Nitin Ashruba Dhanve and Others Vs the State of… — Service and Employment | Bombay HC (2018)

Nitin Ashruba Dhanve and Others Vs the State of… — Service and Employment | Bombay HC (2018)

1186.18WP+.odt

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITOIN NO. 1186 OF 2018

1. Ashok S/o Somnath Swami Age : 35 yeas, Occ : Teacher, R/o At. Post. Morfali, Kendra Asardoh, Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

2. Dilip S/o Tukaram Sanap Age : 47 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Post. Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

3. Dipak S/o Narayan Gaikwad Age : 36 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At. Post Chinchpur Kendra, Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

4. Balasaheb S/o Vishnu Gadkar Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At. Post Amla Kendra, Devadhifal, Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

5. Balasaheb S/o Yashwant Jogdand Age : 42 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At. Post. Jivachiwaid (Ke), Lavhuri, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

6. Ramdhan S/o Yadavrao Hajare Age : 45 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Post. Maindvadi, Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

..PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through its Secretary, Rural Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

1186.18WP+.odt

2

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITION NO. 1195 OF 2018

1. Nitin S/o Ashruba Dhanve Age : 40 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Adgaon Post : Adgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

2. Sumedh S/o Sakharam Jogdand Age : 36 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Eat, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

3. Balasaheb S/o Ramkisan Dongardive Age : 36 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Adgaon Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

4. Jagannath S/o Khiraji Jadhav Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Eat, Post : Wadgaon (Guntha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

5. Smt. Vanita D/o Dyanobarao Kamble Age : 36 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Bakalwadi, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

6. Smt. Sapna Waman Mhaske Age : 37 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Wadgaon, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

3

1186.18WP+.odt

7. Smt. Surekha Prabhakarrao Gore Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Umarad (Kh), Post : Khande Pargaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

8. Smt. Vaishali Sopanrao Waghmare Age : 36 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Wadgaon, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

9. Smt. Sunita Kantarao Joshi Age : 45 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Wadgaon, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

10. Smt. Reena Sanjay Nalawade Age : 37 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Secondary Girls School, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

11. Smt. Varsha Nagorao Hanwate Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Wadgaon, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

12. Smt. Vidya Suryakantrao Joshi Age : 48 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Eat, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

13. Smt. Jyoti Asraji Sonavane Age : 37 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Umarad (Kh.), Post : Khande Pargaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

14. Smt. Bhagwati Bharat Pardeshi Age : 48 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Eat, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

4

15. Yoganand S/o Achut Gandhale Age : 45 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zilla Parishad, Adgaon, Post : Wadgaon (Gundha), Tq. & Dist. Beed. ...

...PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through its Secretary, Rural Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITION NO. 1198 OF 2018

1. Shaikh Abdul Azim Vaziroddin Age : 43 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zum Zum Colony, Barshi Road, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

2. Khatib Md Muzammil Nawaboddin Age : 50 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Barabhai Galli Ambajogai, Tq. Ambajogai, Dist. Beed.

3. Sheikh Wasefoddin Ikramoddin Age : 55 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Majalgaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

4. Hashmi Mumtaz Ali Amir Ali Age : 50 years, Occ : Teacher,

1186.18WP+.odt

5

R/o At Post Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

5. Syeda Farida Begum Mushtaq Husain Age : 53 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Miyan Bhai Colony, Ambajogai, Tq. Ambajogai, Dist. Beed.

6. Julha Aliya Abdul Qdeer Age : 42 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Behind Heena Petrol Pump Barshi Naka Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

7. Mirza Nusrat Shahnawaz Baig Age : 39 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Behind Heena Petrol Pump Barshi Naka Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

8. Syed Afroz Begum Syed Ali Age : 41 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Nursery Road Shahinsha Nagar, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

9. Pathan Zafar Khan Jabbar Khan Age : 43 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Chuna Galli, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

10. Mirza Afrin Fatema Farhatulla Age : 32 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Post Asti, Tq. Asti, Dist. Beed.

