Dismissed

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat v. Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav

Bombay HC5 Dec 2017SA/67/2015

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court dismissed the second appeal challenging a decree for specific performance. It held the appellant failed to prove her thumb impression was obtained on blank paper, rejecting submissions that compensation would suffice and finding no substantial legal question.

What did the court decide?

Second appeal dismissed; pending civil application rejected; decree for specific performance upheld.

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat Vs Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav — Specific Performance | Bombay HC (2017)

¶1

¶2

5 sa 67-15 with cas 1615-17-c

¶3

Priya

¶4

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

¶5

SECOND APPEAL NO.67 OF 2015 WITH

¶6

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1615 OF 2017

¶7

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat V/s.

¶8

... Appellant

¶9

Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav ... Respondent

¶10

Mr.Ajay A. Joshi for the Appellant/Applicant. None for the Respondent.

¶11

CORAM : NITIN W. SAMBRE, J. DATED : DECEMBER 5, 2017.

¶12

P.C. :

¶13

. The second appeal is by the original defendant, who suffered

¶14

a decree for specific performance of contract.

¶15

The learned counsel for the Appellant Mr. Ajay A. Joshi while inviting attention of this Court to the provisions of Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, would urge that discretion exercised by both the Courts below in granting the specific performance based on the Agreement of Sale dated September 20, 2007 is misplaced for the reasons of failure of exercise of discretion.

¶16

Priya 2 5 sa 67-15 with cas 1615-17-c

¶17

According to the Appellant he could be adequately compensated by asking payment of compensation, as out of total 90 R. land, 40 R land is ordered to be transferred in favour of the RespondentPlaintiff.

¶18

If the aforesaid submissions are appreciated in the background of findings recorded, it is to be noted that the Appellant has come out with the specific defence that the agreement is not the agreement of sale, but there was loan transaction. The Trial court framed issues at Ex.16 and appreciated the defence of the Appellant that the Appellant claimed that the Respondent-Plaintiff has obtained her thumb impression on blank stamp paper. The Trial court also framed an issue as regard readiness and willingness of the Respondent to perform his part of contract and granted the decree for specific performance.

¶19

The Appellate court confirmed the said decree based on evidence that is brought on record.

¶20

Priya 3 5 sa 67-15 with cas 1615-17-c

¶21

Once the appellant has come out with a defence that her

¶22

thumb impression was obtained on blank stamp paper, the burden was on the Appellant to prove the same to which she has failed to discharge.

¶23

Apart from the above, both the courts below have appreciated the willingness and readiness of the Respondentplaintiff in execution of the contract.

¶24

In the wake of above against the concurrent findings, no substantial question of law could be noticed. Second appeal as such dismissed.

¶25

As consequence of dismissal of second appeal, the pending

¶26

Civil Application also stands rejected.

¶27

(NITIN W. SAMBRE J.)

¶28

…...

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat v. Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat v. Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Shri Murlidhar S. Pednekar Vs Shri Sadashiv a. Vaze and Others.

Shri Murlidhar S. Pednekar (Thr Poa Mr. Mahadeo Murlidhar Pednekar) (Since Deceased) Vs Shri Sadashiv a. Vaze and Others.

Shri. Yashwant Shankar Nazare (Thr. Const. Attorney Shri. Surendra Yashwant Nazare) Vs Smt. Dattatraya Mahadeo Pandharkame

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat Vs Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat Vs Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav

Sou. Parvati Dasu Thorat Vs Vitthal Sarjerao Jadhav