The Court disposed of multiple company petitions against Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. in light of an NCLT order directing the company's liquidation. Petitioners were given liberty to lodge claims with the appointed liquidator.
Petitions disposed with liberty to lodge claims with the liquidator appointed by NCLT.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
1
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
COMPANY PETITION NO. 75 OF 2014
Industrial Engineering Corporation … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 577 OF 2013 M/s. Chirag Enterprises A Sole Prop. Concern of Mr.Chirag Punatar … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 65 OF 2014 Velocity Transolutions Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 101 OF 2014 ATO (I) Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 159 OF 2014
Sharma Fabricators & Erectors Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 201 OF 2014
DHTC Logistics Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 279 OF 2014
1/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
2
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
Shah ways Pvt. Ltd. (Formerly known as Paras Transports) … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 334 OF 2014
Welsun Projects Limited (Formerly known as MSK Projects (India) Limited … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH OLR NO. 405 OF 2014
The Official Liquidator High Court Bombay … Official Liquidator Vs. Noble Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. … Respondent
… Official Liquidator
WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 536 OF 2014
Ekato Rohr-Und Mischtechnik GMBH … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH
COMPANY PETITION NO. 634 OF 2014
M/s. Union Roadways Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 792 OF 2014
M/s. State Pipe and Supply Company … Petitioner Vs.
Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH
COMPANY PETITION NO. 984 OF 2014
Dmsons Metal Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs.
2/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
3
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 246 OF 2017 IN
COMPANY PETITION NO. 984 OF 2014
Lebracs Rubber Lining Pvt. Ltd. … Applicant Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 8 OF 2015
| Hrishikesh Industrial Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. Vs. |
… Petitioner |
|---|---|
| Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. WITH |
… Respondent |
| OLR NO. 142 OF 2015 | |
| The Official Liquidator High Court | |
| Bombay Vs. |
… Official Liquidator |
| Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. | … Respondent |
| WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 150 |
OF 2015 |
| M/s. Mahavir Tube Corporation Vs. |
… Petitioner |
| Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 153 |
… Respondent OF 2015 |
| M/s. Mahavir Tube Corporation Vs. |
… Petitioner |
| Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 171 |
… Respondent OF 2015 |
| Jayesh Doshi Vs. |
… Petitioner |
| Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. WITH |
… Respondent |
3/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
4
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
COMPANY PETITION NO. 189 OF 2015
IBIC Engineering (Division of IBI Chematru (Engg.& Cony( Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 237 OF 2015 M/s. Shreyas Steel Corporation … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 290 OF 2015 M/s. ANS Construction Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 414 OF 2015
Shashikant N. Shah (Name and Style Subha Jyot Traders and Engineers Sole Prop.) … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 449 OF 2015 M/s. Control Engineers … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 486 OF 2015 M/s. Premier Logistics … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 530 OF 2015 The South Eastern Carriers Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner
4/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
5
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
Vs.
HDO Technologies Limited … Respondent
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION (LODG.) NO. 533 OF 2015 IN
COMPANY PETITION NO. 159 OF 2014
Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Applicant Vs. Sharma Fabricators & Erectors P. Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 627 OF 2015 M/s. GGS Infrastructure Private Limited … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 730 OF 2015 Associated Road Carriers Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 740 OF 2015 M/s. S.L. Hirers, Prop. Of Nilofer Bare Alam Shaikh … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 794 OF 2015 M/s. Crescent Roadways Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 812 OF 2015 VRC Constructions (India) Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent WITH
5/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
6
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
COMPANY PETITION NO. 1131 OF 2015
S. Amin and Co. Prop.of Anand Amin … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH COMPANY PETITION (LODG.) NO. 1209 OF 2015
Keller Ground Engineering India Pvt. Ltd. … Petitioner Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
WITH COMPANY PETITION NO. 262 OF 2016
Indiana Conveyors Pvt. Ltd.
… Petitioner
Vs.
Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd.
… Respondent
WITH COMPANY APPLICATION NO. 585 OF 2016 IN COMPANY PETITION NO. 159 OF 2014
Standard Chartered Bank … Applicant Vs. Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd. … Respondent
Mr.S.P. Dalal I/b Dalal and Co. for petitioner in CP/75/2014, CP/171/2015, CP/141/2015.
Mr.Dhiren Akbari for petitioner in CP/577/2013.
Ms. H.D. Kapadia I/b Kalyani G. Parmar for petitioner in CP/101/2014, CP/201/2014, CP/279/2014, CP/530/2015, CP/730/2015.
Ms.Vanita Kakar for petitioner in CP/159/2014.
Mr.Shubhabata Chakaraborti I/b Juris Corp for petitioner in CP/334/2014 and for applicant in CA/585/2016.
Mr.Rahul Sarda I/b Prompt Legal for petitioner in CP/536/2014.
6/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
7
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
Mr.Saurabh Patil I/b Nitesh V. Bhutekar for petitioner in CP/792/2014.
Ms. Ameeta Bakshi I/b Anil Agarwal for petitioner in CP/984/2014 and for applicant in CA/246/2017.
Mr.A.W.Ansari I/b Bhupendra Parekh for petitioner in CP/237/2015.
Mr.Darshan Ashar I/b M/s. Sanjay Udeshi and Co. for petitioner in CP/812/2015.
Mr.Sachin Chowdhari I/b Dharam and Co. for petitioner in CP/1131/2015.
None for petitioner in CP/634/2014, CP/8/2015, CP/150/2015, CP/153/2015, CP/189/2015, CP/290/2015, CP/449/2015, CP/486/2015, CP/627/2015, CP/740/2015, CP/794/2015, CPL/1209/2015 & CP/262/2016.
None for respondent.
Mr.Mahendhar Aithe, company prosecutor for official liquidator.
CORAM : K.R.SHRIRAM, J. DATE : 6TH JULY 2018
P.C.
1 Mr.Chakraborti appearing for petitioner in Company Petition No.334 of 2014 tenders a copy of an order pronounced on 25th June 2018 by the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench (NCLT) which is taken on record and marked 'X' for identification.
7/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
8
4.cp.75.2014==.doc
(K.R. SHRIRAM, J.)
8/8
Shraddha Talekar PS
2 issues framed by the court
Effect of NCLT order directing liquidation on pending company petitions.
Procedure for petitioners to preserve their claims after company liquidation.
Industrial Engineering Corporation
Hindustan Dorr Oliver Ltd.
Krishna Ram Shriram
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
