Dismissed

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana and 2 Others v. Chedalla Sarada and 6 Others

Andhra Pradesh HC22 Dec 2023CMA/379/2014

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

High Court of Andhra Pradesh dismissed various appeals against property decrees and succession orders as infructuous due to disposal of related earlier appeals under Section 151, Order 38 Rule 3 CPC and Section 384 of the Succession Act.

What did the court decide?

Dismissed appeals as infructuous due to disposal of related appeals; no order as to costs.

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana and 2… — Succession and Inheritance | Andhra Pradesh HC (2023)

¶1

i i ■ ■

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI FRIDAY. THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE

¶3

PRESENT

¶4

THE HON’BLE JUSTICE DR V R K KRUPA SAGAR

¶5

AS NO: 99 OF 2011.512.776 OF 2013.856 OF 2017

¶6

¶7

CMA No.190 of 2013 & 379 nf 9ni4

¶8

AS NO: 99 OF 2011-

¶9

Appeal Under Section 96 of C.P.C. against the Decree and Judgment dt.31-10-2009 made in O.S.No. 71 of 1998, on the file of the Court of the I Additional District Judge, Rajahmundry, East Godavari District.

¶10

Between:

¶11

Cheedella Sarada, W/o.Venakta Siva Satyanarayana, R/o. D.No. 6-37/1/G1, Bandalaguda Jagir, Rajendra Nagar Mandal,

¶12

...APPELLANT

¶13

AND

¶14

Tummapudi Venkata Satyavathi (Died) W/o. Venakta Siva Satyanarayana, R/o. D.No. 6-37/1/G-1, Bandalaguda Jagir, Rajendra Nagar Mandal,

¶15

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o. Basava Raju, Business R/o. Rajahmundry.

¶16

Innamuri Bala Subrahmanyam, S/o. Veera Venakta Satyanarayana, Student, R/o. Rajahmundry.

¶17

Innamuri Gangaphani Ravi Teja, S/o. Veera Venakta Satyanarayana, Student, R/o. Rajahmundry. (R3 & R 4 are minors rep. by its father 2nd Respondent I Veeravenkata Satyanarayana)

¶18

Tummapudi Pitchamma (Died), W/o.S.Satyanarayana Mandal Parishad Development officer Office of Mandal Praja Parishad, Gesuganda Warangal District Resident of H.No.1-1-443, Prashanthnagar, Opp:NIT

¶19

Tummapudi Venakteswara Rao (Died), R&B (NH), Vijayawada,^Krishna Dist.

¶20

Tummapudi Basavaraju (Died), W/o. Sambasivarao R/o. Nidumukkala

¶21

Tummapudi Seetharamayya, S/o.Jaganmohan Rao, Business,^R/o. Kakinada, Near Big Mosque, D.No. 25-6-2, Ganjamvari Street,

¶22

Satya Saibabu & Co., by its Proprietor, P.kameswara Rao, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶23

Thummapudi Nagaratnam, W/o.jaganmohan Rao, Business,^R/o. Kakinada, Vasavi Binni Show Room, Near Big Mosque, D.No. 25-6-2,

¶24

Raja Associates by its Proprietor Chilukuri Ashok,, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahimundry.

¶25

Swarajsingh Khadi Bhandar,, A Society by its Manager, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶26

Syamala Bag Works, By the Proprietor, Beera Padmanabham, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶27

Hariharaputhra Agencies by its Proprietor, Polasanapalli Venakteswara Rao, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶28

Ramesh Trades by its Proprietor, A.Ramesh, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶29

M/s Lakshmi Industries, Rep. by its Manager, S.Gopala Krishna Reddy, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶30

M/s Seelam Nookayya & Sons, A Firm by its Partner:^S. Ramalingeswara Rao, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶31

#4 •

¶32

Sri Sai Real Estates by its Proprietor, Nadipalli Satya Bhama, Business, Tummapudi Qhambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶33

Shyam Assodiates by B.Srinivasa Rao, Business, Tummapudi Chambers, Main Road, Rajahmundry.

¶34

Sri Vinayaka Devi Rajeswari Cloth Shop, a Firm rep. by its Partner Basina Prasad, Shop No. 246, MG Complex, Thadithota,

¶35

21, Ashok T.V Servicing Net Work, by its Proprietor A.Ashok Reddy, Business, Rangireejupeta, Rajahmundry.

¶36

Lakshmi Vilas Bank, Rajahmundry, Rep. by its Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶37

Tamilnadu Marchtail Bank Ltd., Rep, by its Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶38

Karnataka Bank Ltd.,Rep. by its Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶39

The Aryapuram Co-Operative Urban Bank Ltd. Rajahmundry, Rep. by

¶40

its Secretary, Rajahmundry.

¶41

Bam of Madhura Ltd., Rajahmundry, Rep. by its Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶42

The Post Master, Ullithota Post Office, Rajahmundry.

