Criminal bail application where the High Court granted bail to the applicant, Narendra, who was an interim bail recipient in another case, dismissing concerns regarding investigation completeness and prior public announcements.
Bail granted to the applicant Narendra.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:177898
Court No. - 68
Case :- CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. - 40070 of 2023
Applicant :- Narendra Opposite Party :- State of U.P. Counsel for Applicant :- Dharmendra Pratap Singh Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.
Hon'ble Dr. Gautam Chowdhary,J.
1.अधधवककगणआजनयकययकककयरससयवरतहहएववयवदकनअपरशकसककय अधधवककउपसससतहह।
2.वतरमकनदकसणणकपककणरजमकनतपकसरनकपतआवसदकनरसनद ककओरसस मम०अ०स० 70/2022, अनतगरतधकरक 304- बबभक०दव०यव०, सकनकबकबरब, धजलकशकमलबममजमकनतपरममककरनसहसतमपसतमतयकयकगयकहह।
4.आवसदककसपतकवलबकसशपस-पतममतथयउलसधखतयकयकगयकयकआवसदक ककइसपकरणममगलतएववफजरढवगससझझठकफवसकयकगयकहह, उसनसकधसत अपरकधककररतनहहयकयकहह।आवसदक, ममतककककससमरहह।पसमसझचनक ररपकररयवलवयबतहह, धजसककककईसममयचतसपषबकरणनहहयदयकगयकहह।उनकक यहभबकसनहहयकअवरनयकयकलयमममकमलसकससतपरबकणकसददरकन पब०णबलझ०-1, पब०णबलझ०-2, पब०णबलझ०-3, पब०णबलझ०-4, पब०णबलझ०-5 व पब०णबलझ०-6 दकरकअयभयकजनकसकनकककसमसरननहहयकयकगयकएववइनहम पकदकहबघकयषतयकयकगयकहह। धजससससपषहकरहकहहयकआवसदकयनदरषहह तसकवहइसपकरणममयद० 14.06.2022 ससककरकगकरममयनरदहह।इसधलए आवसदकककजमकनतपरछकडयदयकजकय।
5.यवदकनअपरशकसककयअधधवककनसआवसदककसजमकनतककपबलयवरकध करतसहहएतकरपसतमतयकयकयकआवसदकदकरक ककररतअपरकधस व जसयएववगवभबर पकमयतककहह, इसधलएआवसदकककजमकनतपरनछकडकजकय।
6.आवसदककसयवदकनअधधवकककसतकरवकसपररपसकयममपतकवलबपरउपलबध सकरवकनतथययएववपररसससयतययककसमगरपससअवलककनकरनसकसबकद, सबझतयककपकमयतऔरयकसबभबठकसयवरकधकतमकसकमगबककअनमपसससयतएवव उपलबधसकमगबससछसडछकडककसवभकवनकनहकनसकसतथयककदसखतसहहएमसरब रकयममआवसदकककजमकनतपरममककरनसककउपयमकआधकरहह।
उपरककशतरवममससयकसबकसउलवघनकसमकमलसमम, परबकणनयकयकलयआवसदक ककजमकनतयनयमकनमसकररदकरनसककसवतवतहह।
Order Date :- 14.9.2023 CP.sahani
Digitally signed by :- CHANDRA PRAKASH SAHANI High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
3 issues framed by the court
Whether the applicant is entitled to bail under CrPC Section 437/439.
Whether the grant of interim bail in OTP 70/2022 precludes further discretion.
Whether the investigation activities mentioned justify the applicant's detention.
Narendra
Dr. Gautam Chowdhary
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