11. Lodhi Naseem Ara Sadatulla Khan Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Bashirgunj, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

12. Shaikh Ashra Parveen Kayyum Age : 33 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zum Zum Colony, Barshi Road, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

6

13. Shaikh Shahin Begum Abdul Rahim Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zum Zum Colony, Barshi Road, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

14. Quadri Fareeda Tabassum Khalil Ahmed Age : 38 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zum Zum Colony, Barshi Road, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

15. Saudagar Iliyas Ahemed Abbas Ahemed Age : 39 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Khsderpura Barshinaka Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

16. Mohhamad Imaran Abdul Samad Khan Age : 42 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Zum Zum Colony, Barshi Road, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

17. Shaikh Sajid Farid Age : 42 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Shahinsha Nagar, Beed, Beed At present ZPPS Urdue Georai, Dist. Beed

18. Shaikh Urusa Hasin Khalil Age : 35 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o Ajijpura, Beed, At present ZPPS Vahegaon, Tq. Georai, Dist. Beed.

..PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through its Secretary, Rural Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

1186.18WP+.odt

7

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 1206 OF 2018

1. Babasaheb S/o Ramrao Kedar Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Umari, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

2. Rajendra S/o Jalindar Thombre Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Rarnali, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

3. Bhagwat S/o Dadarao Sonwane Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Massajog, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

4. Babasaheb S/o Mahadeo Kedar Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Malwadi, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

5. Ashruba S/o Arjunrao Sonwane Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Yewata, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

6. Sangita Arunrao Chavan Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Yewata, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

7. Smt. Nanda Madhukarrao Nirmale Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Shepwadi,

1186.18WP+.odt

8

Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

8. Dattatraya S/o Tukaram Raut Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Kanadimali, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

9. Hanumant S/o Dnyaboba Shinde Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Ekurga, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

10. Vasant S/o Uddhavrao Tarkasband Age : 38 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Pisegaon, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

11. Anil S/o Damodhar Chaudhary Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Yusufwadgaon, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

12. Shivhar S/o Narayan Chopne Age : 51 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Sadola, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

13. Dhammadipa Narsingrao Darbare Age : 37 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Yewata, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

14. Ambadas S/o Nanabhau Kale Age : 37 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Ghatewadi, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

15. Lata Vyankatrao Bangar Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Massajog, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

9

16. Ramkishan S/o Deorao Sangle Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Janegaon, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

17. Chandrakant S/o Bhaurao Raskar Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Kalsambar, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

18. Manohar S/o Rama Ovahal Age : 50 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Kalsambar, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

19. Bibishan S/o Barikrao Patil Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Neknoor, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

20. Vilas S/o Navnath Kapse Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Neknoor, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

21. Sulochana Angad Phad Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o C/o. Z.P. M.S. Kumbhephal, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

.. PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through : Deputy Secretary, School Education & Sports Department, Mantralaya, Extension Bhavan, Mumbai-32.

2. Director of Education (Primary), Education Directorate, Maharashtra Pune.

1186.18WP+.odt

10

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

4. Block Education Officer, Panchayat Samiti Kaij, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

5. Block Education Officer, Panchayat Samiti, Ambajogai, Tq. Ambajogai, Dist. Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITION NO. 1511 OF 2018

1. Shrirang S/o Ashruba Ghodke Age : 51 years, Occ : Service, R/o Waghora, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

2. Mohan S/o Haribhau Rathod Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Waghora, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

3. Sumani S/o Haribhau Raut Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Anandgaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

4. Keshav S/o Kisan Bharti Age : 35 years, Occ : Service, R/o Kharat Adgaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

5. Chatrabhuj S/o Ramrao Gavali Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o Harki Nimgaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

11

6. Balaprasad S/o Madanlal Chavan Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o Mali Pargaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

7. Piraji S/o Malhari Wanole Age : 34 years, Occ : Service, R/o Abegaon, Tq. Majalgaon, Dist. Beed.

..PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Secretary, School Education & Sports Department, Maharashtra State, Mumbai-32.