¶43

Federal bank, Rajahmundry, Rep. by tis Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶44

Vysya Bank Ltd., Rep. by tis Branch Manager, Rajahmundry.

¶45

Nunna Padmasri, W/o. NVArya, R/o. D.No. 9-20-127 Binny Show

¶46

Room, Main Road,

¶47

Tummapudi Lalitha, W/o. Jaya Raj, R/o. SFS No. 70, APHB Colony,

¶48

Lalacheruvu,

¶49

Tummapudi Parameswara, D/o. Venkateswara Rao R/o. 31-11-2,

¶50

Hindu College Road, Machavaram,

¶51

Chundruri Hemalatha, W/o.Mallikharjuna Rao, R/o. 31-11-2, Hindu College Road, Machavaram,

¶52

Maddu Sri Krishna Veni, W/o. Ciridhara Babu, ASR Electrical School Street, Opp; Ram Mandir, Chirala.

¶53

Ac;,

¶54

Vysya Seva Sadan, rep by is Secretary, Rajahmundry. (RR Nos. 9,11 to 29 and 35 is not necessary parties in the appeal)

¶55

...RESPONDENTS

¶56

Counsel for the Appellant(s): SMT NAZREN representing^SRIVSR ANJANEYALU

¶57

Counsel for the Respondents No.2 to 4: SRI K. SARVA BHOUMA RAO Counsel for the Respondents No.8 to 10: SRI K. SUBRAHMANYAM Counsel for the Respondents No.30 to 32; SRI CH PUSHYAM KIRAN Counsel for the Respondents: None Appeared

¶58

AS NO: 512 OF 2013:

¶59

Appeal Under Section 96 of C.P.C. against the Decree and Judgment dt.31-10-2009 made in O.S.No. 42 of 2003, on the file of the Court of the I Additional District Judge, Rajahmundry, East Godavari^District. Between:

¶60

Tummapudi Veera Venkata Satyavathi (Died) (D-3), W/o. Late Shankara Rao R/o. Poranki Village, Krishna District. (A-5)

¶61

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o. Basava Raju,^R/o.31-1- 2/1, Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶62

Innamuri Bala Subrahmanyamma, S/o. I.V.V.Satyanarayana,^R/o.31-1- 2/1, Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶63

Innamuri Gana Phani Ravi Teja, S/o. I.V.V. Satyanarayana^R/o. 31-12/1, Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶64

...APPELLANT(S)/DEFENDANTS 11 to 13 AND

¶65

¶66

Tummapudi Pitchamma (Died) (Plaintiff No. 1), W/o.^Chinna Hanumanthu Coolie Ploy No. 41 Udumulapadu village and^mandal

¶67

Kurnool District

¶68

Tummapudi Basava Raju (Died), W/o. Vara Prasad R/o. MIG-1, Sector 2, Muvvalavanipalem Colony, Visakhapatna m.

¶69

Tummapudi Nagaratnam,, W/o. Late Jaganmohan Rao,^R/o.D.No.25- 6-2, Vasavi Binni Show Room, Near Big Mosque, Ganjamvari Street, Kakinada. (D-1)

¶70

Tummapudi Seetharamayya,, S/o. Late Jaganmohan Rao, R/o. D.No. 25-6-2, Vasavi Binni Show Room, Near Big Mosque, Ganjamvari Street, Kakinada. (D-2)

¶71

Chedella @ Chedella Sarada,, W/o. Venkata Siva Satyanarayana,^C/o. Chunduri Mallikharjuna Rao, D.No. 31-11-2, Hindu College Road, Machavaram Vijayawada.(D^4)

¶72

Tummapudi Venkateswara Rao (Died), W/o.K.Jagadeeshwar Reddy r/o.2-2-18/18/5/10, Bagh Amberpet, Hyderabad

¶73

Maddu Sri Krishna Veni„ W/o. Girdhara Babu, A.S.R. Electrical School Street, Kotta Bazaar, Chirala.

¶74

Nunna Padmasree,, W/o. N.V. Arya, R/o. 9-20-127, Binny Show Room, Rajahmundry.

¶75

Tummapudi Lalitha,, W/o. Jaya Raj, R/o. S.F.S.70, A.P.H.B. Colony, Lalacheruvu, Rajahmundry.

¶76

10.Tummapudi Parameswari,, W/o. P.V.Prasada rao, R/o. D.No.9-20-127, Main Roada, Binny Show Room, Rajahmundry.

¶77

...RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS

¶78

Counsel for the Appellant(s); SMT NAZREN representing^SRIVSR ANJANEYALU

¶79

Counsel for the Respondents No.3,4: SRI K. SUBRAHMANYAM Counsel for the Respondents No.8 to 10: SRI P. RAJESH BABU Counsel for the Respondents: None Appeared

¶80

AS NO: 776 OF 20131:

¶81

Appeal Under Section 96 of C.P.C. against the Decree and Judgment dt.31-10-2009 made in O.S.No. 22 of 2003, on the file of the Court of the I Additional District Judge, Rajahmundry East Godavari District.

