The High Court of Bombay dismissed the income tax appeal as questions of law arising therein were found to be similar to and already resolved in a subsequent judgment, rendering the current appeal devoid of a substantive legal question.
Appeal dismissed; no new questions of law arise.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
:1:
| IN THE HIGH ORDINARY O |
COURT RIGINAL |
OF JU CIVI |
DICATURE L |
AT JUR |
BOMBAY ISDICTION |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| INCOME TAX |
AP |
PEAL | NO.1033 | OF | 2008 | |
| The Comm M/s. |
issioner of Income tax-4. Vs. Shriyam Borking |
Intermediary | Ltd |
..Appell . |
ant. |
..Respondent. |
| Mr.Vimal | Gupta | for | the | Appellant. | ||
| Mr. | A.K. | Jasani | f |
or the |
Respondent. | |
| CORAM : F.I DATD : |
. REBE |
LLO 19TH |
& R.S. JANU |
MOHI ARY, |
TE, JJ. 2009. |
|
| PC | : | |||||
| 1. | The questions of |
law as |
framed | in this |
appeal | were |
| similar | to what was |
in |
question | in A |
ppeal | Lodging |
| No.1915 | of 2007 in |
the case |
of |
Commissioner | of | Income |
| Tax | Vs. Star Chemical |
s (Bomb |
ay) Pvt. |
Ltd. |
d | ecided on |
| 27.2.2008 | which were |
decided | against | the reve |
nue | and in |
| favour | of the assessee |
and |
the | said |
order | was |
| subsequent | ly followed in |
another | Appeal | No.338 | of | 2001 |
| in | the case of Commiss |
ioner of |
Income | Tax Vs. |
Ashok J. |
|
| Thawani | dated 11.2.200 |
8. C |
onsidering | the | above, | the |
questions of law as framed in this appeal would not
arise. Consequently appeal dismissed.
( R.S. MOHITE, J.)
( F.I.REBELLO, J.)
Colour shows how this judgement treated each authority
Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Star Chemicals (Bombay) Pvt. Ltd.Referred¶1
Appeal No.1915 of 2007
Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Ashok J. ThawaniReferred¶1
Appeal No.338 of 2001
Commissioner of Income Tax-4
Shriyam Boroking Intermediary Ltd
R.S. Mohite
F.I. Rebello
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
