Dismissed

Vaintey Co-Op Hsg. Society Ltd. v. Maria Fernandes (Since Deceased) through Her Legal Representative and Legal Heir Stanley Mascarenha

Bombay HC10 Aug 2017MPT/36/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court dismissed the respondent's petition challenging the Letters of Administration granted to a deceased's heir. The court held that the petitioner society lacked locus standi to file for revocation merely due to correspondence from third parties claiming interest in the property.

What the court decided

AI extract

Vaintey Co-Op Hsg. Society Ltd. Vs Maria Fernandes… — Succession and Inheritance | Bombay HC (2017)

26-MPT-36-2017

Shailaja

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY TESTAMENTARY AND INTESTATE JURISDICTION

¶5

MISC. PETITION NO. 36 OF 2017 IN

¶6

TESTAMENTARY PETITION NO. 1746 OF 2012

¶7

Vaintey Co-op Hsg. Society Ltd. ] Petitioner Vs. Maria Fernandes (since deceased) ] Shri Stanley Mascarenhas ] Respondent

¶8

Mr. Neelesh Kalantri, for petitioner.

¶9

…... CORAM : R.G. KETKAR, J. DATE : 10^th AUGUST, 2017. P.C .

¶10

Heard Mr. Kalantri, learned Counsel for the petitioner

¶11

at length.

¶12

By this Petition, petitioner Society has, inter alia, prayed for revocation of Letters of Administration dated 31^st March, 2015 in Testamentary Petition No. 1746 of 2012 after condoning delay in filing Misc. Petition as also for injunction restraining the respondent from disposing or alienating or creating third party interest in flat No. 7737, Vaintey Co.op.Hsg. Society Ltd., 197, Kannamwar Nagar-1, Vikroli (E), Mumbai; for directing respondent to hand over possession of the said property to the petitioner.

¶13

In support of this Petition, Mr. Kalantri submitted that respondent had instituted Testamentary Petition No. 1746 of 2011 in this Court. By order dated 31^st March, 2015, Letters of

¶14

2 26-MPT-36-2017

¶15

Administration was granted to the respondent. He submitted that several persons have entered into correspondence with the petitioner/society claiming right in respect of the property. He submitted that petitioner though is not effected, because of constant correspondence made by the persons claiming interest in the property, it has instituted present Petition. He, therefore, submitted that Petition requires consideration.

¶16

I have considered submissions advanced by Mr. Kalantri. I have also perused Testamentary Petition No. 1746 of 2012. Mr. Kalantri submitted that the respondent has not clarified as to on what basis, he is claiming heir and legal representative of Maria Fernandes and claiming right in respect of the premises in petitioner/Society. A perusal of the Testamentary Petition and in particular paragraphs 4 onwards show that respondent has set out relations with deceased Maria Fernandes. This Court had granted Letters of Administration on 31^st March, 2015. Even, if the persons claiming interest in subject matter of the property are writing letters to the Society, the petitioner is at liberty to inform them to adopt appropriate proceedings. It cannot be said that the petitioner has locus to maintain the present Petition for revocation of Letters of Administration. 5. In view thereof, on the ground of maintainability of the Petition, at the instance of the petitioner/Society, the same is dismissed. Order accordingly.

¶17

[R.G. KETKAR, J.]

Vaintey Co-Op Hsg. Society Ltd. v. Maria Fernandes (Since Deceased) through Her Legal Representative and Legal Heir Stanley Mascarenha

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

Vaintey Co-Op Hsg. Society Ltd. v. Maria Fernandes (Since Deceased) through Her Legal Representative and Legal Heir Stanley Mascarenha

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Bhikaji Sahadev Pawar Vs Keshav Govind Gawde ........Deceased

Gautam Rasiklal Ashra Vs Bharat Rasiklal Ashra

Nitin Patankar and Noella Patankar Vs Hannah Netanya Patankar (Minor)

Mrs. Janhavi Gaurav Dhotre Vs Mr. Gaurav Shridhar Dhotre

Sadiq Shaikh Mohamed Yusuf Vs Nadira Shaikh Mohamed Yusuf(Deceased)

Homi Phirozshaw Daruwalla Zarastrain Parsee Vs Feroz Rustamji Kavarana Zarastrian Parsee (Deceased)