¶82

Between:

¶83

Cheedella Sarada, W/o. Venkata Siva Satyanarayana, Hindu R/o. Chennai Rep.by Power of Attorney Holder Cheedella Koteswara Rao Hindu, aged about 40 years, R/o. Hyderabad.

¶84

...APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF

¶85

AND

¶86

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o. Basava Raju, Hindu Business R/o. D.No. 31-1-2/2, Opp: Ajanta Hotel, Rajahmundry.

¶87

Innamuri Bala Subrahmanyam, S/o. Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, Hindu Student R/o. Rajahmundry.

¶88

Innamuri Gana Phani Teja, S/o. Veera Venkata Satyanarayana,^Hindu Student R/o. Rajahmundry. (R-2 & R-3 are minors rep.by guardian and father 1®‘)

¶89

A.Ashok Reddy, Father's name not known, Hindu Business R/o D.No. 10-7-10, Ground Floor, Rangreejpeta, Rajahmundry.

¶90

Eethakota Parvathi, W/o. Veerabhadra Rao, Hindu R/o D.No. 10-7-10, Rangreejpeta, Rajahmundry.

¶91

Kanecharla Kondamma, W/o. Fancis Paninani, Hindu Housewife R/o 1st Floor, D.No. 10-7-10, Rangreejpeta, Rajahmundry.

¶92

...RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS

¶93

Counsel for the Appellant: SMT NAZREN representing^SRIVSR

¶94

ANJANEYALU

¶95

¶96

Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 3; SRI K. SARVA BHOUMA RAO Counsel for the Respondents: None Appeared

AS NO: 856 OF 2017:

Between:

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o. Basava Raju, R/o. 31-12/1, Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶101

Innamuri Bala Subramanyam, S/o. I.V.V.Satyanarayana, R/o. 31-12/1,Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶102

Innamuri Gana Phani Ravi Teja, S/o. I.V.V.Satyanarayana, R/o. 31-12/1,Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry.

¶103

(RR2 & 3 Appellants declared as majors vide court order dated 06-11-2017 in ASMP No.06-11-2017

¶104

...APPELLANT(S)/DEFENDANTS 1 to 3

¶105

AND

¶106

Chedalla Sarada, W/o. Venkata Siva Satyanarayana,^R/o.C/o.C. Mallikharjuna Rao, 31-11-2, College Road, Machavaram, Vijayawada.

¶107

PLAINTIFF

¶108

A.Ashok Reddy, Business, R/o. Ground Floor, D.No. 10-7-10, Rangreejupeta, Rajahmundry.

¶109

Eethakota Parvathi, W/o. Veerabhadra Rao, R/o. Ground Floor, D.No. 10-7-10, Rangreejupeta, Rajahmundry.

¶110

Kanecharla Kondamma, W/o. Francis Panmani, R/o. First Floor, D.No.

¶111

10-7-10, Rangreejupeta, Rajahmundry.

¶112

...RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS 4 to 6/RESPONDENTS

¶113

Counsel for the Appellant(s):SRI K. SARVA BHOUMA RAO Counsel for the Respondents: None Appeared

¶114

_C MA NO: 190 OF 201.*^!

¶115

Appeal Under Section 384 of Indian Succession Act 1925, against the Order and Decree dt.31-10-2009 passed in O P. No. 1293 of 2002 on the file of the Court of the I Additional District Judge, Rajahmundry, East Godavari District.

¶116

Between:

¶117

Tummapudi Venkata Satyavathi (Died), Rep. by its Asst. General Manager, Guntur, Guntur District.

¶118

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o Basava Raju, Hindu R/o

¶119

31-1-2/1, Jandapanja Road, Rajahmundry

¶120

...APPELLANT(S)/RESPONDENTS 1 & 2

¶121

AND

¶122

Tummapudi Lalitha, W/o Jaya Raj, R/o D.No. 9-20-127,Binny Show Room Main Road, Rajahmundry

¶123

...RESPONDENT/PETITIONER/RESPONDENT

¶124

Counsel for the Appellant(s):SRI K. SARVA BHOUMA RAO Counsel for the Respondent: CH PUSHYAM KIRAN

¶125

CMA NO: 379 OF 2014

¶126

Appeal Under Section 384 of Indian Succession Act 1925, against the Order and Decree dt.31-10-2009 passed in O.P. No. 810 of 2003 on the file of the Court of the I Additional District Judge, Rajahmundry East Godavari District.