2. The State of Maharashtra Through the Secretary, Rural Development Department, Maharashtra State, Mumbai-32.

3. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

4. The Chief Executive Officer, Beed Zilla Parishad, Beed.

5. The Education Officer (Primary), Beed Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITION NO. 1606 OF 2018

1. Ajinath Bhausaheb Pache Age : 39 years, Occ : Service, R/o Devinimgaon, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

12

2. Babasaheb Shripati Londhe Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o Daithana, Post. Takalsing, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

3. Sanjay Shrivant Sole Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o Shikshak Colony, Matoshri Nagar, Khadkat Road, Ashti

4. Altaf Mohmad Shaikh Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o Takalsing, Post. Takalsing, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed

5. Usha Sakharam Morale Age : 38 years, Occ : Service, R/o Near 132 (K.V.) Sub Station, Ashti, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

6. Somanth Waman Walke Age : 35 years, Occ : Service, R/o Loni (S), Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

7. Sayyed Sallaudin Sayyed Rahiman Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Pimparkhed, Tq. Jamkhed, Dist. Ahmednagar.

8. Salim Shikandar Shaikh Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o Khuntefal, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

9. Sachin Raghunath Andhale Age : 39 years, Occ : Service, R/o Limbodi, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

10. Dattatray Trimbak Gadekar Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Khadkat, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

13

11. Shobhana Vishwanath Satav Age : 38 years, Occ : Service, R/o Behind Tekade Hospital, Ashti, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

12. Raghunath Ramji Khandagale Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o Shindewadi, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

13. Sadu Bhausaheb Gavhane Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Velturi, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

14. Shahadev Ajinath Pimple Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Matoshri Coloney, Ashti, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

.. PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Secretary, Rural Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed. .. RESPONDENTS

1186.18WP+.odt

14

WITH

WRIT PETITION NO. 1607 OF 2018

1. Sunil S/o Dnyanoba Khedkar Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Nandevali, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

2. Dilip S/o Namdeo Jaybhaye Age : 51 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Shirur, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

3. Madhukar S/o Babasaheb Sanap Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Hivarsinga, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

4. Dnyanoba S/o Bhaguji Dhakane Age : 56 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Zapewadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

5. Bharat S/o Hanumant Dhakane Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Dhangarwadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

6. Suresh S/o Shankar Sonwane Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Dhangarwadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

7. Haribhau S/o Daulatrao Kanthale Age : 54 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Tagadgaon, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

8. Raghunath S/o Govindrao Nagargoje Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Nimgaon (M), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

15

9. Ajinath S/o Laxman Deshmukh Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Gomalwada, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

10. Namdeo S/o baburao Jaybhaye Age : 51 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Pimpalner, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

11. Sanjaykumar S/o Baburao Dorle Age : 45 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Jatnandur, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

12. Tajuddin S/o Muniruddin Shaikh Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bargajwadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

13. Vitthal S/o Maruti Jadhav Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Wadali, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

14. Eknath S/o Bhanudas Kharat Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Vadali, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

15. Pradip S/o Raghunath Kanthale Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bavi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

16. Sominath S/o Sitaram Misal Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Vanjarwadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

16

17. Asha Devrao Garkal Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Raymoha, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

18. Subhash S/o Bhagwan Kanthale Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Yelamb (B), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

19. Mahadeo S/o Rabhaji Shirsat Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Khopati, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

20. Mubarak S/o Shabbir Shaikh Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.H.S. Shirapur (Gat), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

21. Shivaji S/o Kashinath Dudhal Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Limba, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

22. Suresh S/o Laxman Londhe Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bavi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

23. Lateef Hamid Sayyed Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Rakshashbhuvan, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

24. Mohan S/o Sudhakar Kulthe Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Rakshashbhuvan, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

17

25. Ashok S/o Narayan Shirsat Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bhadkel, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

26. Rajendra S/o Bhanudas Shinde Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bhadkel, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

27. Uttam S/o Nivrutti Tambe Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Pimpalner, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

28. Kalyan S/o Dnyanoba Sanap Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Anandwadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

29. Jalindar S/o Ram Gaikwad Age : 43 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Badewadi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

30. Dattatray S/o Krishnat Gadekar Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.H.S. Phulsangvi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

