The position emerging from these affidavits is that of the thirteen workers who have been regularized with effect from 23 June 1998, about eight have already superannuated between the years 2000 and 2011, two have expired, respectively, in the years 2007 and 2010, and two others have been transferred in the years 2008 and 2011 to other departments of the State Government, whereas one is still working as Class IV employee in the post. Even this workman has superannuated on 15 November 2015. As for the remaining twenty four workmen, about ten of them have either expired or voluntarily resigned or superannuated or removed from the service before the Industrial Tribunal passed the impugned award. This is reflected in Exhibit-3 to the Additional Affidavit of the Farm Superintendent dated 1 July 2015. As for the other fourteen, even they have either died or superannuated during the period 4 January 2000 and 20 February 2013. The dates of their superannuations and deaths are also reflected in Exhibit-3 of the Affidavit 1 July 2015. There is no response filed by the Union to this Affidavit and in the premises, the statement made by the Farm Superintendent in Exhibit-3, cannot be disputed. There is no question, in the premises, of making anyone permanent as of today.