¶127

Between:

¶128

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana, S/o. Basava Raju R/o. 31-12/1 Jandapanja Road Rajahmundry

¶129

Innamuri Bala Subramanyam, S/o. I.V.V.Satyanarayana R/o. 31-1-2/1 Jandapanja Road Rajahmundry

¶130

Innamuri Gana Phani Ravi Teja, S/o. I.V.V.Satyanarayana^R/o.31-1-2/1 Jandapanja Road Rajahmundry

¶131

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENTS 1 to 3

¶132

AND

¶133

Chedalla Sarada, W/o. Venkata Siva Satyanarayana^R/o.C/o. C.Mallikharjuna Rao 31-11-2 College Road, Machavaram Vijayawada

¶134

Tummapudi Basava Raju (Died), S/o Sitarami Reddy Postal NSC Agent Manduru Village, Tsundur Mandal, Guntur District.

¶135

Chunduri Hemalatha, W/o. Mallikarjuna Rao D.no. 31-11-2 College road Machavaram Vijayawada

¶136

Nunna Padmasri, W/o. N.V.Arya D.No. 9-20-127 Binny^ShowRoom Main Road., Rajahmundry

¶137

Tummapudi Lalitha, W/o. Jaya Raj D.No. 9-20-127 Binny Show Room Main Road., Rajahmundry

¶138

Tummapudi Parameswari, D/o. Venkateswara Rao D.No. 9-20-127 Binny Show Room Main Road., Rajahmundry

¶139

Lie of India, Rep. by its Divisional Manager At Rajahmundry ...RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS

¶140

Counsel for the Appellant(s):SRI K. SARVA BHOUMA RAO Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI VSR ANJANEYALU

¶141

Counsel for the Respondents No.4,5,6: SRI CH. PUSHYAM KIRAN Counsel for the Respondent No.7: SMT Y. MAHALAKSHMI Counsel for the Respondent No.3: None Appeared

¶142

HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE DR.V R K KRUPA SAGAR

¶143

A.S.Nos.99 of 2011, 512. 776 of 2013. 856 of 2017

¶144

¶145

C.M.A.Nos.190 of 2013 & 379 of 2014

¶146

COMMON JUDGMENT;

¶147

Sri P.Rajesh Babu, learned counsel for the appellants, Sri Nirmal Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Sri K.Sekhar Babu, learned counsel for respondent Nos.34 to 36, Smt.Nazreen, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Sri V.S.R.Anjaneyulu, learned counsel for respondent No. 12 are physically present and Sri K.Sarva Bhouma Rao, learned counsel for respondent Nos.2 to⁴ is present online.

¶148

The family members at dispute are all physically

¶149

present.

¶150

Heard both sides.

¶151

In view of the disposal of A.S.Nos.399 of 2010 and 398 of 2011, these Appeal Suits and Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are dismissed as infructuous. There shall be no order as to costs.

¶152

¶153

As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any,

¶154

shall stand closed.

¶155

SD/- S.V.S.R. MURTHY JOINT REGISTRAR

//TRUE COPY//

To,

SECTION OFFICER

The I Additional District Judge. Rajahmundry, East Godavari District. 2. One CC to SRI. VSR ANJANEYALU. Advocate [OPUC]

¶160

One CC to SRI. K. SUBRAHMANYAM Advocate [OPUC]

¶161

One CC to SRI. P. RAJESH BABU, Advocate [OPUC] 5. One CC to SRI. K SARVA BHOUMA RAO, Advocate [OPUC]

¶162

One CC to SRI. Y. MAHALAKSHMI, Advocate [OPUC]

¶163

One CC to SRI. CH PUSHYAM KIRAN, Advocate [OPUC]

¶164

One CC to SRI. K. SEKHAR BABU, Advocate [OPUC]

¶165

Three C.D.Copies

¶166

¶167

¶168

HIGH COURT DATED:22/12/2023

¶169

COMMON JUDGMENT

¶170

AS.No.99 of 2011,512,776 of 2013,856 of 2017

¶171

¶172

CMA.No.190 of 2013 & 379 of 2014

¶173

5 21 SEP 20?'*
^ , Current Section ^

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana and 2 Others v. Chedalla Sarada and 6 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Innamuri Veera Venkata Satyanarayana and 2 Others v. Chedalla Sarada and 6 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Burakayala Bapanamma Sklm Dist and Another Vs Nookala Kurma Rao Sklm Dist

Smt.Shaik Bhadrunnisa Vs Mr.Ankireddipalli Pedda Obul Reddy

Sri Sai Baba Bhajana Mandiram Committee, Vs Bondada Sri Rama Murthy (died)

Nunna Padmasri and 2 Others Vs Tummapudi Venkata Satyavathi(Died) and 32 Others

Setti Narasamma (Died) Vs Tadimalla Subrahmanya Brahmaji Rao

Smt.Shaik Bhadrunnisa Vs Mr.Ankireddipalli Pedda Obul Reddy