Dismissed¶22

Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home and Another

Allahabad HC13 Jan 2025CRLR/39/2025

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench; Criminal Revision No. 39 of 2025; decided 13.01.2025; Neutral Citation 2025:AHC-LKO:2252; Karunesh Singh Pawar, J.; revision against Sessions Judge Court No. 8 Lucknow order dated 08.10.2024 rejecting discharge application under Section 227 CrPC; trial under Sections 302/364/201 IPC; FIR dated 09.05.2023, incident dated 04.05.2023; last seen evidence; prima facie case; no illegality in impugned order; revision dismissed.

What did the court decide?

During investigation, last seen evidence was found against the revisionist. ¶21

Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya vs State of… — Murder and Culpable Homicide | Allahabad HC (2025)

¶1

Neutral Citation No. - 2025:AHC-LKO:2252

¶2

Court No. - 16

¶3

Case :- CRIMINAL REVISION No. - 39 of 2025 Revisionist :- Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya Opposite Party :- State Of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home And Another Counsel for Revisionist :- Gopesh Tripathi Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.

¶4

Hon'ble Karunesh Singh Pawar,J .

¶5

Heard learned counsel for the revisionist as well as learned AGA for the State.

¶6

Notices to respondent no. 2 are dispensed with in view of the proposed order.

¶7

The present revision has been filed against the judgment and order dated 08.10.2024 passed in sessions No. 2512/2023, "State Vs. Rahul Kumar Maurya", whereby the learned Sessions Judge, Court No. 8, Lucknow, rejected the discharge application filed by the revisionist.

¶8

Perused the record so also the impugned order dated 08.10.2024. The impugned order dated 08.10.2024 is extracted below:-

¶9

" पततवललआजआददशतररपदशहहई।अभभययककदभवदतनअधधवकतएववभवदतनसहतयकधजलतशतसककय अधधवकतककपपवरममसयनतजतचयकतहह। भनसततरणपतररनतपतकतगजसव०बल -1 अवतगरतधतरत -227 दव०प०सव०पतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 अवतगरतधतरत -227 दव०प०सव०पतरर / अभभययकरतहहलकयमतरममयरदतरतपसतयतकरयहकरनभकयतगयतहह भकवतदलदतरतघटनतभदनतवक 04.05. 2023 कदसवदभरममपतरभमककभदनतवक 09.05.2023 ककदजरकरतईगई रल।भदनतवक 09 05.2023 ककवतदलककभपकभनकसपपटकदजवगललमम , रतनतइननदरतनगर , ममलतशपतपहकनद ककसपचनतपतपहहई।

¶10

अभभययकवममतकतकतभववतहएकपदमभववतहरतधजसककममतकतकदपररवतरवतलदसवलकतरकरनदककतहयतर नहहरदऔरउसकदभवरदझपठतमयकदमतदजरकरतयतगयत।भदनतवक 10.05.2023 ककगयमशयदगलककररपकटर धलखतईगईऔरउसलभदनपतररककभगरफततरभकयतगयत , जकयहदभशरतकरततहहभकवहफरतरनहहरत औरनहलइसघटनतममशतभमलरत।उसदउसकदघरसदहलभगरफफफततरभकयतगयतहह।जकपतरभमककभदनतवक 04.05.2023 ककदजरकरतईगईरलउसममजतन - बपझकरममतकतकतमकबतइलनवबरअवभकतनहहभकयतगयत रत।ममतकतकतपवचनतमतभदनतवक 09.05.2023 ककवतदलककउपनसरभतममतहयतरभकयतगयतऔरउसकक वलभडयकगतफकभलककगईहह . जकअभभयकजनकदकरतनकककसवभदगधबनततलहह।भदनतवक 10.05.2023 ककहहए शवभवचछ द नममककईभलएवटलमपटरमइवजरलममतकतकदशरलरपरनहहपतईगईहहतरतशवभवचछ द नररपकटरमम यहदभशरतभकयतगयतहहभकममतकतककममतययकतकतरणअभलभननशचतनहहभकयतजतसकतत।उसकक भगरफफफततरलकदसमययहझपठतदभशरतभकयतगयतहहभकककईजनततकतगवतहनहहरतचपचभकमतमलत पररनसरभतजनयसतकयकतहहऔरपररनसरभतयलकककभड़यतचपपणरनहहहह।शतदलसदसवबवधधतसभलबयभकवगपतरर दतरतहलककगईरल , जकयहदभशरतकरततहहभकपतररउकभववतहसदखयशरत।वतदलकददतरतशतदलकदकतडर ममउसककजतभतककदभशरतनहहभकयतगयतहह , जकयहदशतरततहहभकवहउससदखयशनहहरद।वतदल , ममतकत ककमतततमवजपकशयपवबहनचवचलकदबयतनलममभवरकधतभतसहहतरतउनकदबयतनघटनतसदडदढमतहबतद भदनतवक 19.06.2023 ककदजरभकएगए।पयधलसदतरतभदनतवक 26.06.2023 ककमकभहतकशयप , पप्पपफकशयप वरतजदशकशयपकदबयतनदजरभकएगएधजसमममकभहतकशयपदतरतअपनदबयतनलममयहकहतगयतभक रतजकयमतरई - ररकशतचतलकनदममतकतवपतररककमकटरसतइफभकलसदजततदददखतरतभकनतयपयधलसदतरत

