Disposed
Panchsheel Nagar (Sra) Co-Op.Hsg.Society (Proposed) v. State of Maharashtra and 6 Ors.
Bombay HCWP/2638/2016
Case brief
from the order text
What is this about?
COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY…
What the court decided
AI extract
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 874 OF 2018
Anita Dattatray Dhole And 6 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And ....Respondent 3 Ors
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 308 OF 2017 In
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION 140 OF 2006
Janhit Manch And 3 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation Through ....Respondent Its Ch.engineer And Anr & Hanumant Nivrutti Sathe & Anr
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 166 OF 2017
In
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION 140 OF 2006
Janhit Manch And 3 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation And Anr ....Respondent
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 1332 OF 2017
Baban S Rahatwal And 17 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Page 1/7
The Commissioner, Municipal Coproation Of Gr ....Respondent Mumbai And 3 Ors
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 165 OF 2017 In
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION 140 OF 2006
Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation Through ....Respondent Its Executive Engineerand Anr.
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 2638 OF 2016
Panchsheel Nagar (sra) Co-op.hsg.society ....Petitioner (proposed)
State Of Maharashtra And 6 Ors. ....Respondent
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 166 OF 2017
In
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION 140 OF 2006
Janhit Manch And 3 Ors ....Petitioner
V/S
Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation And Anr ....Respondent
WITH
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO. 81 OF 2017
Mohammed Arif (alias) Naseem Khan And 2 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Page 2/7
....Respondent
The State Of Maharashtra And 4 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3314 OF 2017
Ramprasad Mishra And 36 Ors ....Petitioner V/S Assistant Engineer, Assistant Municipal ....Respondent
Assistant Engineer, Assistant Municipal Commissioners Office And 4 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3368 OF 2017
Namrata Bhagwan Tambe And 2 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer Assistant Municipal ....Respondent Commissioners Office And 5 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 1664 OF 2018
Zaidunnisaabdul Aziz Ansari And Anr. ....Petitioner V/S
The Municipal Corporation Of Gr. Mumbai And ....Respondent 5 Ors.
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3108 OF 2017
Ulhas Vasant Salvi And 5 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer Assistant Municipal ....Respondent Commissioners Office And 5 Ors
WITH
Page 3/7
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3278 OF 2017
Sandesh R. Khadpe ....Petitioner V/S
The State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors.
....Respondent
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3301 OF 2017
Sandeep Shivaji Shirke And 34 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer Assistant Municipal Commissioner Office And 5 Ors
....Respondent
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3316 OF 2017
Srimati Asha Vinyak Thorat And 52 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer Assistant Municipal ....Respondent Commissioners Office And 5 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3350 OF 2017
Krishna Tukaram Ahire And 14 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer Assistant Municipal ....Respondent Commissioner Office Mcgm And 5 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3390 OF 2017
Datta Maruti Pathade And 18 Ors. ....Petitioner V/S
Page 4/7
Assistant Engineer Asstt. Municipal Commissioners And 5 Ors.
....Respondent
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 385 OF 2018
Ramallu Chilka And 5 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Assistant Engineer, Assistant Municipal ....Respondent Commissioners Office And 5 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 2475 OF 2018
Municipal Corporation Of Gr.mumbai And 3 Ors ....Respondent
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 3353 OF 2018
Shahaji Jyotiram Sawant And 2 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And ....Respondent 3 Ors
WITH
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO. 1158 OF 2017
Vishwanath Pandurang Dede And 62 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
The Commissioner, Municipal Corporation Of ....Respondent Greater Mumbai And 3 Ors
WITH
Page 5/7
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 622 OF 2018 In
WRIT PETITION LODGING NO . 874 OF 2018
Anita Dattatray Dhole And 6 Ors ....Petitioner V/S
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And ....Respondent 3 Ors
Ms Ronita Bhattacharya & Mr. Kranti L. C. for petitioner in WPL/3108/2017, WPL/3301/2017, WPL/3314/2017, WPL/3316/2017,WPL/3350/2017, WPL/3368/2017, WPL/3390/2017, WPL/385/2018 & WPL/2475/18
Mr. Nikhil Patil a/w Mr. Prabhakar Jadhav for petitioner in WPL/3278/2017
Ms. Juilee Ghadge i/b Mr. Himanshu Kode for Petitioner in WPL/1158/2017, WPL/1332/17,
Mr. Prashant V. Malik a/w Mr. Irfan Ansari a/w Mr. Vaibhav Shah i/b Mr. Nilesh Masurkar for petitioner in WP/1664/2018 Mr. A.Y.Sakhare, SR. Counsel a/w Mr. Sagar Patil for respondent BMC in PIL/140/2006
Mr. Sagar Patil for respondent BMC in all other matters except PIL/140/2006
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. L.T.Satelkar, AGP for respodent State in PIL/140/2006
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Ms. Geeta Shastri, Addl. G.P. for respondent state in WPL/1158/2017, WP/1664/18 & WPL/2475/18
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Ms. Deepali Patankar, Asst. to G.P. for res. state in WPL/3314/17 & WPL/3278/17, WPL/3108/17
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. Hemant Haryan, AGP for respondent state in WPL/3316/17
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. Sukanta Karmakar, AGP for resp. State in WPL/1332/2017, WPL/3301/2017 &
Page 6/7
WPL/3350/17
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. S.B.Gore for respondent state in WPL/3368/17
Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. Manish Upadhyay, AGP for respondent state in WPL/3390/17 Mr. Girish Godbole, Spl. Counsel a/w Mr. Himanshu Takke, AGP for respondent state in WPL/385/18 Ms. Sharmila Deshmukh for respondent no. 3 in WPL/874/18 & Respondent no. 6 & 7 in WPL/1158/17, Mr. A.P.Kulkarni for respodent no. 3 in WPL/1158/17, WPL/1332/17, WPL/3278/17 & for respondent no. 4 in WPL/3108/17, WPL/3314/17, WPL/3316/17, WPL/3350/17, WPL/3368/17, WPL/3390/17 & for respodent no. 5 in WPL/3301/17,
Mr. Anoop Patil for respondent no. 4 in WPL/385/18 Ms. Janhavi Rane for respondent no. 5 in WPL/3108/2017 Ms. Kiran Bagalia for R.No.4 in WPL/3976/2018�
CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.S. GADKARI, JJ DATE : 18th January, 2019
P.C. :
Place the matter on board on 30/01/2019 for directions.
( ASSOCIATE )
Page 7/7
Anita Dattatray Dhole
Janhit Manch
Baban S Rahatwal
Panchsheel Nagar (sra) Co-op.hsg.society
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai
State Of Maharashtra
A.S. OKA
A.S. GADKARI
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court