule.ious offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce or Chougule. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the society. The Cour Chougule.t has to en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.deavour Chougule. to fin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d out whether Chougule. the F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.deed discloses in Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. r Chougul e . dien Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ts of Maharashtra & Others. such offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d that the Cour Chougule.t can Dnyaneshwar Chougule. accept the settlem : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d quash the F JUD I CATURE AT BOMBAY R / Char Chou g ule. e-sheet if Maharashtra & Others. the Cour Chougule.t is of Maharashtra & Others. the opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that such an Dnyaneshwar Chougule. offen Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce is un D n yaneshwar Chougule. ecessar Chougule.ily in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.cor Chougule.por Chougule.ated in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the char Chou g ule. e-sheet.

¶43

10 of 2003. In Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the above f M a harashtra & Others. cts an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d cir Chougule.cum : stan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ces we ar Chougul e of Maharashtra & Others. the opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that case is m : ade out f Maharashtra & Others.or Chougule. quashin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. . In Dnyaneshwar Chougule. addition Dnyaneshwar Chougule. to this, APP for the Respondent-State. we ar Chougul e of Maharashtra & Others. the opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that n Dnyaneshwar Ch o pur Chougule.pose would be ser Chougule.ved by m : ak Rajopadhye for Respondent No. 3.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t to f M a harashtra & Others. ce tr Chougule.ial. W 1 to PW 4 r e ar Chougul e also of Maharashtra & Others. the opin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ion Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that quashin Dnyaneshwar Chou g of Maharashtra & Others. the subject session Dnyane s case is in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ter Chougul e . st of Maharashtra & Others. Respon Dnyaneshwar Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYo.3 as n Dnyaneshwar Ch o ugule. w she is m : ar Chougule.r Chougule.ied to the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t.

¶44

In Dnyaneshwar Chougule. these cir Chougule.cum : stan Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ces, APP for the Respondent-State. an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d especially, APP for the Respondent-State. in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. view of Maharashtra & Others. the law laid down Dnyaneshwar Chougule. by the Apex Court has held as under : Cour Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the case of Maharashtra & Others. Madan Dnyaneshwar Chougule. Mohan Dnyaneshwar Chougule. Abbot vs. State of Maharashtra & Others. Pun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jab, APP for the Respondent-State. [(20 of 2 0 03 8) 4 SCC 582], APP for the Respondent-State. we fin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d that n Dnyaneshwar Ch o pur Chougule.pose would be ser Chougule.ved by k Rajopadhy e for Respondent No. 3. epin Dnyaneshwar Chou g alive the subject session Dnyane s case ex Court has held as under :cept ultim : ately bur Chougule.den Dnyaneshwar Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chou g the Cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Cour Chougule.ts which ar Chougul e alr Chougul e . ady over Chougule.bur Chougule.den Dnyan e shwar Chougule. d. 12. In Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the light of Maharashtra & Others. the pr Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ciples laid down Dnyaneshwar Chougule. by the Apex Court has held as under :

6 / 7

patilsr

Apl-285/19

Cour Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the af Maharashtra & Others.or Chougul e . said decision Dnyaneshwar Chougule. as well as in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the case of Maharashtra & Others. N THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYar Chougule.in Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. Sin Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. h vs. State of Maharashtra & Others. Pun Dnyaneshwar Chougule.jab [20 of 200314 AIR SCW 1 to PW 4 recorded in Sessions Case No. 190 of 2003 at the 20 of 20036 of5] we ar Chougul e of Maharashtra & Others. the con Dnyane s hwar Chougule. ider Chougul e . d view that ther Chougul e is n Dnyaneshwar Ch o im : pedim : en Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. quashin Dnyaneshwar Chou g the subject session Dnyane s case. In Dnyaneshwar Chougule. that view of Maharashtra & Others. the m : atter Chougule., APP for the Respondent-State. application Dnyaneshwar Chougule. is m : ade absolute in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. ter Chougule.m : s of Maharashtra & Others. pr Chougule.ayer Chougule. clause (a).

¶49

Sin Dnyaneshwar Chougule.ce we have quashed the subject session Dnyane s case, APP for the Respondent-State. the pr Ch o ugule. clam : ation Dnyaneshwar Chougule. issued in Dnyaneshwar Chougule. the said case again Dnyane s hwar Chougule. t the Applican Dnyaneshwar Chougule.t un Dnyaneshwar Chougule.der Chougule. section Dnyaneshwar Chougule. 82 of Maharashtra & Others. the Code of Maharashtra & Others. Cr Chougule.im : in Dny a neshwar Chougule. l Pr Ch o ugule. cedur Chougul e . , APP for the Respondent-State. 1973 n Dnyan e shwar Chougule. eds to be quashed an Dnyaneshwar Chougule.d the sam : e is her Chougul e . by accor Chougule.din Dnyaneshwar Chou g ule. ly quashed.

¶50

[SMT. 285 OF 2019 BHARATI H. 285 OF 2019 DANGRE, 2019 J.] 285 OF 2019

¶51

[RANJIT MORE, 2019 J. 285 OF 2019 ]

¶52

7 / 7

¶53

patilsr

Sachin Dnyaneshwar Chougule v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Sachin Dnyaneshwar Chougule v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Rishi Techtex Limited Vs Union of India and Ors.

Manish D. Khandelwal Vs the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Sunil Mangilal Jain Vs State of Maharashtra and Ors.

A.C. Narayanan. and Anr. . Vs the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

A Ramalingam Ramesh Vs the State of Maharashtra and Anr.

Gem Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. through Sandhya Vakil Vs the State of Maharashtra and Ors.