¶11

रतजकयमतरकदबयतनदजरनहहभकएगए।पतररकदपतससदभकसलपकतरककककईबरतमदगलनहहहहईहहतरतन हलउसकतककईआपरतधधकइभतहतसहह।समपपणर कदसफडतयरलममउसकदभवरदऐसतककईसतकयनहहहह धजससदपतररकदभवरदधतरत -302, 364 च 201 भत०दव०सव०कतआरकपभवरभचतभकयतजतसकद।अतत उककदअभतररकअनयआधतरलपरपतरर / अभभययकदतरतउनमकचनपतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 सवलकमत करउसदपसतयतमतमलदसदउनमकभचतभकएजतनदकतअनयरकधभकयतगयत।

¶12

उकउनमकचनपतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 कतभवदतनसहतयकधजलतशतसककयअधधवकतदतरतघकर भवरकधभकयतगयततरतपतररनतपतभनरसतभकएजतनदकतभनव द नभकयत।

¶13

पतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 परभवदतनअधधवकतएववभवदतनसहतयकधजलतशतसककयअधधवकतककसयनत एववपततवललपरउपलबधपपतलकतअवलककनभकयत।

¶14

पततवललकदअवलककनसदयहभवभदतहकततहहभकभववदचनतकददमरतनगवतहलदतरतअवभतमबतरममतकतकक अभभययककदसतरहलददखतगयतरत।सतभकयलदतरतभदनतवक 04.05.2023 ककममतकतककअभभययककक मकटरसतइभकलपरखयररमनगरककतरफजततदहहएददखतगयतरत।सवयवममतफकतदतरतभलअभभयकजनसतभकयल ककफकनपरयहबततयतगयतरतभकवहअभलरतहहलकदसतरबयपटलपतल जतरहलहह।पतरर / अभभययकदतरत उनमकचनपतररनतपतममभकएगएकरनसतकयकतभवषयहह . इससतरपरअभभयकजनसतभकयलकद भवरकधतभतसलकरनलकतपरलकणकरनतयतपररनसरभतजनयसतकयकककड़लकदबतबतभनषकषरददनत नयतयकभचतनहहहह।मतमलदममभववदचनकपरतनतआरकपपतपतरर / अभभययककदभवरदपदभषतभकयतगयतहह धजसपरनयतयतलयदतरतसवजतनधलयतजतचयकतहह।

¶15

पलभवनदरधसवहबनतमबलभवनदरधसवह , 2009 (3) एस०सल०सल० 850 मममतननलयउचचतमनयतयतलयनद यहअभभभनधत र रतभकयतहहभकपयखततसनददहकदआधतरपरभलआरकपतयभकयदजतसकतदहह।इससतरपर सबपतलककजतवचऔरमपलयतवकननहहभकयतजतनतचतभहयद।

¶16

मतननलयसवरचचनयतयतलयदतरततभमलनतडपरतजयबनतमजयलधलतत , एआईआर 2000 सयपलमककटर , 1589 एववभदललरतजयबनतमजतनददवल , एआईआर 2001 सयपलमककटर 40 ममयहअभभमतपकटभकयत गयतहहभकआरकपभवरचनतकदसतरपरकदवलपरमदषयतहलसतकयकतअवलककनभकयतजतएगत।सतकय कतसमपपणर भवशलदषणआरकपभवरचनतकदसतरपरअपदभकतनहहहह।पतरर / अभभययकदतरतपसतयतसतकयकक इससतरपरभवचतरममनहहधलयतजतसकतत।

¶17

अततपतरर / अभभययकरतहहलकयमतरममयतरदतरतपसतयतउनमकचनपतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 भनरसतभकए जतनदयकगयहह।

¶18

आददश

¶19

पतरर / अभभययकरतहहलकयमतरममयतरदतरतपसतयतउनमकचनपतररनतपतकतगजसव० - बल -1 अवतगरतधतरत -227 दव०प०सव०भनरसतभकयतजतततहह।

¶20

पततवललवतसतदआरकपभवरचनभदनतवक 22.11.2024 ककपदशहक।"

¶21

Perused the record as well as the impugned order dated 08.10.2024 shows that during investigation, last seen evidence has been found against the revisionist. Learned trial court has given specific finding at 2-3 instances where the prima facie case against the revisionist is made out. There appears to be no illegality in the impugned order. The trial is under Section 302/364/201 IPC.

¶22

The revision is devoid of merits and is accordingly dismissed .

¶23

Order Date :- 13.1.2025/R.C.

¶24

Digitally signed by :- RAM CHANDER YADAV High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench

Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home and Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home and Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

Amit Kumar Shukla Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. and 4 Others

Sahdeo Singh and 5 Others Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Deptt. of Home Lko. and Another

Girish Chandra Patwa Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko and Another

Ankush Singh @ Lalu Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. and 2 Others

Rahul Kumar @ Rahul Kumar Maurya Vs State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home and Another

Surendra Kumar Maurya Vs the State of U.P. Thru. the Prin. Secy. Deptt. of Home U.P. Lko. and Another