31. Bhausaheb S/o Kashinath Shelake Age : 4 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.H.S. Phulsangvi, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

32. Baban S/o Bhanudas Tambe Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Shirapur (D), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

33. Chhatrapati S/o Tanaji Sasane Age : 48 years, Occ : Service,

1186.18WP+.odt

18

R/o Z.P.P.S. Hivarsinga,
Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

34. Shilpabai Vishnu Badade Age : 40 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Hivarsinga, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

35. Santosh S/o Bhaurao Bhabad Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Ukirda (Ch), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

36. Gangasagar Nanasaheb Maske Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Shirapur (D), Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

37. Bhagwat S/o Laxman Garkal Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Malegaon, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

38. Suresh S/o Ramrao Nagargoje Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Therala, Tq. Shirur (K), Dist. Beed.

39. Phulchand S/o Ashruba Bade Age : 51 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Mahasangvi, Tq. Patoda, Dist. Beed.

40. Sanjay S/o Mahadev Jaybhay Age : 39 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.H.S. Sautada, Tq. Patoda, Dist. Beed.

41. Vitthal S/o Ramkrushna Binwade Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Mahadangvi Tq. Patoda, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

19

42. Ramrao S/o Sakharam Bangar Age : 50 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Manzari, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

43. Ashok S/o Vishwanath Khose Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Mandavjali, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

44. Bibishan S/o Rambhau Shelke Age : 45 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Imampur, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

45. Suresh S/o Dhondiram Kamble Age : 45 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Loladgaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

46. Prabhawati Dashrath Jadhavar Age : 38 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Loladgaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

47. Aruna Saudagar Zapugade Age : 47 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Pothara, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

48. Vimal Changdev Choure Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Roulasgaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

49. Jayshree Ramdas Mehetre Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Loladgaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

20

50. Bapu S/o Tatyasaheb Khandare Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Pothara, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

51. Jankiram S/o Govardhan Kurund Age : 47 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Kurla, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

52. Vishnu S/o Sakharam Gore Age : 48 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Shidod, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

53. Popat S/o Dagdu Gaikwad Age : 41 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Raulasgaon, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

54. Manjushri Somnath Gawali Age : 32 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Gawalwadi, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

55. Nagutai Rangnath Joshi Age : 57 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Kakadhira, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

56.Shailaja Satwa Ovhal
Age : 36 years, Occ : Service,
R/o Z.P.P.S. Jirewadi,
Tq. & Dist. Beed.

57. Shailesh S/o Pandharinath Chilwant Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Kakadhira, Tq. & Dist. Beed.

58. Savitri Shripati Kamble Age : 38 years, Occ : Service,

1186.18WP+.odt

21

R/o Z.P.P.S. Gandhinagar,

Tq. & Dist. Beed.

59. Shivnanda Dhondiram Tidke Age : 46 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Sadola, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

60. Siraj Mahamad Shaikh Age : 50 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Khadparton, Tq. Ambejogai & Dist. Beed.

61. Shaikh Shameem Begum Shaik Ameer Age : 50 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Guruwarpeth, Ambejogai, Tq. Ambejogai, Dist. Beed.

62. Jyoti Rameshwarrao Malode Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Khaparton, Tq. Ambejogai & Dist. Beed.

63. Babasaheb S/o Mahadeo Pawar Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Khilad, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

64.Aslam Yakub Shaikh
Age : 48 years, Occ : Service,
R/o Z.P.P.S. Hivara,
Tq. Ashti & Dist. Beed.

65. Rameshwar S/o Bhimrao Sumbe Age : 45 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Shirapur, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

66. Shidheshwar S/o Eknath Shendage Age : 42 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Sarate Wadgaon,

1186.18WP+.odt

22

Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.

67. Jayshri Manikrao Bade Age : 37 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Varvati, Tq. Beed & Dist. Beed.

68. Vinod S/o Acchutrao Wagh Age : 32 years, Occ : Service, R/o Mitranagar, Beed, Tq. Beed & Dist. Beed.

69. Govind S/o Ramkishan Yadav Age : 49 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Bhatumba, Tq. Kaij & Dist. Beed.

