The Allahabad High Court dismissed an application under Section 482 CrPC. The applicant sought quashing of proceedings citing a settlement and another Supreme Court judgment distinguishing the present case.
The application was dismissed and the applicant was directed to file a writ petition.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:119451
Court No. - 70
Case :- APPLICATION U/S 482 No. - 20038 of 2023
Applicant :- Satendra Alias Surendra And Another Opposite Party :- State Of U.P.And Another Counsel for Applicant :- Nirbhay Singh Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.
Hon'ble Shekhar Kumar Yadav,J.
1- आववदकगणककओरसवयहआववदनपतअनतगरतधधरध 482 दद०प०सद०, इसआशयसवययजजतककयधगयधहहककवधदसदखयध 3931 वरर 2022, (उतर पदवशरधजयपकतसतयवनदजसदहउररससरवनदजसदहएवदअनय), मस०अ०सद० 287 वरर 2019 अनतगरतधधरध 406, 419, 420 भध०दद०सद०थधनधकधसगदजजजलध कधसगदज जय कवदधन जसकवल नयधयधधधश (सध०कड०)/तवररत नयधयधलय/ए०सध०जव०एम०कधसगदज-पथमकवनयधयधलयममलमममतहह, मम दधजखलआरयपपतकदनधनककत 26.07.2019 कयएवदउकवधदककसमपपणर कधयरवधहधकयकनरसतकरनवहवतसययजजतककयधगयधहह।
2- आववदकगणकवकवदधनअजधवकधएवदरधजयककओरसवकवदधनअपर शधसककयअजधवकधकयससनधएवदपतधवलधकधअवलयकनककयध।
3- आववदकगणकवकवदधनअजधवकधकवतकरदकयससननवएवदपतधवलधकव पररशधलनसव, नयधयधलयनवपधयधककपथमसपचनधररपयररममलगधएगएआरयप एकसदजवयअपरधधकवकमधशनकधखसलधसधकरतवहहऔरवहआरयप, कक गयधकवववचनधकवउपरधनतलगधएगएहह, उनआरयपपकयइसनयधयधलयदधरध धधरध 482 जधनचकव दद०प०सद०कवतहतअपनधशकककधपययगकरतवहहए, ददरधनएकतककगयधसधमगधकवआरयपपककशसदतधऔरकवशवसनधयतधकध आकलनकरनवककआवशयकतधनहहहह, इससतरपरअकभयसककवकववधकदत मयधनपरकवचधरनहहककयधजधसकतधहह।तदन स धरइसपधथरनधपतमम आववदकगणदधरधचधहधगयधअनसतयरपदधनककयधजधनधउकचतपतधतनहह हयतधहह।
4- इससतरपर, आववदकगणकवकवदधनअजधवकधकधअनसरयधहहकक आववदकगणकयअभधतकउपरयकमधमलवममकगरफतधरनहहककयधगयधहह औरपसजलसआववदकगणकयकगरफतधरकरनवकवपयधसममहह, औरसदमदजधत अवरनयधयधलयदधरधआववदककवजखलधरदणडधतमकपककयधजधरधककजध सकतधहह, इसजलएआववदककवजमधनतआववदनपतपरकवचधरकरनवकवजलए सदमदजधतअवरनयधयधलयकयकनदरशजधरधकरकदयधजधए।
5- मधननधयउचचतमनयधयधलयदधरध Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and another ( Special Leave to Appeal Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021 कवपकरणकयआदवशकदनधनक 07.10.2021 दधरधपहलवहधजमधनतहवतसकदशध-कनदरशदवतवहहएकनसतधररत ककयधजधचसकधहह, इसकवपशचधतअमसदमदजधतअवरनयधयधलयकयजमधनत दवनवकवजलएउनकवकवववकऔरकवचधरकयकनयदकततकरनववधलववहधधकनक
पधकवधधनपकयपभधकवतककएकमनध, इसनयधयधलयदधरधकयईकवकशषकनदरश जधरधकरनवककआवशयकतधनहहहह, कयपककयहअपवकधककजधतधहहकक सदमदजधतअवरनयधयधलयआववदकगणकवजमधनतपधथरनधपतकयकनसतधररत करतवसमयमधननधयउचचतमनयधयधलयदधरधपहलवसवजधरधआवशयक कदशध-कनदरशपकयधयधनममरखवगध।
6- उपरयककरपपकणयपकवसधथ, यहआववदनपतअमनतमरपसवकनसतधररत ककयधजधतधहह।
Order Date :- 29.5.2023 Rahul
Digitally signed by :- RAHUL KUMAR High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
2 issues framed by the court
Whether to quash criminal proceedings against the applicant on grounds of settlement and non-charge-sheeting.
Whether the prior Supreme Court decision in Satendra Kumar Antil is applicable to the present facts.
Colour shows how this judgement treated each authority
Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of InvestigationDistinguished¶10
Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and another ( Special Leave to Appeal Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021
1 provisions across 1 enactments
Satendra Alias Surendra And Another
State Of U.P.
Shekhar Kumar Yadav
Rahul Kumar
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
