Haining High Court Court granted anticipatory bail to the applicant despite the applicant not being familiar with the specific details of the case statistics, relying on paternal instincts to grant release.
Granted bail to the applicant with liberty to approach the court for quashing of proceedings.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Court No. - 78
Case :- CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. - 4331 of 2023
Applicant :- Sagar Chauhan Opposite Party :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others Counsel for Applicant :- Ashok Kumar Singh,Ankit Singh Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.
Hon'ble Dr. Gautam Chowdhary,J.
वररममनदमणणणकपककररजममनरपमररनमपतआववदक समगरचचहमन ककओरसवमम०अ०स० 162/2022, अनरग धमरम 363, 366, 376 भम०दद०वव०एवदधमरम 3/4 पपकससएकट, रमनमगदजणमणणवमरम, जजलमकमसगदजममजममनरपरममककरनवहवरमपसरमरवकयमगयमहह।
आववदककवववदमनअजधवकमएवदववदमनअपरशमसककयअजधवकमकससमनमररमपतमवलल कमपररशललनवकयम। आववदककवववदमनअजधवकमनवरकरपसरमरवकयमवकआववदककसइसपकररममगलरएवद फजरढदगसवझझठमफदसमयमगयमहह, उसनवकजररअपरमधकमरररनहहवकयमहह।परमसझचनम ररपसटरववलदवबरहह, जजसकमकसईउवचरसपषलकररनहहवदयमगयमहह।ररमकजररघटनमकम कसईसवरदतसमकलनहहहह।आववदकदमरमकजररपलवडरमकवसमरदमरमचमरनहहवकयमगयम औरनहलउसकमवयपहररवकयमगयमहह।कजररपलवडरमकवधमरम 161 दद०प०सद०वधमरम 164 दद०प०सद०कवबयमनममपरसपरववरसधमभमषहह।उनकमयहभलकरनहहवककजरर पलवडरमदमरमअपनवधमरम 164 दद०प०सद०कवबयमनममआववदकपरदमरमचमरकरनवकमकसई आरसपनहहलगमयमगयमहहवकजररपलवडरमकवम व णकलररपसटरममणपकटरदमरमयचनदमरमचमर कवपररपवकयममकसईसपषरमयपकटनहहककगयलहह।" आववदकवनदरषहहररमवहइस पकररममवद० 18.08.2022 सवकमरमगमरममवनरदहह।इसजलएआववदककसजममनरपर छसडवदयमजमय।
ववदमनअपरशमसककयअजधवकमनवआववदककवजममनरकमपबलववरसधकररवहहएरकर पसरमरवकयमवकआववदकदमरम कमरररअपरमधस द जवयएवदगदभलरपककवरकमहह, इसजलए आववदककसजममनरपरनछसडमजमय।
आववदककवववदमनअजधवकमकवरकरदकवपररपवकयममपतमवललपरउपलबधसमरवमनरथयय एवदपररणसरवरययकमसमगरपसवअवलसकनकरनवकवबमद, सबझरयककपककवरऔरवकसलभल ठससववरसधमतमकसममगलककअनमपणसरवरएवदउपलबधसममगलसवछवडछमडककसदभमवनमन हसनवकवरथयकसदवखरवहहएमवरलरमयममआववदककसजममनरपरममककरनवकमउपयमक आधमरहह।
अरतवमदकवगमर-दसषपरवबनमकसईवटपपरलवकएहहएआववदककसउपरसकववर अपरमधमम सदबदजधरनयमयमलयककसदरमवषपरवयवकगरबदध-पतएवदअजधकधनरमवशकवदससरमनलय पवरभझपसरमरकरनवपरवनमनजलजखरशररदकवसमरजममनर परछसडवदयमजमय। 1. आववदकववववचनमयमपरलकरकवदचरमनअवभयसजनसमकययकवसमरछवडछमडनहह करवगम।
उपरसकशररदममसववकसलकवउलदघनकवमममलवमम, परलकरनयमयमलयआववदकककजममनर वनयममनमसमररदकरनवकससवरदतहह।
Order Date :- 4.4.2023 CP.sahani/KC.singh
Digitally signed by :- CHANDRA PRAKASH SAHANI High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
3 issues framed by the court
Whether bail is admissible when the applicant is not familiar with the case facts but the court cites them in its reasoning.
Whether bail can be granted in anticipatory bail application where the applicant does not know the details of the allegations against him.
Whether the lack of knowledge of the case statistics by the applicant precludes the grant of bail.
Sagar Chauhan
State Of U.P.
Dr. Gautam Chowdhary
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