70. Shivaji S/o Rohidas Jagtap Age : 44 years, Occ : Service, R/o Z.P.P.S. Limbarui, Tq. Beed & Dist. Beed.

.. PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Secretary, School Education & Sports Department, Maharashtra State, Mumbai-32.

2. The State of Maharashtra Through the Secretary, Rural Development Department, Maharashtra State, Mumbai – 32.

3. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

4. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed,

1186.18WP+.odt

23

5. The Education Officer (Primary), Beed Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITOIN NO. 1609 OF 2018

Navnath S/o Govindrao Rakh
Age : 34 years, Occ : Service as
Primary Graduate Teacher,
Zilla Parishad Primary School,
Pimpari, Tq. Parli-Vaijnath,
District Beed.

..PETITIONER

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through its Secretary, School Education Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

WITH

WRIT PETITOIN NO. 1377 OF 2018

1. Siddharth S/o Ekanath Jadhav Age : 37 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Post. Devdahiphal, Tq. Dharur, Dist. Beed.

2. Prabhakar S/o Devidas Ghadge Age : 47 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Kekatsarni, Post. Hole, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

1186.18WP+.odt

24

3. Shivanand S/o Ganpati Swami Age : 35 years, Occ : Teacher, R/o At Ladegaon, Post. Adas, Tq. Kaij, Dist. Beed.

..PETITIONERS

VERSUS

1. The State of Maharashtra, Through its Secretary, Rural Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

2. The Director of Education (Primary), Maharashtra State, Pune.

3. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed.

4. The Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad, Beed.

..RESPONDENTS

.....

Shri S.A. Nagarsoge, Shri D.G. Kamble, Shri. M.K.
Deshpande, Shri V.P. Savant, Shri T.M. Tandale
and Shri A.V. Rakh, Advocates for the
petitioners.

Shri S.S. Dande, Shri C.S. Kulkarni, Shri S.B.
Yawalkar, Shri P.N. Kutti and Shri P.K.
Lakhotiya, AGPs for the Respondent/State.

Shri V.M. Chate, Advocate for Respondent Nos.3
and 4 in WP Nos. 1186/2018, 1195/2018 and
1198/2018,

Shri V.M. Chate, Advocate for Respondent Nos.3 to
5 in WP No.1206/2018.

Shri Kiran B. Jadhavar, Advocate for Respondent
Nos.3 and 4 in WP Nos. 1606/2018, 1609/2018 and
1377/2018

Shri Kiran B. Jadhavar, Advocate for Respondent
Nos.4 and 5 in WP Nos. 1511/2018 and 1607/2018,

.....

1186.18WP+.odt

25

CORAM: S.S.SHINDE &

S.M.GAVHANE,JJ.

Reserved on : 08.02.2018

 Pronounced on : 20.02.2018

JUDGMENT : (Per S.S.Shinde, J.):

Rule.Rulemadereturnable

forthwith. With the consent of learned
counsel appearing for the parties, heard
finally.

2.Since the issue raised and relief

claimed in these Petitions is identical, all
these Petitions are heard together and being
disposed of by this common judgment.

3.Learned counsel appearing for the

petitioners submits that, the Chief Executive

Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed has issued the

impugned orders, thereby reverting the

petitioners from the post of Trained Graduate

Teachers to Assistant Teachers, however

without giving an opportunity of hearing and

1186.18WP+.odt

26

in contravention to the principles of natural
justice. The Chief Executive Officer has
passed the impugned orders, which are
contrary to the government policy as well as
the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court.

The impugned orders passed by the Chief
Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed are
without there being any valid reason and
without application of mind, and therefore,
they are required to be quashed and set aside
in the interest of justice.

4.Learned A.G.Ps. appearing for the

Respondent State and its officials and the
learned counsel appearing for the Zilla
Parishad, Beed submit that the orders

impugned in these Petitions are self
speaking, in as much as, the reasons are

assigned in the impugned orders, and
therefore, the Petitions deserve to be

dismissed in limine.

