This application u/s 482 CrPC was disposed of on merits following the precedent in Satendra Kumar Antil. The court directed the opposing party to respond to show-cause for quashing proceedings, noting the existence of related appeal and undertrial detention. Order date is 23.5.2023.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:116347
Court No. - 70
Case :- APPLICATION U/S 482 No. - 1308 of 2021
Applicant :- Dr. Gautendra Singh Opposite Party :- State of U.P. and Another Counsel for Applicant :- Manoj Kumar Srivastava Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.,Dev Prakash Singh,Sanjay Srivastava
Hon'ble Shekhar Kumar Yadav,J.
1- आववदकककओरसवयहआववदनपतअनतररतधधरध 482 दद०प०सद०, इस आशयसवययजजतककयधरयधहहककवधदसदखयध 9786 वरर 2020 (उतरपदवश रधजयबनधमडड०रगतवनदजसदह), मम०अ०सद० 108 वरर 2019 अनतररतधधरध 498-ए, 323, 504, 506 भध०दद०सद०एवदधधरध 3/4 दहवजपकतरवध अजधकनयमथधनधअमररयध, जजलधपपलपभपतजयकवदधननयधकयकमजजसटरटव, पपलपभपतकवनयधयधलयममलममबतहहएवदउकवधदममदधजखलआरयपपत कदनधदककत 22.09.2020 एवदपसदजधनआदवशकदनधनककत 10.10.2020 कयएवद उकवधदककसमपपरर कधयरवधहपकयकनरसतकरनवहवतमययजजतककयधरयधहह।
2- आजआववदककवकवदधनअजधवकधउपमसथतनहहहह।कवपकपकवकवदधन अजधवकधएवदरधजयककओरसवकवदधनअपरशधसककयअजधवकधकयसमनध एवदपतधवलपकधअवलयकनककयध।
3- आदवशकदनधदक 22.01.2021 कवअनमपधलनममवतरमधनमधमलधमधयसथतध कवनदउचचनयधयधलयइलधहधबधदकयसनदकभरतककयधरयधथध, जहधन मधयसथतधअफसलहयरईहह।
4- यकदआववदकररअवरनयधयधलयकवसमकउपमसथतहयकरजमधनतहवतम पधथरनधपतपसतमतकरतवहहतयउनकवजमधनतपधथरनधपतकधकधकनसतधरर मधननपयउचचतमनयधयधलयकव Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and another ( Special Leave to Appeal Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021 कवकदयरएकदशधकनदरशकवअनमसधर कनसतधररतकरम।
5- आववदककव कवदधनअजधवकधकव तकरदकयसमननवएवदपतधवलपकव पररशपलनसव, नयधयधलयनवपधयधककपथमसपचनधररपयटरममलरधएरएआरयप एकसदजवयअपरधधकवकमपशनकधखमलधसधकरतवहहऔरवहआरयप, कक रयपकवववचनधकवउपरधनतलरधएरएहह, उनआरयपपकयइसनयधयधलयदधरध धधरध 482 जधनचकव दद०प०सद०कवतहतअपनपशकककधपययरकरतवहहए, दगरधनएकतककरयपसधमगपकवआरयपपककशमदतधऔरकवशवसनपयतधकध आकलनकरनवककआवशयकतधनहहहह, इससतरपरअकभयमककवकववधकदत बयधनपरकवचधरनहहककयधजधसकतधहह।तदनमसधरइसपधथरनधपतमम आववदकदधरधचधहधरयधअनमतयरपदधनककयधजधनधउकचतपतपतनहहहयतध हह।
6- इससतरपर, आववदककवकवदधनअजधवकधकधअनमरयधहहककआववदक कयअभपतकउपरयकमधमलवममकररफतधरनहहककयधरयधहहऔरपमजलस आववदककयकररफतधरकरनवकवपयधसममहह, औरसदबदजधतअवरनयधयधलय दधरधआववदककवजखलधफदणडधतमकपककयधजधरपककजधसकतपहह, इसजलएआववदककवजमधनतआववदनपतपरकवचधरकरनवकवजलएसदबदजधत अवरनयधयधलयकयकनदरशजधरपकरकदयधजधए।
7- मधननपयउचचतमनयधयधलयदधरध Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and another ( Special Leave to Appeal Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021 कवपकररकयआदवशकदनधनक 07.10.2021 दधरधपहलवहपजमधनतहवतमकदशध-कनदरशदवतवहहएकनसतधररत ककयधजधचमकधहह, इसकवपशचधतअबसदबदजधतअवरनयधयधलयकयजमधनत दवनवकवजलएउनकवकवववकऔरकवचधरकयकनयदकततकरनववधलववहधधकनक पधकवधधनपकयपभधकवतककएकबनध, इसनयधयधलयदधरधकयईकवकशषकनदरश जधरपकरनवककआवशयकतधनहहहह, कयपककयहअपवकधककजधतपहहकक सदबदजधतअवरनयधयधलयआववदककवजमधनतपधथरनधपतकयकनसतधररत करतवसमयमधननपयउचचतमनयधयधलयदधरधपहलवसवजधरपआवशयक कदशध-कनदरशपकयधयधनममरखवरध।
8- उपरयककटपपकरयपकवसधथ, यहआववदनपतअमनतमरपसवकनसतधररत ककयधजधतधहह।
Order Date :- 23.5.2023 Rahul
Digitally signed by :- RAHUL KUMAR High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
1 issue framed by the court
Whether the application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is maintainable given pending related proceedings.
Colour shows how this judgement treated each authority
Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and anotherExplained¶9
Satendra Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and another ( Special Leave to Appeal Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021
Dr. Gautendra Singh
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