1186.18WP+.odt

27

5.We have considered the rival

submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the parties, and also perused
the pleadings and grounds taken in the
Petitions. Admittedly, before passing the
impugned orders thereby reverting the
petitioners from the post of Trained Graduate
Teachers to the Assistant Teachers, the
reasonable opportunity of hearing has not
been afforded to the respective petitioners.
The impugned orders are passed in breach of
principles of natural justice, and therefore,
on the said ground alone, said orders deserve
to be quashed and set aside.

6.In the similar fact situation, this
Court in Writ Petition No. 217 of 2018
(Tatyaram S/o Dhanlal Kanade and others V/s
The State of Maharashtra and others) and
other connected Petitions, on 24th January,

1186.18WP+.odt

28

2018 in paras 5 to 7 observed thus :

“5.We have considered the rival
submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties, and
also perused the pleadings and grounds
taken in the Petitions. Admittedly,
before passing the impugned orders
thereby reverting the petitioners from
the post of Trained Graduate Teachers
to the Assistant Teachers, the
reasonable opportunity of hearing has
not been afforded to the respective
petitioners. The impugned orders are
passed in breach of principles of
natural justice, and therefore, on
the said ground alone, said orders
deserve to be quashed and set aside to
the extent of petitioners in each
Petition.

6.The Bombay High Court Bench
at Goa in the case of Mrs. Kunda
Santosh Kerkar alias Kunda Narayan
Kerkar V/s Hon'ble Speaker, Goa
Legislative Assembly and ors.1 in

1 2016(5) Mah.L.J. 593

1186.18WP+.odt

29

similar facts situation observed that
the impugned order in the said
petition is passed without giving an
opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner therein, and accordingly,
the said impugned order was quashed
and set aside. In the facts of that
case also the petitioner therein was
promoted and thereafter, he was
reverted to the original post of
Junior Assistant with immediate
effect. The said order was passed
withouthearingthepetitioner
therein, which came to be quashed on
the ground of violation of principles
of natural justice.

7.In the light of discussion
herein above, the impugned orders
dated 14th December, 2017 in respective
Writ Petitions, passed by the Chief
Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad,
Beed are quashed and set aside to the
extent of the petitioners. The
Petitions are accordingly allowed.
Rule made absolute in above terms.

However, we make it clear that,

1186.18WP+.odt

30

we have quashed and set aside the
impugned orders only on the ground of
non-adherence to the principles of
natural justice and not on any other
ground. We further make it clear that,
thoughwehaveallowedthese
Petitions, the same shall not be
construed as an impediment to the
concerned Respondent/ Respondents from
passing an appropriate order/orders on
merits of each case.”

7.Taking the same view and for the

same reasons as stated in order dated 24th
January, 2018 passed in Writ Petition No.217
of 2018 and other connected Writ Petitions,

referred above, we pass the following
order :-

ORDER:-

(i)The impugned orders dated 14th December,
2017 issued by the Respondent – Chief
Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Beed is
quashed and set aside. The petitions are

1186.18WP+.odt

31

accordingly allowed. Rule made absolute in
above terms.

However, we make it clear that, we
have quashed and set aside the impugned

orders on the ground of non-adherence to the
principles of natural justice and not on any
other ground. We further make it clear that,
though we have allowed these Petitions, the
same shall not be construed as an impediment
to the concerned Respondent from passing an
appropriate order on merits.

(ii)Other similarly situated teachers, whose
names are mentioned in the impugned orders
and who have not approached this Court, and

the facts in their cases and the action taken

against them, is identical, in that case, the
decision taken in Writ Petition No.217 of
2018 and other connected Writ Petitions shall

be made applicable and they are not required

32

1186.18WP+.odt

to file separate Petition/Petitions. The
Chief Executive Officers shall take
appropriate corrective steps/ measures even
in the case of similarly situated employees,
who have not approached to this Court, but
their names have been shown in the impugned
orders.

 [S.M.GAVHANE] [S.S.SHINDE]
 JUDGE JUDGE

SGA